When it comes to collecting Social Security, the conventional wisdom is clear:
Wait. The longer you delay claiming Social Security, the larger your monthly check will be.
While that’s true, it’s not the whole story. Financial advisers say there are some good reasons starting benefits at 62 can be a smart move.
“Obviously, this is a very important decision for our clients,” said David Root Jr., CEO of DBR & Co., Downtown. “It’s a calculation that’s frequently emotional and fraught with both short- and long-term consequences.”
Deciding when to claim Social Security is a financial choice in which deeply personal factors collide with hard numbers.
A worker who claims benefits at 62 — the earliest possible age — takes a roughly 30% permanent reduction in monthly income compared to waiting until full retirement age, which is 67 for people born in 1960 or later. Those willing and able to hold out until age 70 get a boost of about 8% a year for delaying.
Read More
But life is unpredictable.
Some people may simply need the income earlier. Low cash flow, rising bills and groceries, or a layoff late in life — especially where age discrimination is involved — can turn Social Security into a lifeline rather than a far-off retirement strategy.
For someone facing an employment crisis or an income shortage, the smaller monthly check at 62 is still better than draining savings or piling up debt.
“If you are laid off and cannot find comparable work, Social Security can provide a crucial income floor and may be worth claiming earlier, especially if you would otherwise draw heavily from savings or take on high-interest debt,” Mr. Root said.
“It matters a lot if you are laid off or underemployed,” he said. “But you still have to weigh permanent benefit cuts, earnings-test rules and your long-term safety net against your level of personal savings and life expectancy.”
Health is another critical factor, often a deciding one.
“Tell me when you’re going to pass away, and I’ll know exactly when you should start receiving benefits,” said Victor Conrad, owner of Pinnacle Financial Strategies in Pine.
He said the breakeven age — the point at which waiting to full retirement age to collect yields more total money than people who collected earlier — typically falls between age 82 and 83. So delaying only pays off for those who expect to live well past that.
For workers facing chronic illness or with a family history of shorter lifespans, claiming at 62 makes perfect sense as a practical way to collect as many checks as possible during their lifespan.
“Again, the breakeven is about age 82 to 83, so make an educated guess,” Mr. Conrad said. “I know this sounds morbid, but if that milestone doesn’t seem to be in reach, claiming early could be the best option.”
Situations for early claiming
A financial setback — being laid off, downsized or stuck in a string of low-wage, part-time jobs — can nudge people toward claiming early as well.
In those situations, Social Security can feel like the only steady income they can count on. But financial advisers warn that hardship today doesn’t always justify a permanent decision that will follow a person for the rest of their life.
If someone claims early and then goes back to work before reaching full retirement age, their earnings can trigger a reduction in benefits. And the bar isn’t high. Earn more than roughly $23,000, and Social Security starts withholding some of the monthly check.
“So you want to be very, very careful to determine if your current working or income situation is temporary or permanent before starting benefits,” Mr. Conrad said.
“You’ll be in for a rude surprise if you end up getting another job or become fully employed, and your earned income rises significantly and all of a sudden your Social Security check is significantly less,” he said.
The silver lining is that the money isn’t gone forever. Those withheld benefits are credited back once a person reaches full retirement age. But the sudden drop in income can catch people off guard.
That’s why advisers recommend running a breakeven analysis — a simple but powerful comparison of total benefits collected if you claim at 62, 67 or 70. The math helps anchor the decision in reality. At what age does delaying begin to pay off?
But the numbers are just a starting point. There’s a lot more to consider.
“Beyond the math, risk tolerance matters,” Mr. Root said. “Some prefer the certainty of getting money sooner, while others value the insurance of a larger, lifelong inflation-adjusted income stream.”
The spousal benefit
If deciding when to claim Social Security is tricky for individuals, couples have to consider their spouses — not just themselves — to get the most out of Social Security.
Coordinating the timing — especially when one spouse has a much higher earnings record — could mean thousands of dollars more over a lifetime and more security for the surviving spouse down the road.
Mr. Conrad said the classic approach works like this: If both spouses are roughly the same age, the lower-benefit spouse often starts collecting earlier — not necessarily at 62, but earlier. Meanwhile, the higher-benefit spouse keeps working and delays their claim, allowing their eventual monthly check to grow — sometimes dramatically — by waiting until 65, 67 or even 70.
This strategy isn’t just about maximizing one person’s check, it’s about protecting the household over the long haul.
“One very important note to understand is, the lower-benefit spouse, if their benefit based on their earnings is less than 50% of the higher-benefit spouse, the lower-benefit spouse is entitled to receive an amount that is at least 50% of the higher-benefit spouse,” Mr. Conrad said.
“But the lower-benefit spouse will only receive this 50% amount if and when the higher-benefit spouse is also collecting their benefit,” he said.
He used an example: Suppose the lower-benefit spouse claims early at age 62 and receives $675 a month based on their own work record. Years later, the higher-benefit spouse begins claiming at 67 with a $3,500 monthly benefit. At that point, Social Security recalculates the lower-benefit spouse’s payment and bumps it up because they now qualify for a spousal benefit.
But here’s the catch:
“It will not be 50% of the $3,500,” Mr. Conrad said. “It will be something less than $1,750 because they have been receiving the $675 a month for several years.
“The calculation is a bit messy,” he said.
“The point is, don’t assume and plan on getting $1,750 a month when the high-benefit spouse starts to collect. But the amount will increase significantly from $675 a month.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.