Planning for retirement should start years before the actual event, but change is occurring so fast with emotions running so high this year that financial adviser P.J. DiNuzzo has been amazed by the number of new clients seeking advice because they plan to accept an early retirement offer in only a few weeks.
“Anxiety levels have gone way up,” said Mr. DiNuzzo, president of DiNuzzo Private Wealth in Beaver.
“I’ve seen situations where the person could have worked for nine months and replaced the entire benefit of the early retirement package and still had a regular check,” he said. “We would have advised them against that had they come to us sooner.”
Worry and fear brought on by the COVID-19 crisis is causing more people to make hasty decisions, according to financial advisers who manage money for clients in the Pittsburgh region.
Some individuals close to retirement have liquidated all their stocks, dreading a future market crash. Some workers who lost jobs in the pandemic have begun tapping into retirement savings to help make ends meet while they ride out the storm. Others have accepted early retirement packages that may not have been in their best interest.
As if retirement planning wasn’t already stressful enough.
Read More
Even as the stock market keeps marching higher, the economic damage from the pandemic has left a trail of shut-down businesses and lost jobs across the national landscape. Industries such as hospitality, retail, restaurants and airlines have been hit hardest by workforce reductions, but teachers and government workers also are being forced to retire before they wanted to.
“The top question I get whenever we have challenging economic times like we have now is: ‘Am I going to be OK?,’ ” said Mr. DiNuzzo, who recently published a book based on his 31 years of experience as an adviser titled, “The Seven Keys to Investing Success.”
“About 50% of the time when a client calls us, it has nothing to do with money and investments,” he said. “It’s on the emotional side of the scale.”
And that’s not just true for accepting a retirement buyout.
Advisers spend a lot of time persuading clients to resist their natural urge to sell when markets drop, especially when stocks fall as hard as they did in March. Stocks tumbled 34% from Feb. 19 to March 23 on worries about the impact of the coronavirus pandemic.
By June, stocks had fully rebounded and hit new record highs.
Adam Yofan, a financial adviser at Buckingham Strategic Wealth, Downtown, said — despite his best efforts to convince them otherwise — two of his clients insisted on liquidating all stocks at the bottom of the March crash.
“They couldn’t handle the stress of the market going down. Now, they are ticked at themselves, not me,” Mr. Yofan said.
Some clients still live on pins and needles even though they stay the course. He said his clients are, for the most part, baby boomers who have never been in a situation where they could no longer replace their nest egg if it were lost.
“The acorns have got to last a 20-year winter,” Mr. Yofan said. “That’s a terrifying thought for someone no longer working.”
Clients’ expectations for the type of return they get on their retirement savings have changed over the years, he said. “The question I get asked most these days is: Do I have enough?” Mr. Yofan said.

“Twenty years ago, the question was: ‘Can I make more?’ Twenty years ago, it was the greed that got people in trouble. Now, it’s the fear.”
Retirement experts have varying opinions on how much is enough for retirement. Depending on who you ask, the answer could be somewhere in the neighborhood of $1 million, or 12 times a person’s pre-retirement salary.
Curt Knotick has been overcommunicating with his clients who are near or recently retired to reassure them their feelings are real and to evaluate how volatility has affected their long-term plan.
“It’s fair to say that with COVID-19 and the upcoming election, people are concerned with their retirements,” said Mr. Knotick, CEO of Accurate Solutions Group in Butler.
“We help our clients understand that their emphasis should be on what they can control and not what they cannot,” he said. “Markets will always be markets. Volatility has and will always be a part of that. What they can control is how they plan for it in advance.”
For people who’ve lost a job or had some other negative impact on their finances due to COVID-19, Congress included in the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) in late March a measure to allow individuals more flexibility to make emergency withdrawals from qualified retirement savings accounts during 2020.
Among other things, the CARES Act eliminates the 10% early withdrawal penalty for people under the age of 59.5. One-third of the withdrawals will be included as income in that individual’s taxes for each of the next three years.
While the legislation is meant to help people get access to cash who really need it, taking money from retirement accounts to pay for current needs increases the risk of running out of money later.
The retirement planning strategy that’s been most effective for Ashby Daniels, a financial adviser at Shorebridge Wealth Management on Washington’s Landing, has been to retrain clients on how they think about portfolio risk.
That means having them consider how many years they could go without selling equities before it would require a change in their lifestyle.
“The typical portfolio is 60% stocks and 40% bonds,” he said. “If you withdraw 4% from the portfolio each year with a 40% fixed income allocation, that gives you a 10-year buffer before you sell equities.”
With that line of thinking, he said, when the market takes a significant dip as it did in the spring, it’s easier to advise his clients to stay calm and not to sell their stocks.
“I tell them this is only Month 1 of your 10-year buffer,” Mr. Daniels said. “The day-to-day gyrations of the market should be less psychologically troubling because you have a 10-year buffer.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.