After two-plus years of slinging pies, the Pittsburgh Pie Guy has decided to close up shop.

In an email sent to “Friends of Pie” on Wednesday, baker Louis Butler laid out his plans: “The Pie Guy is giving up the pie goose for the indefinite future to travel the world by bicycle. Absurd: yes. True: Also yes.”

It is easy to dismiss the soon-to-be-former Pie Guy as flaky, but Mr. Butler said it was never in the cards to grow the business all that much, for all that long. The venture he founded in 2012 with his business partner Wren McGalliard was entirely mobile, and had reached a point many small businesses do: It either had to get much bigger to accommodate growth, or close.

They chose the latter.

Advertise with us

“That’s exactly what it was. We were just getting bigger than we wanted to — too inefficient,” he said.

It will be a relatively easy shutdown, since Pittsburgh Pie Guy had only its founders as employees.

Mr. Butler said the two toyed with the idea of a brick-and-mortar location, but decided it wasn’t for them. “We could have gone out and raised capital and gotten a storefront,” Mr. Butler said. “But having a business is too stressful, and getting bigger wasn’t what we really wanted.”

The Pie Guy journey began in a Duquesne University philosophy class in 2008, where the two founders shared a vision of running “some kind of food business,” Mr. McGalliard told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last year.

Asked Wednesday if there were anything that could have kept Pittsburgh Pie Guy going, or any aspect of running a business in this region that motivated them to close, Mr. Butler said no.

Advertise with us

“The environment for this kind of business in Pittsburgh couldn’t be better right now, really,” he said. “We had a lot of fun, made a lot of great connections and have this huge network here.”

Mr. Butler plans to take himself and his bicycle and explore the East Coast and Canada as well as other parts of the United States. He does not have a formal plan or any savings for his trip, but is confident he will be able to make his way just fine.

“I totally believe in the power of relying on your own resources, and the power of humanity.”

He plans to blog about his adventures, but hasn’t set up a formal site yet. The recipes for his pies are likely to make their way online at some point as well, once the Pie Guy is all done.

And fear not, Friends of Pie, there will be one last hurrah. Mr. Butler plans to bake a last batch for Thanksgiving orders, which will include apple, pecan, chocolate pecan and pumpkin. Orders must be placed by phone (724-355-9126) by Nov. 23 for pickup on Nov. 26 at Zeke’s Coffee in East Liberty.