Tim Gasper has been getting the sideways look from some customers at Werner Jewelry in Ross.
“People look at me like I’m overcharging,” he said. “My joke I always tell them is to try filling your gas tank for $12 like we used to.”
John Henne, owner of Henne Jewelers in Shadyside, also is raising prices. He just sold a $25,000 gold necklace that’s been in the store for six months. The new one is priced at $28,000 due to his higher cost.
“We’re seeing replacement costs go up on merchandise,” Mr. Henne said. “But it hasn’t hurt demand at all. We’re having record sales.”
With the spot price of gold recently hitting a new record high, the jewelry industry finds itself in the throes of a modern-day gold rush.
Jewelry dealers who cater to the wealthy are posting record sales this year because well-off customers still want to wear gold no matter what it costs. Even regular folks cleaning out their old jewelry boxes are finding their forgotten trinkets are worth a small fortune on the resale market.
Read More
On the other hand, jewelry dealers who serve the middle market are feeling the pinch of fewer sales as gold prices move higher.
“The middle income guy who makes between $30,000 and $100,000 a year — that middle income guy is lost in our industry right now,” said Anthony Mock, owner of Mock & Co. Diamonds in Monroeville.
Yet, it’s not just the sky-high price of gold causing headaches in the jewelry industry.
The once-lucrative lab-grown diamond market has lost a lot of its luster in recent months. Dealers who paid $2,000 a carat for lab-grown diamonds a year and a half ago have seen the price nose dive to $100 a carat, according to local dealers.
It’s even worse for consumers who, say, break off engagements and try to cash-in lab-grown diamonds, only to find the stones are worth much less today than when they purchased them.
At least their gold bands still hold value.
According to Mr. Henne — who also is a Rolex dealer — the record high gold price is not necessarily a bad thing because it helps to reaffirm gold as a symbol of wealth and an object of fascination.
“Yellow gold is so popular right now in jewelry trends,” Mr. Henne said. “In some ways the price going up is helpful in that people understand and are reminded of how precious it is and the value it has.”
High value for scrap gold
Gold is shining brighter than ever in the public eye since recently hitting a record high of more than $2,400 an ounce.
The asset was already on the rise when it garnered more headlines with the bribery indictment of Sen. Bob Menendez, D-New Jersey. A whole news cycle was devoted to reports that authorities seized a hoard of gold bars from his New Jersey home.
Gold investments have also recently made a big splash in the mainstream as more individuals are buying gold to diversify their assets against inflation and hedge geo-political risk.
Even Costco is getting in on the action — selling gold bars along with bulk toilet paper to everyday families.
But for many consumers, gold is still best known for its use in jewelry as a symbol of power and wealth.
Yellow gold happens to be the popular trend in jewelry right now, and size definitely matters when it comes to price since gold is sold by weight.
“You get some customers who just have money and they don’t care. They still want the big, heavy, chunky gold pieces,” said Stacey Brooks, owner of Brooks Diamonds in the Clark Building, Downtown. “But most of the time, people are looking for smaller, delicate pieces.”
She said foot traffic has slowed in Pittsburgh’s high-rise jewelry district since the pandemic left fewer people working Downtown. But her business picks up on the weekends, especially when sporting events and festivals take place.
The Clark Building still pulls customers from all around the region, she said, due to its long reputation for selling engagement rings to generations of Pittsburghers.
People aren’t just coming in to buy gold, either, she said. They’re selling, too.
“They’re getting high value for scrap gold,” Ms. Brooks said. “They’re able to scrap old jewelry and get more than what they bought it for 20 years ago.”
Ms. Brooks said she’s selling more yellow gold than white gold or silver right now. She said the bread and butter items of the jewelry industry continue to be engagement rings, earrings and diamond tennis bracelets.
But it’s the price tags on gold items that’s mostly causing heads to turn.
For example, the cost of a gold rope-style chain at Werner Jewelry has jumped from around $800 not too long ago to close to $2,000 today because of rising gold prices, Mr. Gasper said He adjusts his stock prices on gold items every time gold moves about $400 or $500. His last price adjustment was at around the $1,800 an ounce level, he said.
“We’re definitely still selling stuff, but no one wants to buy like a nice gold chain for themselves like they used to,” Mr. Gasper said.
The problem with lab-grown diamonds
People aren’t buying engagement rings and bridals either like they used to, and Mr. Mock is starting to get worried about the holiday season at his Monroeville shop.
“Pre-COVID, we were selling between 10 to 12 engagement rings per week,” Mr. Mock, 42, said. “That’s [less than] half now. We do maybe three to four per week.”

The core of his business is the middle-income customer who is usually torn between spending $10,000 for a natural diamond or paying $1,000 for a laboratory-grown diamond the same size, quality and look.
“They either want something with value, or they want something that just sparkles,” he said.
As a general rule, man-made diamonds on average currently sell for about 10% of the cost of natural diamonds, according to Diamond Hedge, a diamond search marketplace.
While natural diamonds retain most of their value, the problem with lab-grown diamonds is they have little resale value on the secondary market. Even wholesalers of lab-grown diamonds have seen the values crash over the past year and a half due to over-production.
“I personally know a couple of companies that bought $1 million worth of these stones,” Mr. Mock said. “They’ve got all these stones they bought for $2,000 a carat now worth only $100 a carat.”
Middle market independent jewelers like Mr. Mock are most affected by the lab-grown diamond industry. Mom and pop jewelers have little choice but to deal in man-made diamonds simply because natural diamond prices are often way too high for their customers.
Jewelry dealers who carry luxury brands like David Yurman, Rolex, Roberto Coin or Brietling cater mostly to customers earning at least $200,000 per year and they mostly stock natural diamonds in their stores, he said.
Shoppers on a budget can more often find themselves priced out of buying natural diamonds at jewelry shops that cater to high-income buyers.
“Whereas these shops would normally try to sell a lot of 1-carat, 1.5-carat and 2-carat diamonds, they are going after the people who are buying 3-carat or 4-carat stones,” Mr. Mock said, adding that high-end jewelry stores often limit their stock of smaller carat natural stones.
“They are going for people with money,” he said. “Their attitude is they aren’t chasing the nickel-and-dime sales. They want to go as high as they can get and sell to the rich.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.