Insurance agents across the Pittsburgh region have been busy this summer, as the skies continue to open up and TV weather teams warn of the potential for flooding.

Fifty years after the National Flood Insurance Program was created to help communities at high risk from water, property owners are increasingly getting coverage from private insurers who have planted a stake in the market — often offering cheaper plans even as frustrations with the national program mount.

“Part of the issue with the NFIP is you’re really at the mercy of what the government decides,” said Heather Hartland, an agent with FWF Insurance Agency Inc. in Johnstown.

Ms. Hartland was referring to surcharges added three years ago. Those looking to insure a primary residence must now pay a $25 annual surcharge, while those insuring nonprimary residences and other buildings were slapped with a $250 annual surcharge.

Advertise with us

Those are among many changes the national program has made as it grapples with declining enrollment and a massive debt that has reached $20.5 billion.

But some question whether private insurers are luring away lower risk customers and putting the national program — created in the 1960s because insurance companies would not sell flood insurance — even further at risk.

Beyond the obvious reminders of the dangers of flooding delivered by a wet summer, flood insurance has become an issue for some property owners as a result of revisions of flood zones.

The national program, which is run by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, designates some areas as “flood-hazard areas.” Building owners with a federally backed mortgage whose property is in one of these areas are required to buy flood insurance.

Recent remapping has included some Pennsylvania properties in flood zones that weren’t before — meaning people living there with a mortgage had to pay up for flood insurance.

Advertise with us

Prime time for private market

Private insurance agents have capitalized on the growing volatility of the national program, which Congress narrowly re-authorized in July through the end of November.

Technology also played a part: According to a report from the Congressional Research Service, private insurers now have access to more accurate analytics and data that allow them to assess the flood risk for a property.

“This really became an opportunity for the private sector to say, ‘Hey, we think we can do this job a little more effectively, a little more efficiently,” said Eric Ash, a Farmers Insurance agent in Elizabeth.

Mr. Ash has been offering private insurance since last fall through the insurer NFS Edge, and he estimates the private policies now account for 10 percent of his total flood policies. He also works with the government’s program.

Advertise with us

Because he works in the Mon Valley — sandwiched between the Monongahela and Youghiogheny rivers — Mr. Ash said he sees a lot of people looking to buy flood insurance.

In Pennsylvania, private flood insurance could tap into a big industry. According to FEMA data, in the two decades between 1996 and 2016, over 35,000 claims were paid out by the national program in Pennsylvania, adding up to more than $700 million.

All about the cost

Except for homes or businesses in particularly high-risk zones, private plans can often be less expensive.

Mr. Ash recently ran the numbers for a home worth $140,000, with $40,000 worth of contents inside. The quote he got from the national program had a premium of roughly $2,840. A similar private plan had a yearly premium of $1,450.

Advertise with us

There are other ways that private flood insurance can be more attractive than the federal plan: Private plans can go above the $250,000 cap single-family dwellings have on structure coverage and the $100,000 cap on contents coverage.

“It really does provide some options, whereas before it felt like, ‘This is a square box we’re going to put you in,’” Mr. Ash said.

Gerald Jacoby, an insurance agent in Sharpsburg, said plans from private insurers often have much broader coverage options — such as business interruption coverage.

Mr. Jacoby, who began selling private flood insurance three years ago, said 70 percent of his flood polices are from private insurers. He estimated the private plans he sells are about 30 percent cheaper than the national program plans.

Antonio Fratangelo,  who rents office space from Mr. Jacoby, didn’t know the O’Hara home he was about to close on in 2016 was in a flood zone until his mortgage lender told him there would be an extra $400 a month charge for the required insurance.

Advertise with us

Scrambling to find a cheaper alternative, Mr. Fratangelo said he found a private plan with a $1,400 yearly premium by searching online.

When that price increased earlier this year, he went to Mr. Jacoby, who found a plan for $1,300 a year.

“It simply just came down to cost and understanding of what exactly I was getting,” Mr. Fratangelo said.

When his split-level home took on five feet of water in early July, Mr. Fratangelo got an unwelcome chance to see the private flood market in action. So far, he has no complaints.

A sinking national program

Advertise with us

Private flood insurance is still dwarfed by the national program. A recent study from the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania estimates between 3.5 and 4.5 percent of all residential flood polices are from private insurers.

Because the private market can turn down insuring high-risk properties there are concerns the national program will be left with increasingly risky properties.

The more lower-risk properties “cherry-picked” from the national program, the less money it will have, said Bob Hunter, the director of insurance with the Consumer Federation of America.

“It’s kind of a death spiral,” he said.

Jessica Altman, Pennsylvania’s insurance commissioner, disputes the notion that cherry-picking could tank the national program, noting that many avoid buying flood insurance if they can.

Advertise with us

“The private market can’t cherry-pick from the NFIP because the cherries are still on the trees,” Ms. Altman said.

Flood-hazard areas mapped out by FEMA aren’t necessarily inclusive of all the areas at risk of flooding, Ms. Altman said, noting 20 percent of claims that the national insurance program pays out are from outside the flood areas.

“I think I’m looking at this as more ‘People need to have flood insurance, and however they choose to get it, great,’” Ms. Altman said.

In Pennsylvania, Ms. Altman said the growth of private flood insurance has been largely without incident, and that she hasn’t heard about mortgage lenders not accepting private flood insurance.

Some have raised concerns about the type of companies offering private flood insurance, which are largely surplus-line insurers or insurers who cover more risky things than the more mainstream companies will.

Advertise with us

Ms. Altman said the surplus-line insurers are not subject to guarantee funds or the mechanism the state has in place to step in if an insurance company finds itself unable to pay out claims.

Still, she said, the surplus-line companies offering private flood insurance do have to follow state guidelines. And, because many of them closely mirror the national program’s policies, Ms. Altman said, the industry is generally trusting of the companies.

“There is a comfort level at least where the market is at right now related to private coverage,” she said.

Nora Shelly: 412-263-1936 or nshelly@post-gazette.com.