A helter-skelter Congress is frantically putting the ribbons and bows on its Christmas gift to Corporate America: reducing the corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 20 percent.

Republican proponents, who have temporarily suspended their obsession with mounting government budget deficits, won’t tell you that their proposed statutory tax rate of 20 percent mirrors the percentage of taxes that companies currently pay on their profits based on the existing statutory rate of 35 percent.

The statutory rate is what chumps pay — chumps who don’t take advantage of credits, deductions and other loopholes. The tax preferences make it possible for Warren Buffett to pay about 16 percent in taxes on his adjusted gross income. That’s what the world’s second-richest man, under Internal Revenue Service audit at the time, said he paid in 2015. He made the disclosure last fall after failing to convince then-candidate Donald Trump to disclose his tax information.

The statutory tax rate is only a starting point. What really counts is the effective tax rate: the percentage of a business’ profits or a person’s income that is paid in taxes.

Advertise with us

The Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy says the 35 percent rate is a myth. In March, the Washington, D.C., think tank reported that 258 Fortune 500 companies that were profitable in each year from 2008 through 2015 paid an effective tax rate of 21.2 percent.

Moreover, 18 of those companies paid no federal income tax over that period, including General Electric, International Paper and Priceline.com. Another 48 companies paid an effective tax rate of less than 10 percent over the eight years, according to the institute’s report.

If you’re inclined to write off the institute as left-leaning propagandists, consider what the U.S. Treasury, which oversees the IRS, had to say on the topic.

The agency examined the 2007-2011 tax bills of profitable companies with more than $10 million in assets.

It found they paid an average of 22 percent of their profit in taxes. The average tax rate varied widely from industry to industry, with utilities paying 10 percent and service industries paying 28 percent.

Advertise with us

Still not convinced the statutory rate is only for suckers?

This year, the Congressional Budget Office looked at the taxes paid by foreign companies incorporated in the U.S. Including state taxes, their statutory rate is 39.1 percent, not 35 percent. However, their average rate, including state taxes, was 29 percent.

Excluding state taxes, CBO’s average tax rate would be somewhat higher than what the Treasury Department found but still well below the statutory rate.

While many proponents of lower taxes focus on the U.S. having the highest statutory rate in the world, what matters is what you actually pay — not what you theoretically pay. Perhaps that’s why Mr. Buffett told CNBC in an October interview, “We have a lot of businesses ... I don't think any of them are noncompetitive in the world because of the corporate tax rate."

While Congress’ Joint Committee on Taxation, the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, and others have developed models of the impact that tax cuts will have on economic growth and the federal deficit, no one apparently has modeled what tax cuts will do to the average tax rate. Suffice it to say, it will be lower, according to Richard Phillips, a senior policy analyst with the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.

Advertise with us

“We estimate that the current effective corporate federal income tax rate is about 21 percent and that the plan will cut corporate taxes overall by about a quarter,” he said in an email.

Tax cut proponents want us to believe that if only their tax burden is reduced, Corporate America will unleash an avalanche of investments powerful enough to generate sufficient tax revenue to offset the $1 trillion federal revenue shortfall that the heavily pro-business tax proposals are expected to create.

But is the corporate cabal that is currently sitting on robust profits and an estimated $2 trillion in cash, and benefiting from record-low interest rates, capable of changing its ways?

If you believe in trickle-down economics, believing in Santa Claus shouldn’t be too much of a stretch.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.