Michigan resident Michelle Anter recently visited a PNC Bank branch in Southfield near her workplace to cash a Progressive insurance check for about $2,800.

She left fuming after PNC deducted $55 from the check as a service fee.

She doesn’t have an account with the Pittsburgh-based bank, but the check was written on Progressive’s PNC account.

She said she was appalled that it would cost so much to cash the check, since PNC could simply look at Progressive’s balance to make sure the money was there to cover it.

Advertise with us

Surely the fee was a mistake, or even illegal, she thought.

It wasn’t.

Roughly a year ago, PNC raised the fees it charges noncustomers who want to cash a check drawn on a PNC account.

Previously, the bank had charged a flat $10 for checks written on a business account, unless the business had a formal check-cashing agreement with PNC to pick up the tab on behalf of the payee. Employers sometimes do that as a courtesy for employees who don’t have bank accounts.

Under the new policy, if the business does not have an agreement to pay the $10 fee, then PNC charges 2 percent of the check’s value.

Advertise with us

The 2 percent fee also applies to noncustomers who want to cash a personal check drawn on a PNC account. Previously, that service was free.

Back when the changes were made, PNC emphasized that the check-cashing fees don’t apply to its own customers.

“PNC regularly assesses fees based on a variety of factors and we communicate changes in advance,” a spokeswoman said at the time.

It’s not unusual for banks to assess such fees. Citizens Bank, for example, charges noncustomers a flat $7, while Dollar Bank charges $9 and FNB collects $10. The fees apply to both business and personal checks.

It might seem odd that a bank wouldn’t cash one of its own checks for free because the bank can quickly check to see if it will bounce.

Advertise with us

But, according to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, there is no federal law or regulation that requires banks to cash checks for noncustomers. And if a bank chooses to do so, it’s expressly allowed to charge a fee.

Of course, people can take checks to their own bank to cash at no charge — if they have a bank account.

An estimated 8.4 million U.S. households — or roughly 6.5 percent of households — were “unbanked” in 2017, according to the latest data from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.

That rate is down from 7 percent in 2015, hitting the lowest level since the FDIC began the survey in 2009.

Ms. Anter said that in the past, she had cashed paychecks at PNC and paid $10.

Advertise with us

She continues to be flabbergasted by the new policy.

“The manager at my bank, I literally had to lift her jaw up when I told her. She said, ‘We charge $8 for that,” Ms. Anter said.

“I can’t believe it’s legal to charge those kind of fees.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.