Even after being damaged by a flood and gutted to the studs, a house in Squirrel Hill might still command top dollar in Pittsburgh’s high-end housing market.

“There is nothing left in it,” said Roslyn Neiman of the house on Beechwood Boulevard she has listed for $1,395,000. “There’s no mantels. No light fixtures. No floors or walls.

“I have a buyer offering over a million, and the seller won’t take it, even though he paid one million fifty thousand when it was in perfect shape,” said Ms. Neiman who works from Howard Hanna Real Estate’s Shadyside office.

The demand for houses priced $1 million and more in Allegheny County remains as strong as it was last year despite the overall housing market slowing down amid rising interest rates and low inventory in all price ranges. So far this year, 166 homes have sold for at least $1 million in the county, compared to 205 last year, according to the West Penn Multi-List.

Advertise with us

“We’re on pace to sell 199 homes in the $1 million and above market,” just six fewer than last year, said Dustin Nulf, a team leader at EXP Realty on Washington’s Landing. “This is surprising to me because usually the higher end is the first to suffer when the market shifts.

“It does not seem like demand for homes in the higher end market has dwindled in the Pittsburgh metro area.”

This is one of Coldwell Banker agent Georgie Smigel’s seven-figure listings in Mars on Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2023. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

And more high-end sales are in the pipeline: There are currently 155 homes countywide carrying price tags of $1 million or more.

Overall, Pittsburgh home prices have generally remained consistent year-on-year, according to West Penn Multi-List data. The average sales price in Allegheny County in the last 90 days is $301,446 compared to $292,000 for the same period last year.

For homes in the average price range, this is still a seller’s market — largely due to the lack of inventory of homes for sale.

Advertise with us

Sellers of seven-figure homes are raising their prices. But the inventory of homes in the $1 million plus market has hit a 9-month supply, which could indicate a slowdown on the horizon for the luxury market as inventory appears to be piling up. Months of inventory for sale is a real estate industry yardstick that tells agents how many months it would take to sell every house listed for sale.

‘They’re not budging’

Real estate agents who work the high-end market say they have buyers waiting in the wings, but not enough inventory to sell.

“I could sell 12 houses today if I had them,” said Ms. Neiman, whose recent transactions range from $400,000 to $4 million.

Her territory includes city neighborhoods like Shadyside, Point Breeze, Squirrel Hill and the suburban community of Fox Chapel. She said she has buyers who are desperate to get into a house in Murdoch Farms in Squirrel Hill, but there’s nothing available. Sellers have the upper hand, she said, and many of them won’t move off their asking prices.

This is the bathtub in the ensuite, with a view of the backyard, in one of Coldwell Banker agent Georgie Smigel’s seven-figure listings in Mars on Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2023. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“Sellers are playing tough and the buyers are tougher,” Ms. Neiman said. “So, when there’s a few that are not coming together it’s mostly because the sellers are not accepting the offers.

Advertise with us

“They get a number in their head that they think their house is worth and they’re not budging,” she added. “I’ve done this for 37 years and I’ve never had so much trouble getting things together.”

The $1 million plus home market has been booming in communities where Kim Marie Angiulli does most of her business — Marshall Township and Cranberry and Adams townships in Butler County.

“It’s become increasingly expensive in Butler County,” she said.

The most recent West Penn Multi-List data shows there are 25 active listings in Butler County with asking prices of $1 million or more, including one at $10 million. This year, 28 Butler County homes have sold for at least $1 million.

The most expensive Butler County home was priced at $1,795,000 and sold for the asking price. Allegheny County’s most expensive home this year was listed at $7,000,000 and sold for $6,350,175.

Advertise with us

“We’re seeing a lot of action in the high-end,” said Ms. Angiulli a Coldwell Banker Realty agent. “I’ve probably seen more sales in the last five years in the million dollar range in the lower Butler County and northern Allegheny County area such as the Marshall Township area than previously.”

Still ‘one of the most affordable’ areas

Coldwell Banker real-estate agent Georgie Smigel also concentrates on the high-end housing market north of Allegheny County and Butler County. She said higher costs for labor and materials has helped push new construction home prices higher.

“So, a $1 million house today isn’t what it used to be,” she said. “Just like a $300,000 house today isn’t what it was. But I can tell you, Pittsburgh is still one of the most affordable housing markets in the U.S.”

Ms. Smigel, who works from the Cranberry office, recently sold a $1.8 million listing in Adams Township. There are currently 15 million-dollar homes on the multi-list that haven’t been built yet, she said.

“They’re active on the multi-list to be sold. But they haven’t even been started,” Ms. Smigel said.

Advertise with us
This is the kitchen of one of Coldwell Banker agent Georgie Smigel’s seven-figure listings in Mars on Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2023. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Despite strong sales, one troubling trend in the $1 million plus market is the growing inventory of homes for sale, which at this point has reached nine months worth of supply.

“A 9-month inventory is probably one of the biggest absorption rates that I’ve seen in a while for any market in Pittsburgh,” Mr. Nulf said. “Back in 2008, 2009 and 2010 — those were the years when we had one-year plus inventory on the market.”

The 9-month inventory of high-end houses could rise closer to 12-months as the housing market goes into its seasonal slow period around the holidays, Mr. Nulf said. When inventory stacks up like that, there is typically more pressure on homeowners to drop their prices.

Signs of a slowdown?

Some sellers are pushing the envelope asking above $1 million, agents say.

Ms. Neiman said she recently lowered the price of one listing from $1.3 million to $999,000, hoping for a faster sale.

Advertise with us

“If the market is going down, buyers get it quick. But sellers have to be dragged to it,” said Mike Netzel, a team leader at Keller Williams Real Estate in Pine. “When the market is going up, sellers are 10 miles down the road ahead of time and the buyers are wondering how come they didn’t get the memo.”

High end homes are still selling around the same pace as last year, according to West Penn Mult-List. The average days on the market for $1 million plus listings fell to 67 days from 68 days last year.

Part of the study inside a seven-figure home Realtor Kim Marie Angiulli recently made a deal on in which she represented both the buyer and seller on Friday, Oct. 13, 2023, in Gibsonia. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Days on the market for average priced homes — $301,446 in the last 90 days — climbed to 36 days, from an average of 33 days during the same 90-day period last year.

There is currently a 2.25-month supply of housing inventory for all home price ranges in Allegheny County. There were 12,782 sales in the last six months and as of mid-October there are 2,398 active listings, according to West Penn Multi-List.

For some perspective on the growing inventory that exists for $1 million homes, at the beginning of last year, there might have been only a 30-day supply of inventory in many Pittsburgh neighborhoods, Mr. Nulf said.

Advertise with us

“Houses were selling in 15 days,” Mr. Nulf said. “So, to have a 30-day inventory last year was cause for alarm because it looked like things were slowing down.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834