POPLAR-COTTON CENTER, Calif. — There are some days when 16-year-old Alexa Martinez struggles to focus. Even when she’s immersed in classwork, her lingering anxiety over her family, and everything that’s gone wrong, seeps in.
Until two years ago, Alexa’s father Jose was one of the more than 200,000 people who worked in agriculture in a region that produces 40% of the fruits and nuts consumed in the United States. Then, he had a stroke. The man who once provided for the family now struggles to keep his balance. Alexa or her mother Nancy must watch over him in case he falls. Even though her school has reopened, the high school sophomore must stay at home — taking classes on a laptop from the one-room trailer her family shares — so she can watch her dad and younger siblings.
“I used to always be concentrated at school, do all my work” Alexa said. “After [his stroke], I was still trying to concentrate. But it was a little bit more difficult because I had that at the back of my mind.”
Educators and policymakers have spent decades — and billions of dollars — trying to figure out how to make it easier for students like Alexa, bright young people who face a cascade of challenges linked to poverty, succeed in school. Almost nothing has stuck. Students growing up in poverty are already lagging behind their classmates by kindergarten — and the disparities only worsen over time.
But the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan, passed in March, will test a new proposition: What does it mean for children when their families receive enough cash benefits to lift them out of poverty?
The plan includes a $100 billion expansion of the child tax credit program, which will infuse family budgets with up to $1,600 more per child, and will allow even the lowest-income families to benefit. Under the previous child tax credit, families got up to $2,000 off their tax bills per child, but the many poor families got a smaller benefit — or nothing at all.
Read More
Now, even the poorest families who do not make enough to pay income taxes will qualify.
Families with citizen children will now get $3,000 per child, and $3,600 for children under the age of six. Crucially, the benefit will be split up and paid out in monthly increments, with the money set to go out to families via checks, debit cards or direct deposits beginning July 15, the Biden administration announced.
The historic investment is expected to cut child poverty in half, according to an analysis from Columbia University’s Center on Poverty and Social Policy.
Sen. Michael Bennet, D-Colo., who has been pushing Congress to expand the child tax credit since 2015, served as the superintendent of Denver Public Schools immediately before he took office in 2009. During his four-year tenure leading the district, he worked hard to boost achievement among low-income students.
“One of the things that I came away from the experience in the school district believing was that the schools wouldn’t be able to solve all these issues on their own,” Mr. Bennet said. “We had to find ways of creating greater economic mobility for families and for kids.”
He cited a 2011 study by the National Bureau of Economic Research that found that increasing tax credits could boost test scores. “These findings suggest that there are substantial returns to public policies that help poor families with children,” wrote economists Raj Chetty and John N. Friedman, then of Harvard University, and Jonah Rockoff, of Columbia University.
They estimated the boost in academic achievement could reap gains over a child’s lifetime, increasing the likelihood they would graduate and attend college, and boosting their earnings.
Where to focus first
That theory will be tested in places like Poplar-Cotton Center, a farming community in California’s Central Valley.
At least a third of children here live below the federal poverty line, and at Pleasant View Elementary, where Alexa attended through 8th grade, 90% of students are considered economically disadvantaged.
Mark Odsather is the superintendent of the Pleasant View Elementary School District. Students at the school score poorly on standardized tests. But Mr. Odsather said they are first focused on meeting basic material and psychological needs.
“I want high academic expectations for my kids, there’s no question. But we have so many other needs that we need to address for our kids,” Mr. Odsather said.
Mr. Odsather has shaped the school around ensuring students build a relationship with at least one staff member. So classrooms are divided by movable walls, allowing students to combine for some lessons, and for students to interact with different teachers. He also hired a school psychologist whose main responsibility is providing counseling, a rare arrangement for a school of 420 students. (On average, school systems employ one psychologist for every 1,200 kids).
Yesenia Ontiveros, the daughter of two agricultural workers who grew up in the region, is the woman he hired for the job. Ms. Ontiveros knows how poverty can make learning difficult. Her parents were teenagers when she was born, and they lived in a cramped home where her bedroom was just a closet, struggling to make ends meet while picking grapes in Delano.
Then they caught a break: Her father taught himself how to code and landed a job with nearby Kern County, and the family relocated to Bakersfield. Everything changed. Her mother, relieved of the stress of surviving day-to-day, helped her study. Her father began laying out plans for her: She would graduate high school, and then get her college degree, and then work for at least five years. And then, and only then, could she start dating. Ms. Ontiveros said the financial stability allowed her parents to imagine a different kind of life for their daughter, one where she would not be confined to low-wage work.
The ‘great equalizer’
The nation’s education system has long fallen far short of its aspiration to be the “great equalizer,” where any child, rich or poor, could have an equal shot at success. Instead, research has shown that household income is one of the strongest factors shaping a child’s academic path. The pandemic has made this difficult to ignore, with schools grappling with students who did not have food, Internet or a quiet place to learn at home.
“We know that that creates a toxic situation for children as they see their parents struggling to make ends meet, struggling to pay bills, struggling to keep the lights on or a roof over their head,” said Betsy Zorio, vice president of U.S. programs and advocacy at Save the Children.
Her organization saw the desperation of its families as the pandemic wore on, deficits that could not be alleviated by after-school programs or budgeting classes. So it started the cash transfer program for the families working with the organization in California and Kentucky, giving cash gift cards of $1,000 to families enrolled in its early childhood programs, and $600 for families who sent their children to the organization’s summer program.
Save the Children is hardly the first organization to use cash grants to fight poverty. Several cities in the United States are experimenting with paying low-income residents a “universal basic income,” and some, including the Central Valley city of Stockton, have seen positive results.
In Poplar, freed from restrictions — the only prohibitions were purchasing alcohol, tobacco and firearms — families paid phone and power bills, fixed a faulty stove, purchased groceries that had been out of reach, like meat.
Children from impoverished households are already behind their more affluent classmates by the time they enter kindergarten. Students living in poverty are twice as likely to repeat a grade, and 10 times as likely to drop out of high school, researchers found a decade ago, a sequence of events that makes it difficult for them to escape it. Household income is indelibly imprinted on test scores: On the SAT, students from households that made less than $20,000 scored, on average, 400 points less than did students growing up in homes where earnings exceeded $100,000, according to 2014 data. All of this, too, is compounded by the fact schools in poor communities are often underfunded.
Now Mr. Bennet and others are watching to see what happens if the child tax credit turns permanent. What will it mean for schools that have to constantly fixate on whether their students’ material needs are being met? What will alleviating the stress of financial instability mean for students?
Ms. Ontiveros believes the money could be a game changer for families she serves and that, more than anything, it could alleviate some of the stress her students carry day-to-day. Now, she said, she has learned to detect when children are anxious simply by the way they walk. Once, she caught up with a student at the school and sensed something was wrong. After she pressed him, he melted in tears, telling her that he had contemplated suicide. He had been carrying the weight of his parents’ problems on his back, he said, and was becoming too much.
“It’s in their bodies after awhile,” Ms. Ontiveros said. “It takes a toll.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.