Lawmakers who promoted the Jumpstart Our Business Startups — or JOBS — Act promised it would spur stock offerings and help companies raise more money.
They were half right. If only Congress could be that effective more often.
Initial public offerings, or IPOs, have increased since 2012, when the law was enacted. However, researchers conclude that provisions of the law that were designed to make it easier for companies to raise capital have significantly crimped the amount of money that IPOs are actually generating.
Why? Because the JOBS Act frees emerging growth companies — companies with less than $1 billion in annual revenue — from disclosing information that similar companies previously had to provide as part of an initial public offering. Lacking that information, investors are forking over less than they did when they had the comfort that more complete disclosure provides.
In investor parlance, it’s called underpricing. In reality, it means companies conducting IPOs are leaving money on the table.
“The percentage of underpricing is statistically and economically very significant,” said Daniel Taylor, who teaches accounting at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School.
Mr. Taylor and two colleagues, Mary Barth of Stanford University and Wayne Landsman of the University of North Carolina, compared emerging growth companies that had IPOs after the law took effect with similar companies that sponsored IPOs before the law was enacted.
The former group of companies collected, on average, about 13 percent less than companies that had to comply with the more robust disclosure requirements before the law was enacted, they found.
Other researchers who conducted a similar study put the underpricing at 11 percent. They also found little evidence that the JOBS Act reduced the costs of going public — something lawgivers pledged it would do.
The lesson, according to Mr. Taylor and other researchers, is that investors value information and not having it prompts them to pay less.
What information aren’t investors getting from these alleged jobs-creating IPOs?
The disclosure provision of the JOBS Act applies to companies that have less than $1 billion in annual revenue that want to sell stock to the public.
It requires them to disclose only two years of financial statements and executive compensation information instead of the three years of data other companies are required to disclose. They only have to report compensation for the top three executives, not the five executives most companies are required to supply. And they are not required to provide any discussion and analysis regarding how their pay plans are structured.
But wait, there’s more.
Emerging growth companies also can delay application of accounting standards, as well as a requirement that auditors evaluate a company’s internal controls. Finally, they get to confidentially file early documents outlining their IPO with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
The confidentiality provision means investors don’t get to see in real time the kind of exchange that occurred when the SEC questioned Groupon’s accounting practices in advance of that company’s $700 million IPO in 2011. Correspondence from the SEC to the companies using the JOBS Act rules isn’t made public until shortly before the IPO, giving investors less time to evaluate the disclosures.
Mr. Taylor and his co-researchers found that most companies take advantage of the confidentiality provision and the looser executive pay disclosure rules. But only 39 percent present less than the standard three years of financial statements and only 18 percent delay adhering to new accounting standards. They said that suggests companies feel disclosing that accounting information has more value than disclosing information about executive pay.
Their study will be published in a forthcoming issue of The Accounting Review, published by the American Accounting Association.
The researchers found that companies compensate for the lack of disclosure by making more disclosures after their IPOs than similar companies did before the law took effect.
The SEC is considering expanding the lighter disclosure requirements to more companies. The theory is that will spur investments, cut IPO costs and create more jobs.
But, as someone who has studied what the JOBS Act has wrought, Mr. Taylor isn’t so sure.
“I would really urge caution about doing that. There isn’t any evidence that the act reduces costs and there is evidence that it increases underpricing and volatility,” he said.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.