Chevron Corp. turned out to be one of the top performing assets David Root included this year in the workplace retirement portfolios his firm manages for companies that offer employee 401k plans.
And he makes no apologies for the investment.
“If you didn’t have energy as part of your portfolio this year — which averaged 35% to 40% returns — you had no chance of outperforming the S&P 500,” said Mr. Root, CEO of DBR & Co., Downtown.
Some fund managers guided by their environmental, social and governance values rather than pure financial considerations might have ruled out an investment in a fossil fuel-related company like Chevron — as well as in businesses involved in weapons or vices like tobacco, alcohol and gambling.
The federal government recently gave its blessing to allow workplace retirement plan fiduciaries to weigh a company’s ESG compliant factors along with financial analysis when choosing investments.
A ruling in late November by the U.S. Department of Labor reversed Trump-era rules which required retirement plan fiduciaries to use only financial analysis when deciding which investments to include in 401k plans.
Read More
The new DOL rule — officially named Prudence and Loyalty in Selecting Plan Investments and Exercising Shareholder Rights — opens the door for fund managers and 401k plan sponsors to consider how well companies perform in areas such as climate change or social equity as part of the investment selection process.
ESG is a type of investing that measures a company’s sustainability with non-financial factors such as the diversity of its board of directors, executive pay, lawsuits, lobbying and political contributions.
Critics of using such measures say it’s a pointless distraction in a business climate beset with high inflation, rising interest rates and the threat of a recession. But supporters believe environmental and social issues present some of the most challenging problems of the day.
The issue has divided some players in the financial services industry along ideological lines and pushed high drama into the usually staid retirement investment world.
States push back
Some Republican-led states have taken aim at sustainable funds.
Florida banned its $228 billion pension fund in August from incorporating ESG considerations in the investment process. This month, state officials also withdrew $2 billion worth of investments managed by BlackRock, saying BlackRock cared more about environmental, social and governance issues than the bottom line.
While the headlines are sensational, the actions in Florida are hardly more than symbolic since the withdrawals won ’t even move the needle for the $8.5 trillion Wall Street giant.
Meanwhile in Texas, the state comptroller has been pushing back against financial firms that boycott energy companies.
The state recently released a list of 10 financial firms and nearly 350 investment funds that are denying the oil industry access to capital by refusing to invest in them. The comptroller directed the state’s pension funds to divest from any companies on the list.
The Texas ban is up against a movement where dozens of big institutional investors, pension funds and university endowments — led by the international 350.org movement — have joined forces to divest from fossil fuels.

Pittsburgh financial adviser Robert Fragasso said ESG investing often is misunderstood by many as a left-wing plot to direct resources to progressive programs. He said that’s a mistaken idea.
His Downtown firm, Fragasso Financial Advisors, has been using such tools for a long time to evaluate companies — simply because he doesn’t want companies turning up skeletons that might cost his clients money.
“ESG means just what it says,” Mr. Fragasso said. “Getting the right product out to people, servicing your customers, treating your employee workforce with respect and running your business as a reputable enterprise.
“The new rule doesn’t promote ESG, but it permits ESG considerations, which is a big step because ESG had not been considered a full-fledged criteria for investing,” he said.
“But people are taking ESG and politicizing what should be a legitimate business discussion.”
Risk, reward and fees
For Mr. Root, it’s really about risk, reward and evaluating a company’s performance on measurable factors like assets, debt and revenues when it comes to picking investments.
His firm manages more than 50 employee retirement plans which have more than 100,000 participants combined. DBR & Co. chooses a lineup of investments for workers to pick for their 401ks. His company also makes discretionary investment decisions for some accounts.
“So, we’ve got a lot on the line with respect to making sound judgments,” he said.
“I’m supportive of ESG, but not at the cost of reduced returns or an inferior investment lineup that’s offered to participants. So, it’s finding that balance.”
Most environmental, social and governance-focused funds don’t pass the rigorous test his firm sets for expenses. Investment products marketed as ESG funds can cost up to five times more than regular index funds and often there’s little difference between the products, he said.
“I’m skeptical and cynical,” Mr. Root said. “I believe it’s cover for the BlackRocks of the world that are marketing ESG at a higher fee level.”
He said multi-national fund managers have created new departments for these types of investments and charge premium fees. ESG investment funds typically charge 0.15% fees versus a 0.03% fee charged for regular index funds.
Often there’s little difference between the two products. Many such products are basic index funds with one or two stocks changed, Mr. Root said.
“You have an S&P 500 index fund where they’ve taken out two or three stocks that are obviously not ESG — such as Exxon or Phillip Morris,” he said.
“They replace them with something more obviously ESG favorable and then market it as an ESG fund that has S&P 500 comparable returns yet it meets all ESG standards.”
While the DOL ruling isn’t a federal mandate, it will change how fund managers evaluate investments. “We are going to have to be probably more thoughtful about how we are viewing ESG and how it fits with a participant’s retirement plan,” Mr. Root said. “We’re going to be asking those questions upfront, likely.”
Changing the rules
In a statement on its website, the Department of Labor said it made the move to approve environmental, social and governance investments in order to fulfill its mission, which is to safeguard the retirement savings of workers.
“Climate change and other ESG factors can be financially material and when they are, considering them will inevitably lead to better long-term risk-adjusted returns, protecting the retirement savings of American workers,” the department said.
Anyone who acts as a fiduciary of employee retirement plans is required by law to follow DOL guidelines when dealing with funds that fall under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).
The new rule reverses the Trump administration’s regulations which told retirement plan fiduciaries they could not invest in “non-pecuniary” vehicles that sacrificed investment returns or take on additional risk.
The DOL concluded that the Trump-era rule, along with another one related to casting proxy votes, unnecessarily restrained plan fiduciaries’ ability to weigh ESG factors when choosing investments, even when those factors could benefit plan participants financially.

“When you think about it, these are all good things to do,” said Paul Brahim, managing director at Wealth Enhancement Group, Downtown.
“Since when is it bad to be cognizant and aware of your environmental impact? Since when is it bad to have a diverse workplace? These are all good things.”
More retirement fund managers are building investment lineups with environmental, social and governance-minded alternatives for people who want to invest with their conscience and for those who don’t choose to take that approach, he said.
The growing demand for such investments is creating a lot of traffic in the industry. One of the challenges with choosing ESG investments is there are so many rating agencies, and they use different measurements.
“Depending upon what a rating entity looks at, you could see different scores for different companies,” Mr. Brahim said.
One concern he has with ESG investing is that extreme adherence to it can exclude companies and sectors, even though they perform reasonably well in most ESG-related areas and score higher than other companies in a sector.
“The public doesn’t want the planet to overheat,” Mr. Brahim said. “So, consumer demand is driving ESG, which is the best way for anything to happen in this country.”
“But how important is it if the pension fund misses its return marks and people lose their benefits or their benefits are reduced, that we wave the banner of fully compliant ESG?”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.