2018 Toyota Tundra 1794 Edition Crewmax: Still big and floppy?

Price: $52,730 as tested. ($50,130 for the trim level; moonroof cost $850; running boards, $345; and 20-inch chrome spokes, $110.)

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver liked the “well-equipped lineup, cavernous crew cab, and capable off-road packages,” but not the “dismal fuel economy, aging powertrains and styling.”

Marketer’s pitch: “Built to lead.”

Advertise with us

Reality: Still big, somewhat smoother, but wears on its occupants.

What’s new: Toyota’s full-size pickup led the Philadelphia Eagles parade after their Super Bowl victory in February, but what else does it have going for it? The full-size truck gets a fresh look, a TRD Sport package and Safety Sense standard.

Up to speed: The 5.7-liter V-8 creates 381 horsepower and 401-pound-feet of torque. Still, while it seemed like no great shakes for motivation, Car and Driver reports the truck takes just 6.5 seconds for 0-60. (A 4.6-liter engine is also available.)

In and out: Give Toyota credit for offering a four-wheel-drive pickup that’s quite easy to climb in and out of. The Lovely Mrs. Passenger Seat and her knees appreciate that.

Inside: The 1794 edition offers some beautiful details — brown leather trim, special shifter knob. It’s a pretty package.

Advertise with us

On the road: Mr. Driver’s Seat once called the previous incarnation of the Tundra “floppy.” It bounced and jostled and went where it wanted to, while I worked the steering wheel to rein in its worst tendencies.

This time around, I felt more cooperation from the Tundra. The steering wheel still feels quite loose, but the country-road handling is not nearly as bad.

But after our four-hour trip across the state, Sturgis Kid 4.0 reported succinctly, “It’s the bounciest truck.” And he was right. The worn-down right lanes of the Pennsylvania Turnpike got tiresome after a while, and even shorter drives were a little more “ride ’em cowboy” than I might have liked.

In the rain: We experienced torrential nighttime thunderstorms while traveling through central Pennsylvania — so heavy that it took a while for the windshield to clear — but the Tundra never slipped an inch, a great feature in a pickup with a light rear end.

Shifty: The beautiful shifter knob in the 1794 edition matches the rest of the lovely interior. The transmission never lurched or jumped, as a good transmission should.

Advertise with us

It has a gear selector mode as well, but Toyota doesn’t provide any real shifting capability, just gear limiting. Sigh.

Friends and stuff: The rear seat splits 60-40 to provide a flat compartment inside the truck. Rear seat room was just fine according to Sturgis Kid 4.0, all 6-feet-2 of him.

The bed in this edition is 5.5 feet long, which surprisingly didn’t seem so bad for hauling debris to the township compost pile. A 6.5-foot and an 8-foot bed are also available.

The Tundra payload maxes out at 1,730 pounds, but not with this bed.

I used the Tundra to haul some small pieces of furniture and yard debris, and found plenty of hooks — both low and high — made tie-downs easy.

Advertise with us

Play some tunes: If you can hear them. As back-seat passenger Sturgis Kid 4.0 further commented after our four-hour ride, “It probably was the world record for a noisy truck.” He said he could hear it right through his ear buds.

The exhaust note makes for fun sounding startups and pullouts, but just droned on and on — especially in the rear seat, evidently.

But I digress — the Tundra stereo sounds like most Toyota stereos — heavy on the treble and bass, but not much richness in the middle, where most music lives.

Operation of the unit was easy, with buttons to get you some places — but not to change the music source — while knobs control volume and tuning.

Keeping warm and cool: I like that the Tundra sticks with round HVAC vents — so simple to direct and close.

Advertise with us

Operation of the system is fairly simple, with dials for temperature and fan and source buttons.

Fuel economy: I averaged just under 14 mpg in a highway-heavy round of testing. Quite disappointing.

Where it’s built: San Antonio, Texas.

How it’s built: Consumer Reports says its reliability will be a 5 out of 5. Last year was a 4, but previous years were also 5s.

In the end: In a world where an F-150 handles like a car, and where Ram 1500s used to, a Tundra is a lot more than you need to handle, although that Toyota reliability is hard to pass up.

Scott Sturgis is a freelance auto writer; mrdriversseat@gmail.com.