The U.S. Department of Energy effectively banned the sale of most incandescent lightbulbs in the U.S. with a new law that went into effect Aug. 1.

But not everyone is prepared for — or excited about — the change.

“I like the old-fashioned soft white lights, and it's harder to find that soft white color in an LED light,” Maury Burgwin said recently in the lightbulb aisle of a local big-box store. He lives in a large house — almost 5,000 square feet — and “it's got a lot of incandescents,” he said. “I'm not about to go through the expense of replacing everything all at once.”

The new law implements a minimum standard of 45 lumens per watt for light bulbs — which incandescent light bulbs do not meet. LEDs are more efficient and environmentally friendly; the Department of Energy estimates that the new rule will save consumers nearly $3 billion per year on their utility bills and cut carbon emissions by 222 million metric tons over the next 30 years.

Advertise with us

Jeremy Weber, associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s Graduate School of Public & International Affairs, said consumers and sellers had plenty of time to prepare.

The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007, which paved the way for the lightbulb law, sought to increase energy security and outline rules for new energy standards.

Read More

“Standards are far easier to comply with the more time you have,” Mr. Weber said. “The 2007 Act that put such a standard on the radar was in a way a signal to the industry, and the more time that an industry has to adapt the less costly it is.”

Mr. Weber added that the recent rapid rate of technology development in the lightbulb industry had already caused many consumers to move away from older types of lightbulbs.

The Residential Energy Consumption Survey by the Energy Information Administration reported that in 2015 only 4.1% of homes used mostly LED bulbs. By 2020, the number jumped to 31.61%.

Advertise with us

But policy tends to move slower than innovation, said Antony Davis, associate professor of economics at Duquesne University. So ... “If this is a good idea — and I'm not saying it isn't — but if this is a good idea, there's no need to mandate it,” he said.

Menards, which has over 300 stores nationwide, has been phasing out incandescent lightbulbs for years, a spokesman said. They were ready for the change.

“The price of an LED bulb has dropped dramatically as they went from a specialty item to a mass-production item,” the spokesman, Jeff Abbott, said.

However, he added, most incandescent bulbs were made in the USA, while most LED bulbs are made in China, “which we find very disappointing.”

Pittsburgh hardware store owners see the new law as a good thing, but acknowledged that it will be an adjustment.

Advertise with us

“Incandescent uses a lot of power and energy [and] sometimes we have to set solid boundaries,” said Steve Miller, owner of Miller Ace Hardware in Mount Oliver. “I believe change is good as long as it is for the betterment of humanity.”

Derek Satterfield, co-owner of Rolliers Hardware in Mt. Lebanon, said he switched his store’s lighting to LEDs almost two years ago and saw savings.

“The energy grid continues to get overwhelmed and this should do a lot to help with that,” he said

“We have to be re-educated,” said Doug Satterfield, Derek’s father and co-owner of the family business. “The good thing is you won't change them as often, and you're going to save money.”

To help with the transition, Derek Satterfield plans to train his staff so they can help customers understand their new options.

Advertise with us

“These LED bulbs have come a long way. They're not the blue light that so many of us remember them being initially,” Derek Satterfield said. “We're just trying to do the best we can to educate [our customers] on the color tones to lumens and what to expect.”

Emma Kim: ekim@post-gazette.com