It’s the age-old question, but many people — including professionals who deal with people involved in these programs — often confuse Medicare and Medicaid.
Since our country spends billions of our tax dollars on these programs each year and they affect so many people, young and old, we thought it was a good time to set the record straight. While few are discussing these programs at cocktail parties or winning “Trivial Pursuit” (remember that?) with the correct answer, it is very important to realize how both Medicare and Medicaid programs can touch our lives and provide a significant benefit to the quality of life, especially with the DOGE movement at the federal level.
First, a little history. In 1965, President Lyndon Johnson signed into law a bill that led to the creation of the Medicare and Medicaid programs. While both programs are administered by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), they are very different in how they are administered and what they cover.
While these two programs are separate, many people may qualify for both. Whether you can qualify for either or both programs depends on many factors. Let’s examine the basic parameters.
Medicare
The original Medicare program was meant to provide health insurance coverage to people when they turned 65. The program is broken down into Part A (hospital coverage) and Part B (medical insurance/doctor services). Shortly after Medicare was created, it was expanded to include coverage for people who were disabled prior to age 65 and people with end-stage renal disease requiring dialysis or a kidney transplant.
In summary, traditional Medicare is thought of as the health insurance you deserve at retirement age for paying into the “system” over many years. There are now many variations on this program through what are known as Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage plans.
Read More
Medicaid
Initially, Medicaid was a welfare program offering medical insurance to people getting cash assistance. However, Medicaid has greatly expanded to cover:
- Low-income families.
- Pregnant women.
- People of all ages with a disability.
- Long-term care.
In Pennsylvania, the Medicaid program is referred to as Medical Assistance and is administered by the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services (formerly the Department of Public Welfare). This means that unlike Medicare, which is run solely by the federal government, Medicaid is funded by both state and federal dollars (in some states the federal government is paying as much as 80% of the cost), but the state Medicaid agency is free to implement its own rules subject to the federal laws.
Unfortunately, many people still consider Medicaid to be a program to provide health care to poor people. This is a very limited view. While many Medicaid programs do have certain financial testing, the nature of the need for care is the primary determination of eligibility.
The last item above, involving long-term care is particularly important.
Many people require long-term care around the clock at home or in a nursing facility. This care is very labor intensive and unaffordable (an average of $146,000 a year in Pennsylvania) for the majority of citizens, so Medicaid pays as much as 70% of the costs of long-term care. Medicaid pays for a lot more than just nursing care, but as the large baby boomers cohort ages more funding will be needed.
According to the Pennsylvania Treasury, of the $30 billion annual budget, the Department of Human Services consumes almost $14 billion, followed by the Department of Education at about $9.5 billion. Everything after that is a distant “second” through the rest of the 42 departments that must divide up the remaining $6.5 billion to make ends meet.
We haven’t even mentioned the cost of Medicare.
The important thing to remember is that Medicare and Medicaid, while with very similar sounding names, are two very different programs.
They each have their own qualification factors, and many people qualify for one or both programs at different times in their lives. Whether you are reaching retirement age or have a permanent disability at any age, getting accurate information on how either or both of these programs can help you can result in a much higher quality of life.
Julian Gray and Frank Petrich are both Certified Elder Law Attorneys with over 65 years of combined elder law experience who practice in the Pittsburgh area at Julian Gray Associates. Send questions for consideration in this column to elderlawguys@grayelderlaw.com and visit their web site at www.grayelderlaw.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.