What are pear trees running this year? Fertilizer is up how much? What will the costumes, staging and dancers cost? Got the latest spot prices on the gold market and the pet store had the price on canaries.

In this case, the shopper — or at least the main one for more than 30 years — has been Rebekah McCahan, vice president, senior investment and portfolio strategist with PNC Asset Management Group.

Ms. McCahan is part of a team that develops reports offering market insights to a clientele that has put $175 billion worth of assets under PNC’s management. Such reports might include a look at, say, investing strategies that prioritize growth equities over value stocks.

But the job also includes pricing out the annual cost of the presents promised in the song “The Twelve Days of Christmas” — a tradition since the bank started doing it 39 years ago.

Advertise with us

This year — well, most years — you should probably get the sweater instead.

In 2022, the total bill rose 10.5% to $45,523.27 — the third highest year-over-year increase in the index’s history. That’s if you bought the goods in brick-and-mortar stores.

It’s a little bit less expensive online, but not much, noted Amanda Agati, executive vice president and chief investment officer for the PNC Asset Management Group and spokeswoman for the index. She likes to say her pleas to Amazon for free shipping on livestock have gone unanswered.

If you’re being really extravagant — and your true love has a whole lot of space in the house — PNC runs a cumulative total of buying the growing list of goods when counting each repetition of the song, totaling 364 presents. That was up 9.8% this year to hit $197,071.09.

It’s a marketing thing

Advertise with us

Ms. Agati has been giving interviews on the cost of lords-a-leaping and turtle doves for years but even she was surprised to hear the PNC Christmas Price Index was the subject of a column in Baltimore one year bemoaning the fact that both the Time magazine Person of the Year and the Christmas index are acts of marketing.

Well, yeah.

PNC Bank records show its signature project started in 1984. Ms. Agati said it was created as a lighthearted message for clients.

A chief economist for Philadelphia-based Provident National Bank dreamt up the idea, right around when Pittsburgh National Bank and Provident National merged.

There have been many mergers and acquisitions since then. PNC last year acquired BBVA USA Bancshares Inc., becoming the fifth-largest U.S. commercial banking organization, with over $560 billion in assets.

Advertise with us

The annual holiday index makes for a pretty good calling card in all those places where the high net worth individuals that PNC would not mind helping invest their assets are saying, “What’s the name of that new bank?”

Economic touchpoints

It’s hard not to notice that the eight maids-a-milking ($58) did not cost more to hire this year. Or last year. Or the year before.

“That’s a frustrating one,” said Ms. Agati. “It’s very much tied to the federal minimum wage.”

The federal minimum has not changed from $7.25 an hour since 2009. “Definitely not keeping pace with inflationary trends,” she said. A number of states have approved higher minimum wages or are in the process of doing so, so if you’re hiring the maids in, say, California, it might cost a bit more. Assuming anyone responds to the job ad.

Advertise with us

The juxtaposition of modern business assessment imposed on charming medieval-flavored whimsy is part of the appeal of the index, of course. Who knew that a song about gifting a lover with jewelry, exotic birds and entertainment would make such a useful vehicle for economic lessons?

Ms. Agati is enthusiastic about the intel that comes out of researching the index, which she calls her favorite project of the year. “We’re trying to get a handle on consumer behavior and consumption trends,” she said. “The consumer is the drum beat for the American economy.”

Her favorite present is those five golden rings, but gold ring prices are up 39% since last year. Those will cost $1,245 vs. $895 last year. The rise was driven, Ms. Agati said, in part by things like the services around those rings as much as the metal itself.

“My True Love is definitely going to have to pay up,” she warned.

Fertilizer prices are high, as American farmers as well aware. That drove the cost of a pear tree up 20.4%, while the partridge sitting in it cost $20.18 — just like last year.

Advertise with us

When the pandemic shut down much of the country in 2020, the PNC Christmas Price Index team thought it was important to zero out the cost of performance-based gifts like drummers drumming. All of those people were out of work, noted Ms. Agati. “We didn’t want to be tone deaf.”

The bank’s index checkers use data from a modern dance company in Philadelphia and from the Philadelphia Ballet to calculate the part about ladies dancing and lords-a-leaping, including expenses such as costumes, staging and makeup.

Since performances have since resumed, the cost of gifting those experiences is back in the index. The price for the drummers is up 2.6%, the ladies dancing are up 10% and the lords-a-leaping will run 24.2% more than last year.

Choppy days ahead

The index is meant to reflect what’s going on in the economy as much as possible, and the big story this year has been the Federal Reserve’s efforts to dump cold water on inflation. The central bank has raised interest rates as inflation peaked just above 9% in June. By November, inflation had begun to slow down.

Advertise with us

Investors will be closely watching, as a statement from Ms. Agati included in the official holiday index release noted.

"Markets continue to focus on two critical variables for the path forward: signs of inflation peaking and rolling over, and the Fed completing its tightening of financial conditions,” she said. “In the absence of confirmation on both, we think the high volatility regime is going to continue to dominate and markets are likely to stay pretty choppy.”

Whether that means a recession is coming isn’t clear, but whatever happens will definitely affect True Love’s budget when trying to gift these same things in 2023.

Has the PNC team ever considered pricing out the very nice gifts requested in another Christmas perennial, “Santa Baby,” sung by Eartha Kitt and many others?

“No, I don’t think we have done that,” said Ms. Agati, quickly demonstrating her familiarity with that lyric’s list of goodies. They include a ring, of course, but also a yacht, a duplex and a deed to a platinum mine.

Ms. Agati noted, with a laugh, that there’s potential there. “We certainly cater to ultra high net worth individuals.”