With the rapid evolution of technology over the past decade, cameras are recording us wherever we are whether we like it or not; arguably invading our right to privacy, however you define it.

Millions of us have a camera on our phones. When you use an automatic bank teller machine, order fast food at a drive-thru, enter just about any business, ride in an Uber, ring someone’s doorbell or happen to be pulled over by a police officer — smile, you’re on camera.

We all go about our lives accepting these random monitoring episodes as we navigate our lives. A more specific surveillance that is commonplace is that of a parent monitoring a child.

When we raised our kids, the radio baby monitor sometimes would pick up the ballgame on AM radio, but it served its purpose. Now, it’s very common to observe a child through video and audio monitoring (even from miles away instead of the next room).

Advertise with us

This then extends to the “Nanny Cams” so parents can check in on their children even when being watched by a seemingly qualified and responsible adult.

Going one step further now involves the so-called “Granny Cams” to address basically the same need — video and sometimes audio monitoring of another person who may not be able to speak for themselves. This time it’s Grandma (or Grandpa).

Monitoring your infant in your own home is one thing. Monitoring an elderly family member in a setting that includes a variety of other people’s activities is a different story — or is it?

There are many legal and ethical issues involved in the latter. This setting is most commonly some type of nursing home or long-term care facility for residents with dementia. And there are legitimate arguments for and against the installation of a video camera in a resident’s room.

From the resident’s perspective, this type of monitoring increases the evidence in the event there is abuse. In addition, the staff’s awareness of video monitoring may act as a deterrent to such abuse.

Advertise with us

Absent abuse, a care facility may argue that this micro-management of the resident’s daily routine can lead to unfounded complaints. Let’s face it, a resident in a long-term care facility is not always monitored individually (one-on-one) because of staffing plus cost issues. Therefore, a family member may not agree with the way care is being administered and complain that a loved one for safety reasons is not receiving the attention that is needed.

This is a matter of what is reasonable to expect for a resident in a long-term care facility. If you haven’t ever been in one, you might want to visit one to become familiar with the difficulties that nursing homes face in delivering quality care, or quality as defined in the eyes of a resident’s family members.

Turning to the legalities of such monitoring, many states’ laws allow someone to have video monitoring in and about their homes. The courts have consistently upheld the right to privacy in one’s home. The argument on behalf of the resident hangs on the notion that the room being rented in a nursing home is now that person’s home and he/she should have the same right to privacy, including monitoring, regardless of the setting that person calls home.

Like many states, Pennsylvania is once again pondering whether statutory guidance is necessary to authorize the placement of video monitors in a resident’s room.

Eventually, whether through an act of our General Assembly or the courts, there will be a resolution of this matter. And given the unstoppable progression of technology, it is likely that with the appropriate parameters in place, video monitors inside a resident’s room will become just as common as the video monitors that already exist when you walk in the lobby of the nursing home to visit your loved one.

Julian Gray and Frank Petrich are both Certified Elder Law Attorneys with over 70 years of combined elder law experience who practice in the Pittsburgh area at Julian Gray Associates. Send questions for consideration in this column to elderlawguys@grayelderlaw.com and visit their web site at www.grayelderlaw.com.