More consumers with damaged credit are turning to credit-building services to raise their scores.
“Generally speaking, credit-building services are a good way for consumers to establish or improve their credit ratings,” said Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, a personal finance author and coach.
While the industry that has sprung up around helping people improve their credit has exploded in recent years, they don’t all play by the same rules, according to a recent survey of the leading credit-building services.
Some companies in this space seem to operate more like debit cards than credit cards; others will only report positive information to the credit bureaus.
Experian Boost offers to improve your FICO Score by giving you credit for making “on-time” utility, telephone and rent payments, with the promise that late payments won’t get counted against you. Credit Karma opens a line of credit for $1,000 to help consumers build credit, but only for the sake of appearance because the company’s website explains that you’re not allowed to spend the money.
The $1,000 credit line “increases your overall credit limit, [and] gives you lower overall credit utilization,” according to Credit Karma.
Read More
According to the 2024 Credit Builder Study — released by personal finance website WalletHub, which evaluated 22 of the most popular credit-building products — 27% of major credit-building services do not provide an actual loan or line of credit that gives customers access to usable funds; 23% never report negative information to credit bureaus; and 27% improve a user’s credit utilization rate by reporting an inflated credit limit to bureaus.
“What a bunch of them do is they take a debit card, essentially, and make it look like it’s a credit card on the credit report,” said Odysseas Papadimitriou, CEO of WalletHub. “And imagine a world where everyone can report only the positives and not the negatives. Lenders will not be able to tell who to lend money to.”
Devil in the details
As with many aspects of credit reporting, the devil is in the details, according to Chi Chi Wu, a senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center in Boston.
“Some ways of building credit are more effective than others,” Ms. Wu said.
Her organization focuses on consumer law and low-income consumers. She is particularly concerned about the rise in landlords reporting rent payments to credit bureaus.
“If you do it the wrong way you could end up hurting vulnerable renters,” she said.
For example, if a landlord requires everyone to have their rent payments reported to the credit bureau, people who want to buy a house will see it as an opportunity to establish a good credit record. But the policy could hurt renters who miss payments, she said.
“If they are not interested in credit building, those missed payments may show up on their credit report and a future landlord might see it, and it hurts their chances of getting a new apartment,” she said. Rent reporting should only be done with the consumer’s consent, she said.
“The problem with missed payments is that it doesn’t just count for credit purposes,” Ms. Wu said. “You could make it very hard for someone to find new rental housing with rent reporting.”
Certain types of credit-building products, such as secured credit cards, don’t move the needle much for people who have bad credit, but they can help people with no credit establish a credit file, Ms. Wu said. Secured credit cards require the cardholder to deposit funds into a bank account — $500, for example — in order for the card company to open a credit line for the equivalent amount.
“The fact that they don’t provide real credit, that is an issue,” Ms. Wu said., adding that many who apply for a secured card, don’t ever receive them, she said, because they “don’t end up funding the deposit.”
The FICO score
A FICO score is a three-digit number from 300 to 850 that lenders use to determine a person’s ability to repay debt.
A score of 700 or above is generally considered good. A score of 800 or above is considered excellent. Most consumers have credit scores that fall between 600 and 750, with the average score being 715, according to Experian.
A consumer’s credit history accounts for 35% of their FICO score; the amounts owed by the consumer accounts for 30% of the score; 15% of the score is based on the age of the accounts in the credit history; 10% is based on the mix — or different types of credit accounts a person has; and 10% of the score is based on how often the consumer has attempted to open new credit accounts.
Some consumers can see their credit score rise as much as 100 points in 30 days by doing things like lowering their credit utilization rate, asking for late payment forgiveness and adding utility and phone payments to their credit report, according to LendingTree.
WalletHub representatives say they found several credit-building services rely on questionable practices that do a disservice to consumers who gain access to credit they can’t afford and more broadly threatens the credit system.
“Because of these shenanigans that companies do, the credit score does truly get improved,” Mr. Papadimitriou said. “Now a number of unsuspecting lenders get exposed to those shenanigans.”
The “shenanigans” he refers to include refusing to report any negative payment information to credit bureaus, showing credit lines that customers cannot access and reporting debit card activity disguised as credit activity.
Companies that are vulnerable to these business practices include small lenders or landlords who build their underwriting model and approval around certain expectations about what a 700 credit score means.
“They have certain expectations about how someone with a 700 score will perform and then they get surprised when that’s not the case, because the applicant has used one of these products for a credit score that got inflated.” Mr. Papadimitriou said.
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau spokeswoman Tia Elbaum said the federal agency declined to comment on the credit-building industry. The credit industry is regulated by the CFPB.
Correcting your report
An important service credit-building companies provide consumers is getting inaccurate information removed from credit reports, Ms. Wu said.
She said 1 in 5 consumers has a verified error on their credit report; and 1 in 20 consumers have a serious error.
“That’s a big deal,” she said. “That’s like 40 million people with an error and 10 million with a serious error.”
Ms. Khalfani-Cox, author of “Bounce Back: The Ultimate Guide to Financial Resilience,” said that in the wake of the pandemic, perhaps the biggest way the credit industry has allowed people to improve their score is by simply offering free weekly access to credit reports.
“When people are able to access and monitor their credit free of charge, they are able to see how their own behavior — like applying for a credit card or paying down a loan balance — affects their credit,” Ms. Khalfani-Cox said.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.