As shoppers increasingly turn online for their purchases — and not just on Black Friday — Klaryssa Michaels is somewhat old school.
“I love shopping and I love bargains,” said Ms. Michaels, 30, of California Borough in Washington County. “It’s my favorite sport. I will be buying a few bracelets for my nieces, a new mattress, lighting and storage options for my house, a few essential oils ...”
And while she does shop online — she’s also got an eye on a vacation this year — this weekend she plans to actually step foot in some good old-fashioned brick-and-mortar stores.
She’ll certainly have company.
Regional malls say they are preparing for “heavy foot traffic” and that in-store sales are back to, if not above, pre-COVID levels.
But analysts say our collective virtual shift is here to stay.
“I definitely think online shopping is going to be the preferred mode,” said Emily Rodgers, of Syracuse-based Drive Research, which recently released its fourth annual Black Friday consumer report. “We see online Black Friday shopping being of huge interest as well as Cyber Monday continuing year over year. Online, you get the ease of comparing prices. Sometimes you get those exclusive online only deals and of course, avoiding the crowds that are driving consumers away from that traditional Black Friday in-store experience.”
Drive Research did note a recent uptick in in-store shopping since pandemic rules have loosened.

“In 2022, we had 34% of respondents saying that they were going to be visiting a shopping mall or center,” while 38 percent of shoppers will visit malls for Black Friday this year, Ms. Rodgers said. And while 47% of shoppers still find shopping malls important for holiday shopping, Ms. Rodgers said malls shouldn’t expect significant increases in shoppers in years to come.
That leaves retailers searching for ways to entice consumers to their locations, including the option of buying online and picking up in-store, which is becoming more common, Ms. Rodgers said.
“That can really help retail locations (and) encourage participation in Black Friday against online shopping,” she said. “I would expect that a lot of the retail locations are going to be gearing towards more of those buy online, pick up in-store models.”
Ross Park Mall and South Hills Village — both owned and operated by Indianapolis-based Simon Property Group — expect to see large crowds this weekend, starting on Black Friday.
“People crave connecting in-person and find joy in making holiday shopping in the mall an annual tradition for the family,” a Simon Property Group spokesperson said in a prepared statement. “The value of the store is so much more than just the sales coming from it. Studies continue to show that having a physical store in a market increases revenue not only from store sales but also higher online sales in the market. Physical stores drive awareness for new brands that are finding it harder and more expensive to drive customer acquisition online.
“‘Touch, try, buy’ is why consumers choose to shop in physical stores versus online.”
Trianna Armstrong, 20, of McCandless, is among those who make the Thanksgiving shopping weekend an in-store annual event.
But this year, with economists predicting that persistently higher inflation and dwindling pandemic-era savings will dampen consumer purchasing power, she’ll be more frugal in her approach.
“It's tradition to wear matching shirts with my mom and sisters and shop,” she said. “However, I do not plan to spend much.”
Ms. Armstrong will be shopping online and in-store this weekend. She prefers to buy personalized gifts in-person and buys business-related items online, she said.
The National Retail Federation estimates that 158 million people are planning to make purchases through Cyber Monday — the Monday following Thanksgiving — which is 15.7 million more than last year and the highest total since 2017.
“The Thanksgiving holiday weekend marks some of the busiest shopping days of the year,” said Matthew Shay, president and CEO of the NRF. “Retailers have been preparing for months for this occasion. They are stocked and ready to help customers find the gifts and other items they want at great prices during the entire holiday season.”
Haley Beckman, 24, of Mount Washington, plans on shopping for Christmas gifts and a new phone on Black Friday this year. But, Ms. Beckman said, Black Friday isn’t as big of a deal as it used to be.
“During previous Black Fridays sales were actually meaningful,” she said. “Now while in the midst of an inflation crisis, Black Friday deals are subpar. There are no large percentages off and if there is a sale, the prices are already raised from inflation. I now look at Black Friday as a time in the past. I don’t see Black Fridays in the future returning to big savings.”
Others say everyday expenses — including rent, gas and food — are so high this year that their holiday shopping is will be limited, if not entirely nixed.
“Deals are not nearly as good as they used to be and prices are through the roof,” Ms. Armstrong said. “Inflation is impacting my purchases. I am not buying presents this year because of my financial situation. It seems everyone else in my circle is doing the same because they are in similar positions.”
Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.