2023 Honda Pilot Elite AWD vs. 2023 Kia Telluride Prestige X-Line V-6 AWD: Battle of two very strong three-row SUVs.

This week: Kia Telluride

Price: $54,120 as tested. Gray paint added $495; terracotta interior, $295; floor mats, $210.

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver touts highs like the “commodious cabin, even the base model is nicely equipped, top trims offer near-luxury environs,” but downsides include “restrained handling, not as fuel efficient as four-cylinder rivals, driver assists are sometimes intrusive.”

Advertise with us

Marketer’s pitch: “All around rugged.”

Reality: Still really good, but with some downsides.

What’s new: Mr. Driver’s Seat has touted the Telluride’s handling and comfort since its debut in 2020.

New X-Line and X-Pro trims step up the Telluride’s ruggedness. It also gets a refreshed look and interior, and more towing capacity.

Competition: In addition to the Pilot, there’s the Hyundai Palisade and Toyota Highlander, plus many more.

Advertise with us

Test drive: We were on the way to upstate New York to test out the new Hyundai Ioniq 6, and Mr. Driver’s Seat decided to switch cars at the fleet headquarters. It’s always nice to meet people you’ve worked with for 12 years but who remain a voice on the phone or an email exchange.

We traded a BMW M340i, so I was wary that the handling in the new vehicle would affect my joy. The first few turns in the Telluride swung a little wide, but overall the adjustment was not too bad, so the handling was not too bad.

Driver’s Seat: Here, the Telluride was a welcome switch. The nice, wide seat offered equal support but was not at all firm. We were driving for more than three hours in one sitting on the way home and I felt comfortable and reasonably rested, even in Friday night traffic.

The gauges are easy to read and easy to see. Controls are laid out logically as well.

On the road: It would have been far nicer to have the M340i around Peekskill, N.Y., where the main highway from our hotel brought back memories of the French Riviera. The lane hugged the water and the guardrail became just rocks jutting out at some points, and the curves were seriously sharp like some cheddar. (Travel tip: Try the Ecuadorian place La Cabana in Peekskill.)

Advertise with us

Needless to say the Telluride was a little out of its element.

But back in Chester County, the less severe country curves were easily handled. The Telluride remains one of my favorite three-row SUVs for giving the driver something to enjoy, even offering a bit of zig when I hit a few curves faster than I might have. The Telluride also handles narrow country lanes wonderfully for a big SUV.

Highway driving was delightful. The Telluride moved smoothly over the Garden State Parkway and New Jersey Turnpike. Advantage, Telluride.

Up to speed: The Telluride is no slouch in the acceleration department, either. The 3.8-liter V-6 engine creates 291 horsepower. It gets to 60 mph in 6.8 seconds, according to Car and Driver.

Shifty: The 8-speed transmission is controlled by an actual gearshift lever, and can be shifted manually there as well. Since the Pilot has rows of buttons, strong advantage, Telluride.

Advertise with us

Friends and stuff: The middle row captains chairs look and feel a little chintzy when you slide them around or fold them, but they provide some decent seating.

The middle row slides, so, like the Pilot, legroom can be divvied up among the second and third row. Head room is good for all, but foot room is not. The rear row sits scrunched against the floor, much more than the Honda.

Cargo space in the back is about on par with the Pilot, at 21 cubic feet, but it drops dramatically after that: 46 with the third row down; and 87 behind the first row, both about a third smaller. (Bonus points to Kia, though, for getting the decimals out of the equation.) Strong advantage, Pilot.

Except for towing. The Telluride can tow up to 5,500 pounds, 10% more than the Pilot.

Play some tunes: The Harman Kardon premium audio provides delightful sound, pretty much an A.

Advertise with us

The system is controlled by dials for tuning and volume, buttons that change modes, and a 12.3-inch touchscreen for the rest. The touchscreen, in fact, melds into the gauges as well, a nice BMW-y touch. (The M340i had the same setup.) Strong advantage, Telluride.

Keeping warm and cool: Temperature is controlled by dials and everything else by buttons. The vents have switches that make them easy to shut off when they blow too much air.

Fuel economy: I averaged about 21 mpg in a highway-heavy test of hundreds of miles.

Where it’s built: West Point, Ga.

How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts the Telluride reliability to be a 3 out of 5.

Advertise with us

In the end: If you’re buying a three-row SUV for total passenger comfort and space, the Pilot wins. But the Telluride provides a much better driving and audio experience.

Scott Sturgis is a freelance auto writer; mrdriversseat@gmail.com