For nearly 32 years, Linda Nolan and her daughter Amber Nolan-Johnston have spent Black Friday together hunting for deals.

The duo from Meadville, who donned matching sweatshirts for their annual tradition this year, have a formula when it comes to shopping on this day: Get to Ross Park Mall in the morning, stay all day, and — most importantly — keep it just between the two of them.

“We’ve never had other people,” Ms. Nolan said. “I’ve had a friend say, ‘Can I go with you?’ She’s had a friend kind of infer (that they want to join),” she said of her daughter. “It’s like, uh — I don’t think so.”

“It’s our thing,” Ms. Nolan-Johnston said.

Advertise with us

Tradition was a common theme at regional malls and shopping centers Friday, the biggest shopping day of the year in the U.S. While consumers are increasingly shifting to online shopping, retailers prepared for and got large crowds. Many shoppers said the potential for great deals brought them out, but just as many said Black Friday held a deeper significance than simply buying the latest gadget.

Customers walk around Ross Park Mall on Friday, Nov. 24, 2023. (Jacob Geanous / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“We've been doing this for years,” said Kristin Donnelly, who was shopping with her mom, Eileen Straub, and sister Kylie Walker at the Target at The Waterfront in Homestead. “We just do it to be together.”

Read More

Early Friday, they’d already snagged a few items for their kids — their cart was stocked with “Spidey” web spinners, kinetic sand, pajamas and Hot Wheels.

“My sister and I are here for mostly kids’ stuff,” Ms. Donnelly said. “We bring my mom, she's along for the ride and helps us. She guarded an item for me.”

Also part of the early crowd was Janet Cordell, 46, who got up with her two girls at 6 a.m. to drive from Poland, Ohio, to visit the Apple Store in Shadyside. Elisabeth, 11, wanted a new iPhone.

Advertise with us

“I’m a teacher, and I work a lot of hours, so it was fun getting to spend a lot of time with these two,” she said.

Ms. Cordell’s younger daughter, Rachel, 4, said earlier: “This is the best day ever because Mommy is not working.”

Diana Campese and Sheryl Monaco, both retired grandmothers from Midland, do their Christmas shopping every year on Black Friday, bringing their grandchildren to make sure they get just the right gifts.

“It’s tradition — we always come here every Black Friday,” Ms. Campese said at Ross Park Mall. “I can just find them so many things on Black Friday.”

“We have them come and pick what they want as opposed to something you buy them and then they have to take back,” Ms. Monaco said.

Advertise with us

Yolanda Davis, 56, of Homestead, was also shopping for her grandkids. The oldest is going to Universal Studios in Orlando, Fla., as a present, so the two younger kids were the focus of the day, and she got them a Lolli bike and Batman scooter.

Her 4-year-old grandson is “obsessed” with Batman and they even call him the superhero’s name. She says she saved up so she could go all-out gift shopping on Black Friday.

“I like the rush,” she said. “I love Christmas. I really do. Sometimes I go overboard, but I’m trying to stay within my limits.”

‘Let’s not go crazy’

The National Retail Federation estimates that more than 180 million people planned to shop in-store and online Friday, nearly 16 million more than last year and the highest numbers since the federation started tracking in 2017. Of those who planned to shop during the five-day stretch from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday, 72% said they would shop on Black Friday, with 39% saying they would shop on Cyber Monday, the second busiest day.

Advertise with us

But this year, persistently high inflation combined with dwindling pandemic savings has threatened to dampen some consumers’ appetites.

Tara Edwards, 42, of Belle Vernon — who donned matching “Team Holiday Spirit” sweaters with her aunt and cousin at the Waterfront Target — said they shop together on Black Friday in a tradition that began after their grandmother died.

They started wearing her old Christmas sweaters and it evolved from there. One thing that’s changed this year, she said, is that the group decided to set a budget limit.

“It’s the first time that we really had that discussion,” Ms. Edwards said. “Let’s not go crazy. There's no need to.”

The core goods consumer price index, which tracks the prices of things other than food and energy, is up 4% since last year. The data, released earlier this month, covers consumer prices through October.

Advertise with us

Household furnishings and operations saw prices increase by 1.7% year over year. Toy prices are actually down 4% since last year. They have been dropping since 1997, but the steep decline plateaued during the pandemic.

Apparel prices dropped during the pandemic as sweatpants trended in the home office, but have been on the rise since 2000. Last month, clothes were up 2.6% from the year before and 12% since this time three years ago.

The best savings might actually be on the way to the mall this year. Gasoline prices are down more than 5% from this time last year, according to the Consumer Price Index. At the pump, Pittsburgh drivers are seeing an average per gallon cost of $3.63 today, down from more than $4 a gallon a year ago, data from GasBuddy.com shows.

Or it might be cheapest to shop from home: The price of natural gas for home heating is down 16%, though the cost of electricity to power that laptop for browsing Black Friday sales is up 4%.

Staying home was not an option for Cheryl Graham, 56, and her niece Amber Matteo, 39, who walked out of the West Mifflin Kohl’s carrying bags filled with presents and a Barbie Dream Camper. Their gray hoodies hinted at their decades-long Black Friday shopping tradition with the words #BlackFriday and “Ready to kick some butt and get some deals!” printed on them.

Advertise with us

“We’ve been doing it for 20 years,” said Ms. Graham, a UPMC oncology nurse who lives in Grove City. “Don’t mind the crowds, don’t mind anything like that. We just do it to shop. I get all my shopping done today and then I’m done for the whole season.”

Throughout the morning, Ms. Matteo, an administrator at a Catholic elementary school who lives in Mount Washington, purchased gifts for her three daughters, spending about $89 on the Barbie Dream Camper.

But inflation is impacting the number of presents she can buy while staying on budget.

“I do set a dollar amount for each child, so they get a lot less than they used to,” Ms. Matteo said. “We actually upped the amount we spend this year just to make it still look like Santa came through.”

Choosing to stay closed

Advertise with us

Not every business partakes in the Black Friday madness. Many store owners intentionally stay closed to allow staff and themselves time with loved ones.

“It’s always been the day I spend with my family since my kids were little,” said Jennifer Shorthouse, owner of Blue Snail Gift Shop in Crafton. “So I always kept with that since I opened the shop three years ago.”

She’ll open Saturday, but not Friday. She said she finds staying open in the days before Black Friday — or as Ms. Shorthouse calls it, “colorful Friday” — is the better option.

“I think a lot of small businesses are trying to promote shopping the week before,” she said. “To encourage shopping small before heading to the big box stores.”

PGH Candle in Troy Hill also remains closed on Black Friday, said owner Kayla Heffernan.

Advertise with us

“There’s no need to compete with the big box stores,” she said. “We stick to offering specials for Small Business Saturday. Our community follows us so closely, so people come out for Small Business Saturday.”

POP! Culture Connection in Greensburg is typically open on Black Friday, but not this year, said Jeremy Frankieve, the owner of the collectibles store. In past years, he held events and specials for Black Friday, with much success.

“It usually gets crazy,” he said.

This year, however: “I will be in Detroit for my son’s hockey tournament.” he said. “This is the first Black Friday we will be closed for since we opened 16 years ago.”

Meanwhile, nearly every national chain takes advantage of the Black Friday surge and its potential windfall.

Advertise with us
The parking lots at Ross Park Mall in the North Hills were nearly full for Black Friday on Nov. 24, 2023. (Tim Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“The Thanksgiving holiday weekend marks some of the busiest shopping days of the year,” said Matthew Shay, president and CEO of the National Retail Federation. “Retailers have been preparing for months for this occasion. They are stocked and ready to help customers find the gifts and other items they want at great prices during the entire holiday season.”

‘It’s weirdly quiet’

While many Black Friday shoppers had an eye on Christmas gifts, others were focused on the essentials.

And they had plenty of space to do so, as the images many people associate with Black Friday of shoppers fighting over items and parking spots have largely faded with the shift to online shopping.

Shane Seamon, 29, of Mount Washington walked out of the West Mifflin Walmart with a cart full of pots and pans, hangers, a sweeper and a mattress. Mr. Seamon, an aircraft mechanic for Republic Airways, recently moved into a new apartment and was looking for deals to furnish it.

Advertise with us

“This is the first trip,” he said. “I’ve got to come back again for more stuff later but my car can only fit so much. That and I heard it was going to be kind of dead because Black Friday’s kind of falling off from what I remember.”

Mr. Seamon said he spent $250 on the mattress, $60 for the sweeper, $25 on the cooking set and $6 for hangers.

“I was expecting to drop $500,” he said. “I was happy for the first trip.”

At the Macy’s inside the Galleria at Pittsburgh Mills, Bob Kleckner, an investment adviser, trailed behind his wife, Michelle, holding a pile of sweaters.

"We have lots of family," he said. "And the sales are a plus."

Advertise with us

Ms. Kleckner said it’s hard to tell if foot traffic had increased this year, as the mall has been "dying for years."

"There used to be so much more," Mr. Kleckner said. "I remember there used to be about four restaurants and the food court was packed."

Back in Pittsburgh, Kristen Sauers, an administrative assistant, and her mother, Mary Sauers, strayed from their usual Black Friday routine of online shopping.

"We usually don't shop in-store," Kristen Sauers said. "But we decided to take the day off."

A family member is expecting, so they were looking for baby clothes, Mary Sauers said as her daughter sifted through items on a clothes rack at a TJ Maxx. They didn’t have much company — the Sauers were shocked to see how few people were at the Waterworks Shopping Center near Aspinwall this year.

Advertise with us

"It’s weirdly quiet," Kristen Sauers said. "It's usually a nightmare."

— Post-Gazette staff writers Jordan Anderson, Laura Esposito, Jacob Geanous, Anya Litvak, Ciara McEneany, Megan Tomasic and Hanna Webster reported and wrote this story.