Buying and selling homes might not be as expensive if the state agencies that regulate the real estate sector weren’t dominated by people from the industry, according a report released Monday by the Consumer Federation of America.

The Washington, D.C.-based group found that of the 378 seats on state real estate boards across the country, only 15% of the seats are held by individuals outside the real estate industry, and even those are usually held by people in affiliated industries like banking and real estate law.

None of the seats, however, are held by consumer or housing advocates.

“We estimate that if there was real price competition, consumers would pay $20 billion to $30 billion less a year in commissions,” said Stephen Brobeck, a senior fellow at CFA and author of the report: State Real Estate Commissions: Do They Serve the Consumer Interest? He said consumers pay about $100 billion in commissions annually to real estate agents who are involved in 90% of all sales.

Advertise with us

In an ideal world, he said state real estate boards wouldn’t be dominated by people in the real estate industry, but would instead operate independent of the industry. “You would see a good portion of the $20 billion to $30 billion savings just because of that,” Mr. Brobeck said.

The Pennsylvania Real Estate Commission has 11 total seats with six of those seats — a majority — being held by people who are tied to the real estate industry and five non-industry seat holders. By comparison, Ohio’s state real estate commission has five total seats with four of them held by industry players and one held by a non-industry person.

Laura Humphrey, a spokeswoman at the Pennsylvania Department of State, which oversees the State Real Estate Commission, said the Pennsylvania General Assembly determined the makeup of agency.

The members consist of the commissioner of Professional and Occupational Affairs, the director of the Attorney General’s Bureau of Consumer Protection (or designee), three public members and six others who are members of the industry (real estate brokers or cemetery brokers).

“Based on numbers alone, the bare majority of members are representatives of the real estate industry,” Ms. Humphrey said.

Advertise with us

The state real estate commission grants and renews licenses to real estate agents in Pennsylvania and administers and enforces laws related to real estate activity.

However, Mr. Brobeck criticized state real estate commissions for not doing enough to help consumers. Only 11 commissions nationwide provide adequate consumer information on their websites and 21 state real estate commission websites ignore homebuyers and sellers altogether.

“Most states do not help consumers effectively resolve complaints,” Mr. Brobeck said. “In part, this is because commissions have no authority to require restitution. In many states, consumers must win a lawsuit or mediation in order to draw on state recovery funds.

“Publicly available information suggests that most commissioners spend most of their time investigating not consumer complaints but agent criminal convictions or the lack of a license,” he said, adding, “It is no surprise that many commissioners from the industry ignore consumers or fail to understand and appreciate the important role of their commission in informing and protecting homebuyers and sellers.”

He said consumers end up paying more because the can’t effectively negotiate commissions and state real estate boards have overlooked industry practices such as agents steering buyers to higher commission properties. The boards also have supported anticompetitive practices that have harmed consumers, such as banning agent rebates and requiring agents to provide minimum service levels, he said.

Advertise with us

He said while it might be unrealistic to expect industry-dominated commissions to address the structural issues, at the very least the state agencies could focus more attention on providing service to homebuyers and sellers.

But that’s more likely to occur if the commissions included more independent voices — not just consumer and housing advocates, but independent experts such as law professors and economists with no financial ties to the real estate industry.

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591