It’s tough to buy a house these days when there are multiple bidders for a listing trying to outdo each other to impress sellers.
Sometimes buyers attempt to stand out from the crowd — and pull a few heartstrings — by writing a letter to the seller which is submitted along with their offer. It’s a long-used tactic in the real estate industry commonly known as the buyer “love letter.”
Buyers who submit these letters — which often include family photographs — want sellers to sympathize with their situation and hear specifically all the things they appreciate about the home.
But these letters also raise fair housing concerns and could open the door for potential lawsuits against real estate agents and their clients for discrimination under the Federal Fair Housing Act.
The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on an individual's race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or disability. If it appears that information disclosed within such a letter caused a seller to choose one buyer over another, it could mean problems for everyone involved in the transaction.
While love letters aren’t banned in this state, Oregon has outlawed them. The National Association of Realtors frowns upon their use and by extension, the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh discourages real estate agents from submitting or receiving them.
Read More
“We prefer agents don’t use that tactic if the love letter can conceivably reveal anything that is discriminatory in any form or fashion,” said John Petrack, vice president of the Downtown-based Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh.
Buyer love letters have been around for some time. But in October 2020, as the historic housing bull market was gaining steam, the National Association of Realtors began warning agents about the potential fair housing risks of the letters.
“Consider where a potential buyer writes to the seller that they can picture their children running down the stairs on Christmas morning for years to come in the house. This statement not only reveals the potential buyer’s familial status, but also their religion, both of which are protected characteristics under fair housing laws. Using protected characteristics as a basis to accept or reject an offer, as opposed to price and terms, would violate the Fair Housing Act.”
Most Pittsburgh-area real estate agents use their own discretion where love letters are concerned. The 3,200 members of the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh have been advised about the risks that come with using them.
“From the preaching we’ve been doing in the past 12 months, many agents have adopted the practice,” Mr. Petrack said. “Agents have asked us if they don’t pass the letters along is it a breach of fiduciary duty to the client. The message we’ve been preaching is to please talk your client out of preparing a love letter.”
Mr. Petrack said such letters practically shout a message to sellers that says: This is who I am. Pick me.
“The buyer is making an effort to say to the seller that we are better than the other three offers you got because we are like you,” he said.
Sometimes you strike out anyway
Preparing a love letter is likely to be an exercise in futility if all the seller cares about is the bottom line — which is often the case.
Mike Netzel, a team leader at Keller Williams Realty in Pine, said he has seen buyer love letters go on about things the seller often doesn’t care about — especially when the bottom line offer is less than desirable.
“With love letters, I’ve seen them hit, and I’ve seen them strike out,” Mr. Netzel said.
They talk about how much they love the house; their multi-generational connection to the area; they graduated from this school district and want their children to also; they’ll tell you they met their spouse two doors down; and they’ve lost nine homes to higher bidders already, he said.
“But the things that matter usually aren’t in those letters,” Mr. Netzel said. “What speaks loudest are the terms you offer and it’s not just price. You can say your inspection will only focus on potentially dangerous or fatal items. Now that’s music to the seller’s ears.”
One listing where Mr. Netzel saw a letter move a seller’s heart involved a man selling a house he had built to accommodate a disabled brother he had once expected to come live with him. The buyer submitted a letter with his offer explaining that he was wheelchair-bound and the house was perfect for him.
“It resonated with the seller,” Mr. Netzel said.
Coldwell Banker real estate agent Kim Marie Angiulli said her company no longer condones buyer love letters.
“I used to enjoy reading them and presenting them to sellers,” Ms. Angiulli said. “At times, it did sway sellers. Now, I only present the offer and the seller looks at the terms of the agreement without the love letters.”
Still, some missives can be persuasive.
“I represented a seller once who took a lesser offer because the buyer was a woman who had health problems and the house had a first-floor master bedroom.You can see how love letters might sway a seller and violate the familiarity status.”
Keeping personal distance
The region’s largest real estate company — Howard Hanna Real Estate Services — hasn’t banned love letters, but has advised agents to focus those letters on characteristics of the home.
“Sellers are getting so many offers that they are more focused on the salient issues of the deal such as price, contingencies and time line, and less concentrated on the personal side of the buyer,” said Dennis Cestra Jr., president of Howard Hanna’s Pennsylvania division.
“I think that’s just the nature of the market we’re in now,” Mr. Cestra said. “Love letters are becoming less of a tradition as the industry progresses, which is making housing available to everyone and it creates a more level playing field.”
Zillow, a Seattle-based online real estate marketplace, also discourages the use of the tactic.
“Not only are so-called ‘love letters’ the least effective strategy for winning an offer, according to a recent survey of seller’s agents, but they could also encourage the recipient to violate fair housing laws,” a Zillow spokesperson said.
“Buyers should consult with their buyer’s agent to pursue other strategies that work better to improve the odds of their offer getting accepted, such as higher down payments or offering more earnest money,” the spokesperson said.
A 2021 Zillow survey of real estate agents found the use of all-cash offers was the most important strategy for influencing a seller’s decision. Agents said love letters were the least important factor.
When it’s a close call, sellers will choose a buyer they click with, said Charlene Haislip, a Re/Max real estate agent in Squirrel Hill. But a note is less likely to make a difference when there is a $40,000 price gap, she said.
Buyers’ agents, looking for any angle that will help clients win, are more likely to favor love letters. Sellers agents don’t like them mostly because of the emotional component they bring to the bidding process.
“Many sellers do not like receiving love letters because they do not want their heart strings pulled upon,” Ms. Haislip said. “In fact, that is one of the reasons they’ve hired an agent instead of selling the home themselves. It puts a little personal distance between potential buyers and themselves, allowing them to stay focused on the monetary aspect of the sale and nothing else.”
Keeping things fair
But sometimes sellers are keenly interested in who is buying their house, especially sellers who have lived in a home for decades and raised families there, and want to know if the buyers will have a similar experience.
And that is why Georgie Smigel, a Coldwell Banker real estate agent in Cranberry, thinks love letters can play a role in housing discrimination.
“It’s not really fair for a mommy and daddy and two kids to get the house because they told the seller they want to watch their children grow there,” Ms. Smigel said. “What about the single client who has yet to marry but qualifies for the house?”
A compelling letter isn’t likely to override financial reality, said Mr. Netzel at Keller Williams.
“If you take an offer for $10,000 less because you like the buyer’s story, how do you explain that to your family or your retirement account?,” he said. “The story and the contract have got to be in unison.
“You don’t really know what you as a seller would do until your bank account is part of the decision,” Mr. Netzel said. “Otherwise, it’s all theory.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.