A year ago, Dick’s Sporting Goods caught the national spotlight when the retailer said it would stop selling modern sporting rifles at its Field & Stream stores following the massacre at a Parkland, Fla., high school.

But the Findlay-based chain didn’t stop there, and neither did the public’s response, which ranged from calls to support the retailer’s social stance to vows of never setting foot in a Dick’s store again. Sales in the year since have taken a hit as well, but analysts say that’s not the whole story.

The company isn’t backing down and that may not hurt it too deeply in the end.

Dick’s didn’t use half measures when it made its decision to drop the modern sporting rifles. Since February 2018, the retailer also said it would not return the rifles to the manufacturer, saying instead it would destroy the guns and send the parts to a salvage company to be recycled.

Advertise with us

And recently, Dick’s went a step further. It began a test removing virtually all of the hunting products — a low-margin business — from 10 of its stores where the department was underperforming, replacing it with things like batting cages for customers to test their swing.

The Parkland response wasn’t the first round of gun activism for the company.

The retailer had pulled assault-style rifles from its namesake stores following the 2012 mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn. But it added those to its specialty Field & Stream stores when those were created in the years after the Newtown case.

Last February’s decision affected those 35 stores. In addition, Dick’s said it would no longer sell high-capacity magazines or sell firearms to anyone under 21 years old.

The response to the post-Parkland measures was more pronounced than to the earlier move, perhaps because the company made its rationale public in statements and media appearances.

Advertise with us

In addition to triggering intense debates on social media, the board of the National Shooting Sports Foundation, based in Newtown, Conn., unanimously voted to expel Dick’s from membership in May. O.F. Mossberg & Sons, a firearms manufacturer, followed suit, saying it would to stop selling products to the company.

All the changes have hurt the company’s bottom line, notes Camilla Yanushevsky, equity analyst at the research firm CFRA.

Dick’s told analysts in November that it expects full-year comparable same-store sales -— sales in stores that have been open at least a year — to slip by 3 percent to 4 percent. That compares with a 0.3 percent decline last year, she pointed out. The company plans to report its fourth-quarter and full-year earnings on March 12.

Yet, turmoil aside, the shifts that Dick’s is making could help it adapt for a changing market.

Phasing out the low-margin hunting segment gives the retailer an opportunity to devote more floor space in its stores to “higher-margin merchandise categories, including private labels, that, we believe, will fuel profitable future growth,” Ms. Yanushevsky wrote in an email.

Advertise with us

Adding more experiential things like batting cages could increase future store traffic as well, she added.

Another factor that analysts are considering is the fact that hunting just isn’t as popular as it once was, Ms. Yanushevsky said. A 2017 survey by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service showed that hunting participation had dropped by about 2 million participants to about 11.5 million hunters.

“We expect the deceleration to continue, reflecting shifting demographics toward urban areas and the acceleration of the wildlife-protectionism movement,” she said.

Also at play in the financial results is who sits in the White House. In August 2017 — even before the Florida shootings — Dick’s had reported flagging gun sales. When there’s a Republican president, guns aren’t in as high demand because stricter firearm policies are seen as less likely.

Dick’s CEO Ed Stack told analysts at the time: “On the hunting side, it is very slow growth. There is no concern about any gun reform right now based on the political situation that is in Washington today, and the inventory’s backed up.”

Advertise with us

The company did not respond to requests to comment for this story.

Sam Poser, an analyst with Susquehanna Financial Group, said that as Dick’s Sporting Goods cuts back on its hunting and electronics business, the company’s merchandise profit margins should improve.

“Hunting and electronics have been removed from 10 stores and the space was allocated to baseball, licensed and outerwear business,” Mr. Poser wrote in a note following Dick’s third-quarter call in November.

“The initial results in those 10 stores has been promising. If results continue to be good, hunting and electronics will likely be removed from more stores.”

Dick’s Sporting Goods is hardly the only company to take another look at its gun policies in the wake of mass shooting incidents.

Advertise with us

Walmart Inc. followed the Findlay retailer’s lead last year, announcing that the Arkansas-based retailer no longer would sell firearms and ammunition to those younger than 21 and it also would remove assault-style rifles from its website.

Grocery chain Kroger and sporting goods chain REI also changed their policies. In the two weeks following the Parkland shooting, more than a dozen companies — including Metlife, Hertz, Avis, Enterprise, Best Western, Wyndham and United Airlines — ended partnerships with the National Rifle Association.

Of course, there’s a difference between Walmart, the world’s biggest retailer, which can remove a product and absorb the blow, and a sporting goods chain that has a more narrow audience — even if modern sporting rifles represent a relatively small portion of the company’s sales.

“That’s the struggle retailers have,” said Jeff Inman, professor of business administration at the University of Pittsburgh. “They’re selling to everybody and any stance they take, they risk alienating a portion of their audience.”

In May, Dick’s hired a lobbying firm to push for stricter gun policy in Washington, D.C. However, that firm has reported that it hasn’t lobbied on behalf of the company since the second quarter of 2018.

Advertise with us

Oliver Hahl, assistant professor of organizational theory and strategy at Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business, said that, as the rhetoric dies down, that’s when it becomes clear how genuinely a company is holding to its stance.

“If it’s not genuine, you’d see them start to put the guns back in slowly because they’re thinking people were not noticing,” he said. “The fact that they’ve stuck with it this far is useful data.”

But there’s always a bottom line, even in cases like Dick’s where the CEO has expressed a personal commitment to the decision. Companies have to balance how much backlash might come and what that will mean for the results that Wall Street counts on.

And, as the social media reactions illustrate, retailers face pressures on both sides of this fight — from gun-rights activists and from those angry at the merchants who have sold weapons used in attacks.

“There’s fear of the boycott — will we get boycotted if we carry this? We can avoid that if guns aren’t a major part of our revenue,” Mr. Hahl said.

Advertise with us

“It’s difficult for firms to live out of pure ideology.”

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com; 412-263-4910.