The U.S. economy is in good shape in the spring of 2024.
Job growth is very strong, wages are rising and, for the first time since the late 1960s, the unemployment rate has been below 4% for more than two years in a row.
But inflation remains a serious problem.
The good news is that inflation has slowed; consumer prices increased 3.4% from April 2023 to April 2024, much better than the more than 8% inflation that households experienced in 2022. But prices are still much higher than they were before the pandemic. Since mid-2020, when the economic recovery from the Viral Recession began, prices have increased a total of 22%. To put this in perspective, it took 11 years for prices to increase 22% during the economic expansion that preceded the pandemic (see Chart 1).
I often hear when I speak in public forums that many consumers are disappointed prices haven’t fallen back to where they were before the pandemic. But that isn’t going to happen, for good reason.
For prices to fall 22%, moving them back to their pre-pandemic level, that would require a significant recession that would put tens of millions of Americans out of work. Instead, in the years ahead, prices will increase slowly, the way they did before the pandemic, when inflation was low and consumers paid little attention to it.
Read More
Let’s start by defining inflation. Inflation is when most prices in the economy are increasing. We generally think about inflation in terms of goods — physical items like food, gasoline, cars, appliances and the like.
But as consumers, we actually buy more services — things like health care, education, housing, dining out and travel — than we do goods. The consumer price index from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) includes both goods and services, weighted by our actual spending patterns. At any time, some prices are increasing and some are falling, but if most prices are increasing, then there is inflation in the economy.
Deflation is when most prices in the economy are falling. It is very rare: Since the BLS first started putting out the CPI more than a century ago, prices have only fallen in 14 years, and only once since 1955. Deflation is almost always associated with recessions.

Why does it take a deep recession to bring down prices in the economy?
Businesses cut prices when demand is weak. If consumers stop purchasing, firms will reduce the prices of their goods and services to entice buyers. Thus, deflation is the result of a contracting economy and falling household spending.
Deflation can also be extremely destructive. If prices are falling consumers may put off purchases in the hope that prices will be even lower in the future, further weakening demand and exacerbating the recession.
And if firms are selling less, they need fewer workers, resulting in layoffs and reduced household incomes, creating an even larger drag on the economy. That is why central banks, including the U.S. Federal Reserve, work extremely hard to avoid deflation.
The Great Depression provides a guide to what might be needed to get prices back to where they were before the pandemic. Over the course of the Great Depression, from mid-1929 to mid-1933, the consumer price index fell 27%, by far the biggest period of deflation in modern U.S. economic history. And then, after a slight recovery, prices fell another 5% from 1937 to 1939, when the U.S. experienced another significant downturn (see Chart 2).
Another reference point is the Great Recession, when the U.S. experienced its deepest economic contraction since the Great Depression. In the second half of 2008, prices fell 3.5% while over the course of the Great Recession, the economy lost almost 9 million jobs and unemployment rose from 4.4% to 10%.
Thus, to get prices back down to where they were before the pandemic, the Federal Reserve would need to raise interest rates to such a high level that they would cause an economic downturn akin to the Great Depression. Tens of millions of Americans would lose their jobs, and the unemployment rate would move above 20%.
In this case, although high inflation is a problem for low-income households, the cure would be far worse than the disease.
Instead, the Fed has raised interest rates to a level where the economy is growing, but not as rapidly as it was during the early stages of the recovery from the pandemic. Prices are increasing, but more slowly than they were a couple of years ago, and the unemployment rate has remained historically low.
With some skill and some luck, the Fed should be able to gradually bring inflation back to the central bank’s 2% long-run target without a recession. Prices will go up slowly, and consumers’ inflation worries will fade back to the way things were before the pandemic.
Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.