Gus Faucher is the senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He will be sharing his insights on the regional economy each month.
The pandemic and Viral Recession wreaked havoc on the U.S. labor market last year. The U.S. economy lost tens of millions of jobs in the spring of 2020 and the unemployment rate soared to a record high.
Not surprisingly some measures of income fell as a result, and the poverty rate increased. But looking at the data more closely, and including federal pandemic-related aid, household income actually rose, despite the recession, and income inequality and poverty declined.
Thus households actually gained ground last year, thanks to support from the federal government.
Every September, the Census Bureau releases a report on income and poverty during the previous year. According to the latest report, median household income — the income level where half of households earn more, and half of households earn less — fell by 3% in 2020 from 2019, after adjusting for inflation, to around $67,500.
This was the first statistically significant decline in household income in almost one decade.
Read More
At the same time the poverty rate rose from 10.5% in 2019 — the lowest poverty rate on record, going back to 1959 — to 11.4% in 2020. This was the first increase in the poverty rate in five years.
The poverty threshold varies by family size and composition, and is updated annually for inflation; for the typical family of four in 2020, the poverty line was about $26,500. The poverty rate is outdated and imperfect. Among other flaws, it was originally calculated as three times the estimated cost of feeding a family of three in the 1960s, a measure with much less relevance five decades later. It also excludes the value of government benefits. But it does provide a consistent way of measuring economic distress over a long period of time.
The decline in median household income, and the increase in the poverty rate, are not terribly surprising. The economy lost 22 million jobs in March and April of 2020, and even with the recovery, employment in December 2020 was down by more than 9 million from the same month in 2019. Households lost all of the income associated with those millions of jobs. This pushed down median household income, and pushed up the poverty rate.
But there’s a big methodological hole in the income and poverty numbers for 2020: They don’t include the impact of some pandemic-related stimulus programs, in particular the stimulus payments that most U.S. households received in April 2020.
As the Census Bureau puts it, “the income and poverty estimates…are based on the concept of money income, which is pretax and does not include these stimulus payments and tax credits.” (These income and poverty measures do include unemployment insurance benefits, so in 2020 they did capture pandemic-related expanded eligibility for unemployment insurance and increased benefit levels.)
When these payments are included, the picture changes dramatically. Median post-tax household income, adjusted for inflation, actually rose 4% in 2020 from 2019. That is, after taxes and including stimulus payments, income increased significantly for the typical household in a year when the unemployment rate soared to almost 15%.
Household income increased across almost all age and demographic groups, with an especially large increase for female-headed families. However, median household income did fall slightly for the wealthiest one-fifth of households last year because the stimulus payments were phased out for upper-income households. As a result, various measures show a reduction in post-tax income inequality in 2020.
The Census Bureau also produces what it calls a “Supplemental Poverty Measure” (SPM) that includes the value of government benefits, such as food stamps; in 2020 the SPM included the federal stimulus payments. In addition, the SPM threshold is based, on more recent data, on a broader category of spending than the official poverty measure.
The poverty rate, as measured using the SPM, fell sharply in 2020 to 9.1%, from 11.8% in 2019. This was the lowest SPM rate since 2009, the first year for which it is available. Also, 2020 was the first year that the SPM rate was below the official poverty rate. According to the Census Bureau, last year’s stimulus payments lifted about 12 million people, or almost 4% of the U.S. population, out of poverty.
Unfortunately, the pandemic has delayed the release of most regional data on household income and poverty, so it’s unclear how it and various stimulus programs have affected those measures in Pennsylvania and the Pittsburgh area. But according to the Census Bureau, the Pennsylvania averages over 2018 and 2020 of both the official poverty rate (10.4%), and the SPM (9.5%), were below the corresponding national averages (both 11.2%).
The fact that the SPM takes local housing costs into account indicates that economic distress is somewhat lower in Pennsylvania than it is in the rest of the country. In addition, the average of the SPM Pennsylvania rate in 2018 through 2020 was below the official poverty rate for those years, suggesting that the stimulus payments lifted many Pennsylvania households out of poverty in 2020.
Although the U.S. economic recovery from the Viral Recession is incomplete, it has been far stronger than recoveries from previous recessions.
A big reason why is that despite the loss of tens of millions of jobs, household income rose in 2020 thanks to aid from the federal government. This has allowed consumer spending to recover quickly, powering overall economic growth. In addition, once this aid is properly accounted for, poverty fell and income inequality declined, even in the face of the steepest economic downturn since the Great Depression. That is very different from the typical recession experience, when poverty usually increases.
This is an important lesson for policymakers when the next recession hits.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.