This past weekend, some prospective homebuyers may have found themselves doing something a bit unusual — signing contracts right on the front porch of homes they wanted to tour.
Why?
Because in the new world of real estate — which started on Aug. 17 — agents representing home buyers can’t even turn the key to let buyers inside without a signed agreement from the buyer in hand.
“We are strongly suggesting that agents meet consumers in the office prior to working with them,” said John Petrack, vice president of the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh.
However, if the initial meeting occurs at the house, he said, “it’s important consumers know that agents have to have some kind of agreement signed before they open the door to show them a house.”
The real estate industry is adapting to a whole new way of doing business on the heels of a massive class action settlement by the National Association of Realtors.
Read More
The lawsuit stems from a group of homeowners in Missouri taking on the real estate industry and winning a landmark class action ruling in April, which found the industry had conspired to keep commissions high and force sellers to pay for the buyer’s agent commission.
As a result of the settlement, home sellers are no longer footing the bill for both real estate agents in the transaction. From now on, sellers only pay a commission to the listing agent, which is subtracted from the proceeds of the sale. Buyers pay their own agent separately out of pocket.
In the new system, buyer’s agents no longer have an automatic guarantee of getting compensated for their services without a signed agreement from the home buyer.
The West Penn Multi-List service that agents in this market operate under took steps to delete the “buyers agent commission” field from its system a week before the ruling took effect.
“Where we’re at is a very interesting place, because we’re not in a place where history has any guide,” said Mike Netzel, a team leader at Keller Williams Real Estate in Pine.
The new rules require changes in agent practices which may confuse consumers. That’s why the local real estate agent trade organization RAMP produced a video for its website to educate the public about agency agreements and agent fees, Mr. Petrack said.
The wording in contracts could be different from one real estate company to another. Companies also will offer different agreements that could range from buyers, for example, paying $500 a month for agents to show homes to a buyer, to paying a negotiated 2.5% of a home’s sale price.
While the whole idea behind the Missouri lawsuit and ruling was to empower homebuyers and sellers to negotiate lower fees and lower their home buying cost, there might be some unintended consequences, agents say.
“This is a very big windfall for sellers,” said Charlene Haislip, an agent at ReMax Realty Brokers in Squirrel Hill.
“My seller is going to list his house tomorrow for $500,000,” she said. “A month ago, he would have listed his house for $500,000. What’s the difference today? Today he doesn’t have to pay a buyers’ broker commission.”
On the other hand, home buyers could end up paying their agent’s commission twice under the new rules, she said.
Although the sales commissions are usually already baked into the sales price, buyers will have to come to the closing table with thousands of dollars in cash to pay their agent on top of the typical closing costs — down payment, transfer taxes, title insurance — not to mention the cost of a home inspection.
“That’s the kind of hardship buyers have now with this ruling,” Ms. Haislip said. “This has harmed buyers, especially first-time buyers that don’t have a lot of cash on-hand.”
Many agents will try to preserve the old system of getting sellers to compensate buyers agents from the sale proceeds in order to maintain the 5% to 6% overall commissions, according to the Consumer Federation of America in Washington.
“The ruling didn’t say the seller can’t pay the buyers’ agent commission,” Ms. Haislip said. “The ruling didn’t say the seller couldn’t advertise that they were going to pay. The ruling just says you couldn’t do that in the Multi-List Service.”
She said she is focused on negotiating sales contracts so that sellers still pay the buyers agent commission.
“I want it wrapped up like it was in the sales price so that my buyer doesn’t have to come up with thousands of dollars in extra cash at the closing,” Ms. Haislip said.
Open houses exception
Signed contracts with specific terms of payment will be an essential document binding buyers and buyers’ agents when it comes to home tours, going forward.
The only exception are open houses.
“Consumers don’t have to worry about some agent pressuring them to sign a contract of any sort if they want to go walk through an open house,” Mr. Petrack said.
Home shoppers have the option of entering an agreement with agents hosting open houses, but they don’t need to obligate themselves to the agent in order to tour an open house, Mr. Petrack said.
But if someone is already under agreement with another agent while touring an open house, they should notify the hosting agent right away, he said, to avoid “any confusion relative to protocol with the particular company hosting the open houses.”
Business conditions were already challenging for real estate agents before they got hit with a new normal.
Home sales have slowed considerably as interest rates rose from around 3% in recent years to about 7%. The inventory of homes available also has been falling as homeowners are reluctant to list their homes and give up their low mortgage rates.
Industry experts have predicted that a wave of agents could leave the real estate business. In Pittsburgh, according to RAMP membership numbers, the organization today has more than 3,300 members after seeing a drop of 2.6%, Mr. Petrack said.
“Where I’ve noticed a drop off in membership is what we call our life members,” he said. “People who have been members for over 20 to 25 years who say ‘I’ve had enough fun for one career’, and hang up their shingle.
“For the most part, membership has really stayed where it was,” Mr. Petrack said. “The change has been nominal.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.