For married couples planning to split, time is running out to meet a Dec. 31 deadline to nail down an agreement under the old tax rules.
How much pressure is there? Ask the lawyers.
“People are in such a rush that we have had cases where instead of meeting in our office to sign agreements, divorcing couples have met each other at notary public offices to execute their agreement and then hand delivered it to our office so that we can process the decree before the end of the year,” said Jay Blechman, a divorce attorney at Steiner & Blechman, Downtown.
Carla Donnelly, a divorce lawyer at Gentile Horoho & Avalli, Downtown, had to clear her schedule to deal with nothing but the tax deductibility issue. “There’s been plenty of late night phone calls between attorneys and clients to get this done,” she said.
This is not the norm.
December is not usually a busy month for divorce lawyers. Even when a marriage is on the rocks, nobody wants to be a Grinch when there are Christmas trees to decorate, office parties to attend and family get-togethers to plan.
“Families don’t really want to rock the boat at Christmas time, especially if there are children involved,” said Brooke McMorrow, a family law attorney in Pine. “But I certainly have worked more hours this month than I ever remember working in the month of December.”
But there’s only a few days left.
The federal Tax Cuts and Jobs Act legislation passed in November last year will go into full effect on Jan. 1, 2019, and it will rewrite rules concerning alimony and divorce that have been in place for 75 years.
Specifically, the new law will eliminate the tax deduction for spouses who pay alimony and make alimony income tax-free to the recipient.
For as long as anyone remembers, it has always been the exact reverse.
Existing divorces will not be affected and all divorces granted before the end of 2018 will fall under the current tax law — allowing ex-spouses who pay alimony to deduct the expense from their federal income taxes and requiring ex-spouses to claim the payments as taxable income.
The papers must be signed before 2019 to keep the tax break.
And that’s sometimes made an already tense situation even more high pressure.
“Spouses all over the country are sweetening divorce settlements if the recipient of the alimony payment can expedite the process and sign an agreement before the year end,” said Michael J. Herzog, a tax attorney at Eckert Seamans, Downtown.
Ms. Donnelly at Gentile Horoho & Avalli is seeing it, too.
“We’ve run into situations where would-be recipients of alimony are trying to extort more money since the husband will keep the tax benefit due to the wife cooperating before the end of the year,” she said
“We have clients willing to pay more alimony per month to get the divorce signed because the tax deductibility is so valuable to him,” she said. “We have also told receiving spouses that if they don’t sign by the end of the year any deal we have made is off.”
Alimony, which is also called spousal support, often is a part of agreements when there is a wide discrepancy in earnings between the marriage partners and when the marriage has lasted for more than a few years.
According to the Internal Revenue Service, close to 600,000 Americans claimed a spousal support deduction on their Form 1040 tax returns in 2015, totaling $12.3 billion.The data indicates 98 percent of alimony recipients that year were women.
The tax deduction has been an incentive for the higher-earning spouse to provide a higher alimony payment. Due to being in a lower tax bracket, the recipient paid less taxes on those funds, resulting in more money for both parties.
For example: If a spouse is required to pay $50,000 a year in alimony and is in the 33 percent tax bracket, that individual saves $16,500 by deducting that amount from income. If the other spouse does not work, the $50,000 alimony payments put that person in the 15 percent tax bracket owing a tax of $7,500.
The current alimony deduction is unique because it is a dollar-for-dollar deduction against the paying spouse’s income.
A person with a taxable income of $500,000 who is ordered to pay $100,000 in alimony would have taxable income reduced to $400,000. If he is in the 33 percent tax bracket, the support payments really only cost $66,000 in taxable income.
Going forward, Pennsylvania has taken steps to re-calculate its guidelines on temporary spousal support based on the new law.
Bruce Ferguson, counsel for the domestic relations procedural rules committee in Harrisburg, said the committee has reviewed issue and has proposed a new formula for determining how much temporary spousal support a paying spouse should be required to pay.
Mr. Ferguson said the calculation used to be the difference between the net income of the person paying and the net income of the person receiving support payments. The state would multiply that number by 40 percent if the couple had no children or 30 percent if there were children.
Assuming the husband earned $2,000 a month and the wife earned $1,000 a month, the $1,000 difference would be calculated by 40 percent if no children are involved — $400 a month, or 30 percent if children are involved — $300 a month.
Under the new proposed formula, the payer’s net income of $2,000 is multiplied by 25 percent to arrive at $500. The recipient’s net income of $1,000 is multiplied by 30 percent. The recipient’s $300 is subtracted from the payer’s $500 and the amount of support that would be awarded to the recipient comes to $200 a month.
“That is the tax effect change on the alimony award,” Mr. Ferguson said. “There will be no tax benefit to paying spousal support now and to balance that out is why the percentages have changed.”
All seven justices of the state Supreme Court will consider the proposed change in calculation, but it is unclear if and when they will approve it.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.