The ironclad 6% real estate commission is headed for the scrap yard now that home buyers and sellers will be able to negotiate how much they pay real estate agents.
The National Association of Realtors on Friday agreed to pay $418 million to settle a nationwide claim that the industry conspired to keep commissions high and force home sellers to pay for the buyer’s agent commission.
For decades, the standard 6% commission was split between the buyer and seller agent at 3% each.
As part of the settlement, the NAR agreed to abandon the longstanding industry practice that tied the buyer and seller commissions together in favor of a new system that allows both to negotiate their commission separately.
“This settlement over time will benefit home sellers and buyers greatly, eventually lowering agent commissions by tens of billions of dollars a year,” said Stephen Brobeck, senior fellow at the Consumer Federation of America in Washington, D.C.
The changes NAR agreed to theoretically take effect in July, pending the acceptance of the settlement by a federal court.
Read More
The real estate industry was turned upside down in October 2023 when a Kansas City jury handed down a $1.8 billion anti-trust verdict against NAR and other national brokerages. The jury determined that the industry practice for how buyers’ agents were paid kept commissions artificially high.
NAR’s $418 million settlement — which will be paid to home sellers — will cancel the $1.8 billion verdict against NAR and all the other brokerages that were named except for Berkshire Hathaway’s HomeServices, which has not settled yet.
As if it wasn’t already hard enough to earn a living selling real estate, more agents are expected to exit the industry as a result of commission rates going down.
NAR currently has 1.5 million real estate agents, a near record high number.
Locally, the West Penn Multi-List has about 8,280 licensed real estate agents listed as members. That compares to 25,948 transactions in the 17 counties in 2023 — roughly three home sales per agent.
John Petrack, vice president of the Realtor’s Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, said first-time buyers and low-income people who can’t afford to pay for their own agent in a real estate transaction will suffer.
“It’s common knowledge that down payment and closing costs are the toughest thing for a first-time buyer,” Mr. Petrack said. “When you raise the cost of buying a house you reduce the number of buyers in the marketplace, which eventually hurts the seller.”
But the settlement still leaves the traditional way of compensating a buyer’s agent as an option for the seller. Homebuyers will still be able to request a concession from sellers that includes funds to help cover buyer agent compensation.
“But this will be after they have had the opportunity to comparison-shop and negotiate buyer rates,” Mr. Brobeck said. “The settlement will also encourage more sellers to negotiate the compensation of their listing agents.”
Commissions, in general, are expected to come down, according to consumer activists.
The lawyer who initiated the court cases that led to the $1.8 billion verdict, Douglas Miller of AttorneyRE in Excelsior, Minn., said the NAR settlement will bring free market forces into the real estate industry.
“The real estate industry has been more of a socialized platform than anything close to being capitalistic or competitive,” Mr. Miller said.
He explained that someone in Minnesota with a kindergarten education and 30 hours of training can compete with attorneys for real estate business, and they are both paid the same commission.
“So it’s socialized real estate, and that commission amount is artificially inflated,” he said. “Most buyers find the house they want to buy on their own without a realtor. Realtors are trying to defend that they have this wonderful value proposition.”
Mr. Miller said he’s not advising buyers to negotiate real estate deals on their own. But he suggests there are less expensive options.
“Hiring a lawyer for maybe $1,500 is a lot less money than $10,000 or $50,000, depending on who you are or what the value of the property is.”
Buyers have always been able to buy a home without an agent. But in those cases, the seller’s agent collects the entire 6% commission. Sellers also will no longer foot the whole 6% bill. The NAR settlement will end that system.
“Now buyers have a choice,” Mr. Miller said. “If they don’t hire a broker or an attorney they can do it themselves and save a lot of money. That was not the case before.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.