The stock market has been good to investors so far this year, but if history is any guide, they are still hoping Santa Claus will bring a little something extra in the month of December.
“I think we are all hoping for that extra boost,” said Carter Henderson, a portfolio manager at Fort Pitt Capital Group in Green Tree,
The Santa Claus rally is a seasonal phenomenon that, according to The Stock Trader’s Almanac, has yielded positive returns on 54 occasions since 1950. The rally usually occurs during the last five trading days of the year and the first two after New Year’s Day.
The lack of a rally can be an early indicator of dark clouds on the financial horizon. That was the case in 2008 and 2000: A 4% decline in December 2000 preceded the bursting of the tech bubble, and a 2.5% loss in December 2008 preceded the worst bear market in history.
But some might say Christmas came early this year, because the Santa Claus rally has already occurred during the first 11 months of the year. The S&P 500 was up 27.5% on the first trading day of December. The year-to-date gain has held steady this week at 27.7% with dividends reinvested.
“The year could stop today and the Santa Claus rally has already happened,” said Jason Staley, director of research and due diligence at Schneider Downs Wealth Management Advisors, Downtown.
“When we think of the Santa Claus rally, we tend to think we can get a couple of percent more rise based on consumer sentiment and other seasonality,” Mr. Staley said. “But I would focus investors on what has already happened in the first 11 months because those first 11 months are factoring in a very strong consumer.”
Mr. Staley said since 1936, the S&P 500 on average has delivered an annual return of 10.%. “At 17% above the average, this has been a very good year in the market,” he said.
Investors are overwhelming bullish on the stock market, according to industry insiders.
“We have half a million traders and they are net buyers,” said Anthony Denier, CEO of Webull, a commission-free trading platform based in New York that was launched 18 months ago.
“I see no reason the market will sell off in December, but you always have to throw in that Trump-tweet caveat,” Mr. Denier said. “There could always be an unexpected announcement or a trade deal falling apart. But I’m positive going into December [that] the market seems to be strong.”
This year, the investment community has a lot of optimism around trade, expecting good news in the days ahead of the Dec. 15 deadline for a U.S.-China trade agreement. Industry experts said the market expects a trade agreement and if none is reached that could create volatility that might disrupt a Santa Claus rally.
Last year happened to be one of those rare holiday seasons when U.S. stock market plunged.
“The stock market was down 2.5% for the day when I walked into church last year for Christmas Eve Mass,” Mr. Staley said.
Last year, investors were concerned the Federal Reserve was raising interest rates too quickly. This year, the Fed has been cutting rates. The central bank is not expected to lower interest rates again this month, but it’s also not expected to raise them.
This year, stock markets globally also are more synchronized in their strong performance.
“Macro economic stories sway the market every year,” Mr. Henderson said. “So, it’s not out of the realm of possibility that we get some news by the end of the year that either halts the rally or lets the rally continue higher.”
business@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.