The winner of the 2016 presidential race could have a major bearing on the outcome of the trade complaint U.S. Steel filed this week against China’s biggest steel producers in the company’s battle to protect the U.S. industry.
The Pittsburgh steel producer is asking the U.S. International Trade Commission to ban imports of all unfairly traded steel made in China, alleging the Asian giant’s major producers conspired to fix prices, stole trade secrets, and falsely labeled imports to avoid tariffs U.S. regulators had imposed on Chinese steel.
Even if the ITC rules in U.S. Steel’s favor, the agency’s decision could be overturned by the White House.
“It could be the first opportunity for the new president to show whether she [sic] favors a policy of protectionism versus free and open international trade,” University of Missouri law professor Dennis D. Crouch wrote in an email.
Apparent Republican nominee Donald Trump — who two weeks ago promised to bring the steel industry back during a Pittsburgh campaign stop — could support that pledge by upholding a ban on Chinese steel. But even the likely Democratic nominee, Hillary Clinton, would probably support U.S. Steel if the ITC ruled against it, said University of Maryland economist Peter Morici.
“Both Clinton and Trump are more hawkish on trade than [President Barack] Obama,” he said. “In the current climate, both of them would be inclined to support the industry.”
Read More
U.S. Steel filed the case against 11 Chinese steel producers, including six that are among the world’s 10 largest steel producers. The company also accused distributors that the Chinese producers use.
The company alleges they fixed prices by sharing information on costs, production schedules and other matters, and coordinating exports to destroy the U.S. industry. U.S. producers believe China, the world’s largest steel producer, has 425 million tons of excess capacity that is heavily subsidized by the Chinese government.
U.S. Steel also accused the Chinese government of hacking its computers in 2010 and 2011, including a January 2011 attack that stole proprietary information about U.S. Steel’s research on high-strength steels for the automotive industry.
That attack targeted the computer of U.S. Steel researcher Eduardo Silva, according to the complaint filed Tuesday. U.S. Steel said it expects to prove that the Chinese government distributed the stolen information to Chinese steelmakers, who a short time later began selling competing product to the automotive industry.
The 2011 cyber security breach was one incident that resulted in federal prosecutors indicting five members of the Chinese military in 2014 for hacking the computer systems of U.S. Steel, Allegheny Technologies, Westinghouse, Alcoa and the United Steelworkers union.
None of those indicted has been brought to trial.
This week’s complaint accuses Chinese producers and distributors of evading duties the ITC imposed on Chinese imports by shipping steel to Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam and other countries, and then labeling it as if it has originated there instead of in China. The complaint cites a surge of imports from those countries after the ITC had levied duties on Chinese exports of the same products.
The ITC has 30 days whether to initiate a case. If it does, the case could take 15 months or so to decide, according to trade law experts.
U.S. Steel’s complaint was filed under a section of a 1930 trade law that gives the White House 60 days after an ITC decision to overturn it.
The most recent high-profile case under that law involved imports of Apple iPhones and tablets.
The U.S.-based subsidiary of Samsung challenged Apple, saying that company infringed Samsung patents by importing Apple’s Chinese-made products. The ITC ruled in Samsung’s favor. But Michael Froman, President Obama’s U.S. trade representative, overturned the decision, citing among other things the impact that the decision would have on U.S. consumers.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.