Pittsburgh-based companies spent more than $9 billion to buy back shares of their own stock in 2022.
This wasn’t always a hot topic. Along with dividends, buybacks or share repurchases have been a common way for companies to give money back to their investors. It happens when a company has extra cash lying around and nothing attractive enough to invest in.
In recent years, though, repurchases have drawn the ire of politicians and even some shareholders who argue they can be manipulated to serve the very same executives who design and execute these buyback programs. Others argue they tend to benefit the already wealthy to the detriment of less wealthy investors. Some might prefer to see that extra cash go toward raising worker salaries, research and development, or expansion.
“For a long time, it was really sleepy,” said Shawn Thomas, professor of business administration at the University of Pittsburgh’s Joseph M. Katz Graduate School of Business. “And then it kind of became a little political.”

Buyback programs — where a public company’s board of directors approves a plan to spend a certain amount of corporate cash buying shares or sets a share number target — proliferated after the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission allowed the practice in 1982. Before that, a company trading in its own stock was thought to brush up against insider trading rules.
By the mid-1990s, buybacks surpassed dividends as the preferred method of rewarding investors. They are taxed at a lower rate than dividends and investors have more control over when they cash out and pay taxes or hold on to the stock that will presumably be worth more with shares removed from circulation after a buyback. Plus, it’s easier to do a one-time buyback program and much harder to lower or suspend a dividend once a company has established one.
So, do buybacks actually increase returns for investors?
“There’s a lot of evidence that they do, and activist investors often pursue them,” said Steven Pakela, managing partner at Pay Governance LLC.
“At the same time, we have researched S&P 500 (and) over the long term, shareholder returns are just about even” with or without buybacks. By long-term, Mr. Pakela means five years.

It’s more about the best use of investor money at the moment, he said.
When a company has excess cash, Mr. Pakela said, “shareholders are going to say, ‘Hey, you can’t just sit on it. You have to do something with it.’
“That’s where activist investors come in and say, ‘That money belongs to the shareholders.’”
Pittsburgh-based firms spent more on buybacks in 2022 than at any point in the past five years, with PNC Financial Services Group Inc. leading the pack.
The bank spent $3.8 billion on repurchases last year, promising to continue buying back shares this year, albeit at a slower rate.
Findlay-based Dick’s Sporting Goods bought back $1.2 billion worth of its own shares, followed by U.S. Steel with $849 million in buybacks, according to an analysis of Bloomberg data.
Federated Hermes highlighted to its investors that since 1998, when it went public, the company spent more on share repurchases, acquisitions and dividends ($5.8 billion) than it has made in cumulative net income during that time ($5 billion).
In 2022, it spent $218 million on buybacks.
At Wabtec, CEO Rafael Santana said the company’s decision to increase dividends and spend $178 million buying back stock illustrates “our confidence in the future of the company.”
He vowed to “continue again to return excess cash to shareholders.”

Since it launched a share buyback program in 2020, CNX Resources has repurchased nearly a quarter of the company’s shares, spending $868 million to do so.
“And we're potentially just getting started,” CEO Nick DeIuliis said during a call with analysts earlier this year.
Coal miner Consol Energy Inc., announced in May that it plans to spend about 75% of its quarterly cash flow on shareholder returns, with as much as $1 billion authorized for share buybacks through the end of next year.
The Cecil-based firm’s CEO Jimmy Brock told investors during an earnings call on May 2 that the company has shifted its preference away from dividends and in favor of buybacks, in part because of the “tax efficiency of buybacks over dividends, and the feedback we received from our shareholder base.”
Following the money
The tax advantages of buybacks are most pronounced for investors in high income tax brackets, Mr. Thomas said. Dividends count as income and are taxed as such, while the proceeds from a stock sale are taxed as capital gains.
President Joe Biden, who has been a vocal critic of share buybacks, included a 1% tax on the value of such purchases in last year’s Inflation Reduction Act. The tax is paid by the company — the buyer — not the shareholders (the sellers). So far, though, it hasn’t made a big difference in how companies deal with their excess cash.
There’s another, overlapping group that likes buybacks: corporate executives whose compensation has shifted more and more towards stock options over the years.
Mr. Thomas said research shows there’s typically a 3% spike in the share price of a company right after it announces a buyback program, which critics and regulators worry gives corporate executives the opportunity to trade their own shares around that time.
In May, the SEC instituted a new disclosure rule for share buybacks. Companies now have to disclose daily buyback activity.
These daily tallies, which would be submitted every quarter, will “provide investors with enhanced information to assess the purposes and effects of share repurchases,” the agency said.
Another concern is that executives are often judged, in part, on a ratio called earnings per share and that by decreasing the share count through buybacks, the ratio looks artificially better.
A Harvard Business Review article from 2014 argued that company executives who make the decision to spend corporate dollars on share buybacks are those who stand the most to gain from those decisions, with “unsurprising” results, wrote William Lazonick, president of the Academic-Industry Research Network.
“Even when adjusted for inflation, the compensation of top U.S. executives has doubled or tripled since the first half of the 1990s, when it was already widely viewed as excessive. Meanwhile, overall U.S. economic performance has faltered.”
“Buybacks have become an unhealthy corporate obsession,” he wrote.
Pay Governance recently released an analysis of how buybacks are or aren’t addressed in executive compensation decisions, concluding that most companies adjust for buybacks even though the majority don’t actually say they do.
“Boards are pretty good at establishing goals to anticipate the buybacks,” Mr. Pakela said.
Mr. Thomas thinks the high-profile concerns over buybacks are “completely misplaced.”
“From a fundamental standpoint, if a firm has generated cashflow that it can’t invest in attractive new projects, those firms should pay that money out to shareholders as a dividend or buyback,” he said. “And anything that we do to prevent that sort of transfer leads to worse outcomes.”
He rejected the notion that buybacks may encourage a shorter-term mentality, forgoing investments in projects that may take years to generate a return. Mr. Thomas said there’s not a lot of evidence for that, in part because investors are pretty good at factoring those future returns into current share prices.
As for using that cash to raise employee salaries, he said that makes sense only as long as it’s profitable.
“We all want people to earn more, but no shareholder wants to be the one paying for it through a restriction on dividends and buybacks,” Mr. Thomas said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.