There have been enormous economic changes since the pandemic hit the United States in early 2020, and one of the biggest has been the historically tight labor market.

With millions of workers dropping out of the labor force in response to COVID-19, and then a strong recovery in demand, businesses are struggling to hire. As a result, wages have risen sharply, both nationally and locally.

High inflation has eroded some of these wage gains, but overall workers, particularly those in lower-wage positions, have benefited from the tight labor market and higher pay.

Employment dropped sharply in March and April of 2020 as businesses closed due to government requirements and a lack of customers.

Advertise with us

Nationally, employment fell by 22 million, or 14%, over those two months. The job losses were even sharper in the Pittsburgh-metropolitan income area, with employment down by 229,000 (19%), in part because restrictions on economic activity were stricter in Pennsylvania than in some other parts of the country. These job losses dwarfed those of past recessions. But employment bounced back quickly as the economy adjusted to the new reality. In addition, massive aid to businesses and households from the federal government and low interest rates due to an extremely aggressive response from the Federal Reserve led to a strong rebound in economic activity and hiring.

Nationally, employment surpassed its pre-recession peak over the summer.

The local jobs recovery has been weaker, with employment in the Pittsburgh area through August 2022 still 45,000, or about 4%, lower than it was before the pandemic. But the problem is primarily one of too few workers, and not too few jobs. The signs of that are everywhere, literally, with help-wanted signs plastered all over the place and businesses advertising for workers on TV, radio, billboards, and online. National and local businesses are short-staffed, with hotels cutting back on housekeeping, stores and restaurants reducing their hours; there are lengthy delays for home repairs, and longer waits for consumer services.

Much of the worker shortage has come from people dropping out of the labor force.

Before the pandemic more than 63% of U.S. adults were either working or looking for work. But that plunged to about 60% in April of 2020 as some workers lost their jobs and stopped seeking work, particularly those already close to retirement. Others left the workforce because they were concerned about catching COVID or spreading it to family members; and some parents quit their jobs because they couldn’t find childcare or their child’s school moved to online instruction.

Advertise with us

The labor force has recovered since then, but nationally the share of adults either working or looking for work is just above 62%, still about one percentage point lower than it was before the pandemic.

The labor force recovery has been even weaker locally.

In Pennsylvania, the share of adults working or looking for work in the summer of 2022 was less than 62%, well below the 63%+ rate before the pandemic.

In the Pittsburgh area, the available pool of labor is smaller by more than 600,000, or about 30%, compared to before the pandemic. Much of this is due to the area’s older-than-average population, which is more susceptible to and more concerned about contracting COVID.

With strong demand for labor and a smaller supply, businesses have been raising pay to attract workers. Although the minimum wage is $7.25 an hour, local firms are offering starting pay well above that to attract employees. Workers have also not been shy about quitting a job to earn more in a new position. The average hourly wage in the Pittsburgh is now above $30 an hour, up from around $27 an hour prior to the pandemic. And although inflation has been high, paychecks have generally been keeping up with rising prices.

Advertise with us

Wage gains have been particularly strong for lower-wage workers in the aftermath of the pandemic.

According to a recent report from the Keystone Research Center, Pennsylvania workers in the bottom one-third of the wage distribution have experienced the strongest wage gains during the economic recovery from the pandemic. This is different from other recent expansions, when high-income earners benefited the most. Competition among businesses to hire has led to strong wage growth for workers with less experience and lower levels of formal education, boosting earnings for lower-wage workers.

Although workers, particularly low-wage workers, are receiving bigger paychecks thanks to the post-pandemic labor market, there are still big problems ahead. High inflation is reducing the value of those higher wages. And with the Federal Reserve now aggressively raising interest rates in an attempt to slow inflation, there is real risk of a near-term recession and increased unemployment that would erode much of the gains that workers have made over the past couple of years. But for now at least, the extremely tight labor market is a big positive for workers nationally and locally.

Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.