You have your smartphone apps and your reward cards for your most frequently visited stores. You have your Amazon Prime membership and frequent flyer miles. And that tattered punch card for your favorite coffee shop.

Programs to keep reeling you into the same shops are a key component of many businesses.

In just the last week, O’Hara-based grocery chain Giant Eagle, which has built its gasoline loyalty program over the years into a regional powerhouse, announced that it is expanding its fuelperks program. And ubiquitous coffee chain Starbucks said it will revamp its rewards program so members will have more options when redeeming points.

Loyalty programs go way back.

Advertise with us

Trading stamps were a very popular program, first developed in the 1890s. People wanted to save money then, too.

“... They were extremely popular around the turn of the century and again during the depression years of the 1930s. They returned after World War II, when retailers needed some new device to attract customers.” That’s from a 1957 article by UPI, which appeared in The Pittsburgh Press.

Trading stamp companies — with names like King Korn and S&H Green Stamps — would supply retailers, like grocery stores and gas stations. The stores would hand the stamps out to customers who made purchases. Shoppers carefully collected stamps in books to redeem later for things like appliances and furniture.

One stamp was awarded for every 10 cents spent. Got your eyes on a new toaster? Pots and pans? Golf clubs? They could be yours with enough stamps.

“I remember my mom collecting Green Stamps,” said Jeff Inman, a professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s Katz School of Business. “The kids would lick them and put them in the books and whatnot.”

Advertise with us
UPI wrote in 1957: Even before Mrs. Peggy D'Andrea, of (22 Bellows Lane) Levittown, Long Island, can manage to unpack her purchases, her two children, Rosemarie, 8, and Ray, 10, team up to paste the stamps in the saver books. The kids think this sticky business is fun, and besides, there may be a premium or two for them when redemption time rolls around. (United Press Photos)

Sometimes it seems like that would be a lot of work for retailers, collecting piles of sticky books and handing out sheets of stamps that had to be carefully counted out … but it paid off.

“The big idea behind the programs is they try to engender shopper loyalty — you give customers a reason to go to that store versus a competitor,” said Mr. Inman, who also is immediate past president of the Society for Consumer Psychology.

And the closer you are to a reward level, the stronger the pull.

Herman Stubbfield and William Webb III at a Pittsburgh grocery store in the late 1960s (Detre Library & Archives at the Heinz History Center)

“If you’re not close to that free coffee and you’re choosing between Starbucks and Peet’s, you’ll probably just go to the one that’s closer,” Mr. Inman said.

Awareness of that psychological draw has infiltrated pop culture. In the Festivus episode of the TV show “Seinfeld,” Elaine went on a quest to get the final stamp on her “Atomic Sub” card.

Advertise with us

Elaine: I got a card, and they stamp it every time I buy a sub. 24 stamps, and I become a submarine captain.

Jerry: What does that mean?

Elaine: Free sub.

Kids in the 1990s and beyond likely remember clipping cereal box tops and collecting Campbell soup labels to raise money for their schools. In 2006, the Box Tops for Education program expanded to include nonfood brands like Ziploc and Kleenex. By 2010, the organization said, schools had earned over $320 million nationally.

The Campbell Labels for Education program was discontinued in recent years. Over 43 years, the company said, the program raised more than $110 million in school supplies.

Advertise with us
Giant Eagle on Atwood Street in Oakland, circa 1950. (Paul Slantis Photographs / University of Pittsburgh Library System.)

Loyalty programs are popular all over the world. It’s not just Americans watching those perks and reward card stamps.

And while discounts and cash back are appealing, it’s not always about the money.

“Monetary rewards are important everywhere, but non-monetary rewards resonate more strongly in some African/Middle Eastern countries than globally,” according to a 2016 report from Nielsen.

“Examples include recognition as a valued customer in Morocco, Egypt and Pakistan and charitable donations in Egypt and Morocco.”

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com; 412-263-4910.