Experts say nearly half of American private sector workers do not have access to a retirement plan at their place of employment.

While 401(k) plans are ubiquitous among large employers, they aren’t as widely offered by smaller companies. The biggest reasons: the plans cost too much to operate; companies don’t have the resources to oversee them; and employees aren’t interested in them, according to survey results released by the Pew Charitable Trusts last week.

A handful of states — Pennsylvania is not among them — are addressing two of those reasons. More about the third later.

The states seizing the initiative are setting up low-cost IRA plans that will automatically deduct a percentage of pay from the checks of workers at companies that do not offer a retirement plan. In general, the plans being implemented offer limited investment choices, such as target date funds tied to a worker’s expected retirement date.

Advertise with us

Workers can opt out. If they don’t but don’t tell their employer how much to take out of their paycheck, a default amount — typically 3 percent — will be deducted. Some plans will automatically increase deductions each year up to a certain percentage of pay.

Employers can’t contribute to the state-run plans, under a U.S. Department of Labor ruling in August.

So, other than letting their employees know about the plan and sending payroll deductions where they are supposed to go, there’s not much fuss for employers, according to Karen Friedman, executive director of the Pension Rights Center. The privately funded Washington, D.C., advocacy group promotes retirement security.

Ms. Friedman said California, Connecticut, Maryland, Illinois and Washington are among the states leading the way.

While most experts concerned with retirement security say saving 3 percent of pay is nowhere near enough, Ms. Friedman says it’s a start.

Advertise with us

“We’re really wrestling with a huge problem here,” she said. “We think it’s great that states are experimenting with different ideas.”

Pew found broad support for the state-based plans when it surveyed businesses with between 5 and 250 employees, according to John Scott, director of the trust’s retirement savings project. He said 27 percent of the businesses strongly supported and another 59 percent somewhat supported automatic IRA plans run by states.

“Small business owners are receptive to policy initiatives because they have a problem on their hands. They want to see this problem solved,” Mr. Scott told reporters during a webcast last week.

One potential issue is start-up costs. States sponsoring plans are fronting the costs of getting them off the ground and will have to wait a number of years for contributions to build up. That will allow the plans to become self-sufficient.

Boston College’s Center for Retirement Research estimated it will take Oregon nine years to recover its startup costs and recoup operating losses of its state-run IRA. That forecast is based on setting fees at 1 percent; setting the contribution rate at 5 percent and escalating it to 10 percent; and charging a $35 per-account fee annually.

Advertise with us

Setting the default contribution rate at 3 percent extends the recovery time to 17 years, the researchers estimated.

Pennsylvania has about 2.2 million workers — or 44 percent of the private sector workforce — whose employers do not offer retirement plans, according to Bill Johnston-Walsh, AARP’s state director. The retiree group said the only effort to set up a state-run retirement plan in Pennsylvania was a 2015 proposal by Rep. Michael Driscoll, D-Philadelphia, that called for a feasibility study. His resolution died in a House committee.

Mr. Johnston-Walsh said Philadelphia is looking into offering a city-run plan after the U.S. Department of Labor said in August that large cities in states that do not offer a retirement plan could launch one of their own.

“It’s in the talking stage. It’s in the looking stage, but nothing’s been introduced,” he said.

State-run IRAs address two reasons that small business owners told Pew for not offering retirement plans. Such government-administered plans don’t address the third: lack of interest among workers.

Advertise with us

The availability of a retirement plan won’t help those living paycheck to paycheck, those who can save but don’t, and those who don’t save enough. That’s an issue for another day.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.