Activist shareholder Nelson Peltz has some credible allies in his fight to win a seat on Procter & Gamble’s board — five former H.J. Heinz directors who say Mr. Peltz contributed to the Pittsburgh ketchup maker’s success after winning a 2006 proxy contest.

“Nelson was a valued member of the Heinz board ... [and] was consistently focused on delivering long-term shareholder value,” the five directors wrote in a letter to P&G’s directors.

The former Heinz directors include former U.S. Steel chairman and CEO Thomas Usher and former PPG chairman and CEO Charles Bunch. Heinz was acquired and taken private in 2013, then merged with Kraft Foods in 2015.

Mr. Peltz’s latest effort to improve the performance of a sluggish consumer products company comes to a head Tuesday, when P&G shareholders vote on whether to add him to the company’s board. The foray follows similar efforts at Heinz, where he won two board seats, and at DuPont, where Mr. Peltz failed to win board seats in a 2015 proxy fight.

Advertise with us

The 75-year-old investor also has been active at PepsiCo, Mondelez, Wendy’s, Cadbury Schweppes and other companies.

Mr. Peltz’s Trian Fund Management has a 1.5 percent stake in P&G, making him the Cincinnati-based company’s fifth largest shareholder. He has several beefs with the maker of Crest toothpaste, Bounty paper towels, Herbal Essences shampoo, and a host of other well-known brands.

Mr. Peltz says P&G has underperformed its peers, as well as the S&P 500 over the past decade; lost market share over the past five years and failed to address its high costs and bureaucratic structure. He insists he is not out to oust chairman, president and CEO David Taylor or other directors, break up the company or promote taking on excessive debt.

P&G counters that Mr. Peltz is a wolf, not a sheep. The company says Mr. Peltz’s concerns are being addressed with a $10 billion cost-cutting program and other measures that are starting to bear fruit.

“We are a profoundly different company, much stronger, more profitable company than we were just several years ago. We are better positioned to win,” Mr. Taylor said on a Tuesday call with investors.

Advertise with us

Mr. Taylor also maintained Mr. Peltz’s expertise in food products is not applicable to the products that P&G sells.

“We need to stay focused and balanced, avoid distractions and move forward with a plan that is working,” he said Tuesday.

Three firms that advise pension funds and other large institutional investors on how to vote on proxy matters find Mr. Peltz more persuasive than Mr. Taylor. ISS, Glass Lewis and Egan-Jones all have recommended that P&G shareholders elect Mr. Peltz as a director.

“The addition of one well-qualified nominee, who holds a large economic stake, appears to have benefits that outweigh the potential risks,” ISS told its clients, adding that Mr. Peltz “could help the board look around the next corner and avoid future missteps.”

Glass Lewis told P&G shareholders they “have been afforded ample cause to support Mr. Peltz’s election.” Despite Mr. Taylor’s restructuring, P&G continues to lag peers in short- and medium-term performance, and long-term shareholder returns are even worse, the proxy adviser wrote in its Sept. 21 report.

Advertise with us

“Trian more readily identifies a number of problematic trends ... that suggest P&G’s existing trajectory is less than attractive,” Glass Lewis wrote.

Egan-Jones echoed those thoughts.

“We believe the current board and management failed to maximize the company’s potential as evidenced by critical continuing loss of market share,” the Haverford, Pa., firm wrote.

Despite the impressive list of supporters, Mr. Peltz faces an uphill battle for a board seat, according to Jefferies analyst Kevin Grundy.

That won’t be bad for investors, Mr. Grundy wrote clients last week. While P&G shares may drop if Mr. Peltz is defeated, Mr. Grundy thinks the activist investor will stick around and continue pressuring P&G  management, which will be good for investors in the long run.

Advertise with us

P&G shares have risen about 5 percent since Trian put up Mr. Peltz for a directorship in July. Through Thursday, they were up about 9.5 percent for the year.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263.1941.