Pennsylvanians whose Independence Day plans include Roman candles and bottle rockets may be in for a punch to the pocketbook this week, as the state collects a hefty tax on the newly legal pyrotechnics — nearly 20 percent in Allegheny County.

Wednesday will be the first Fourth of July celebration since the legislature enacted provisions last fall making aerial fireworks legal for the first time in nearly 80 years — and slapping a 12 percent tax on the amusement products.

According to the state Department of Revenue, the levy is applied after Pennsylvania’s sales tax of 6 percent and any local sales tax. In Allegheny County, where the local sales tax rate is 1 percent, that adds up to a total tax of 19.8 percent.

Novelties that do not leave the ground, like sparklers and spinners, long have been allowed in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us
Jocelyn Golomb (left), 21, Monessen, poses in the doorway of B & D Fireworks with former Mayor of Monessen Lou Mavrakis (right) on Tuesday, June 26, 2018, Monessen. Mavrakis is an avid customer of the store, and Golomb has been working there the past 3 years. (Rebecca Lessner / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The new law allows residents to launch devices classified as “consumer fireworks” by the Federal Consumer Products Safety Commission. These include Roman candles, bottle rockets, firecrackers and some types of reloadable aerial shell launchers.

Display fireworks, which contain more than 130 grams of of explosives, and large aerial shells remain illegal outside licensed displays. The law also prohibits the use of fireworks by people who are intoxicated or those under 18, and specifies that they may not be used near occupied buildings or vehicles.

Shoppers seem to be stocking up for some big holiday displays.

“We’ve had a lot more people coming out,” said Jocelyn Golomb, of B&D Fireworks in Monessen. The store opened several weeks earlier than usual this year, and the number of customers had doubled since last year, she said.

Owner of B & D Fireworks Buzzy Byron, Monessen, in the doorway of his store on Tuesday, June 26, 2018, Monessen. (Rebecca Lessner / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Buzzy Byron, also of B&D, said the average customer buys between $250 and $300 of fireworks, though kits can range from $29 to $799.

Advertise with us

Reloadable mortars, which use a plastic tube to fire shells that explode in the air with a bang and a burst of light, have been the most popular products, he said.

Abby Unis, of A-Rocket Fireworks in Aliquippa, said she has seen several new customers each day this summer, but there “hasn’t been a noticeable change in sales yet.”

The change in Pennsylvania’s laws was passed in October as part of a budget-balancing scheme, although the placement of fireworks regulations in the tax code has drawn some criticism, including a lawsuit by several fireworks sellers.

Pennsylvania is only the latest of several states to abandon decades-old fireworks legislation in favor of higher tax revenue.

A 2016 law in West Virginia allowed the sale of consumer fireworks at a 12 percent tax rate. Georgia imposed a 5 percent tax on newly allowed fireworks sales in 2015. Indiana permitted the sale of fireworks with a 5 percent tax rate in 2006.

Advertise with us
Jocelyn Golomb (left), 21, Monessen, helps Robert Gladys (right), Monessen, check out Fireworks at B & D Fireworks on Tuesday, June 26, 2018, Monessen. Pennsylvania changed its fireworks law last fall, allowing residents to buy aerial fireworks for the first time in decades. Gladys says he has been a customer of the store for three years and buys fireworks "Just for fun." (Rebecca Lessner / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In Pennsylvania, the state’s Independent Fiscal Office estimated the fireworks legislation would produce about $2.5 million in tax revenue and another $500,000 in increased fees for the licensing of firework sellers.

The state previously collected regular sales taxes on fireworks, but did not maintain granular data on the sources of collections.

While the long-term fiscal impact in the Keystone State remains unclear, other states’ experiences have been mixed. In West Virginia, the 12 percent fireworks tax raised only $778,796 during fiscal 2017, according to the state. That was barely more than a third of the $2.1 million expected when the law passed.

West Virginia’s tax department said the disappointing revenue was mostly a result of competition from neighboring states with lower taxes.

In Indiana, where the tax rate is only 5 percent, 2017 fireworks tax revenues totaled $2.8 million, according to the state’s Department of Revenue. Per person, the Indiana and West Virginia fireworks tax revenues were almost identical, at 43 cents per resident, based on U.S. Census data.

Advertise with us

In Georgia, a 5 percent fireworks tax raised only 12 cents per person, totaling about $1.2 million in 2017, according to the Georgia Department of Revenue.

Fireworks tax revenue: predictions, results Pennsylvania is the latest of several states to allow fireworks sales in exchange for a hefty tax. For some states, revenues have outpaced predictions, while in others, they have been much lower. Fireworks taxes collected per person, by selected states, 2017 (fiscal year)

Created with Highstock 6.1.0Tax dollars per capita$0.37$0.37$1.16$1.16$0.48$0.48$0.2$0.2$0.43$0.43$0.43$0.43$0.12$0.12PredictionActualIndianaWest VirginiaGeorgiaPennsylvania*$0$0.2$0.4$0.6$0.8$1$1.2$1.4

*Pennsylvania's 2017 data not yet available. Sources: Georgia Department of Revenue, Indiana Department of Revenue, West Virginia State Tax Department, Pennsylvania Independent Fiscal Office, U. S. Census | James Hilston/Post-Gazette

Pennsylvania’s results have yet to be determined, but the estimated $2.5 million in tax revenue would represent about 20 cents per person, squarely between the collections of Georgia and Indiana.

Advertise with us

The new fireworks tax raised $406,723 on sales from November 2017 through April 2018 in Pennsylvania, according to the Department of Revenue.

But the vast majority of fireworks sales occur during the summer (about 95 percent in Indiana and nearly 80 percent in West Virginia), so tax collections from June and July should provide a clearer picture.

Consumers wince at the tax rate

Though Pennsylvania’s fireworks retailers may benefit from higher sales, some have balked at the tax rate and increases in permit fees. Permanent facilities must now pay an annual fee of $10,000 to maintain their licenses, up from $5,000 charged under the old law.

“We’ve had a lot of complaints about the 12 percent tax,” said Darrin Iams, of Fireworks by DNT, located in West Alexander near the West Virginia border.

Advertise with us

Mr. Iams called the impact of the $10,000 licensing fee “significant” relative to total sales. He had to borrow money to cover the unexpected increase, and had to spend $2,300 on a new point-of-sale system to administer the tax. He said he has not seen a corresponding increase in sales.

“[The increased license fee] sucks, but it doesn’t impact us enough that we’re going to say, ‘No more business,’ ” said Ms. Unis of A-Rocket. “And the 12 percent [tax] is just crazy.”

DNT and A-Rocket also face increased competition from temporary tents, which were previously illegal.

The temporary installations pay a much lower licensing fee of $4,000, but can only sell fireworks during limited periods around July 4 and Jan. 1. According to the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture, 302 temporary facilities have been licensed to operate, compared to just 82 permanent stores.

“I don’t agree with the way they put this through,” said Mr. Iams. “It needs to be cleaned up.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Unis and Mr. Iams are not alone in their opposition to the new law.

“The legislature was just very hung up on raising money,” said William Weimer, vice president of Phantom Fireworks, which operates seven stores across Pennsylvania. Mr. Weimer said he was worried about ambiguous wording in the statue related to fire safety.

Lawsuit challenges the Pa. law

The Youngstown, Ohio, company is making the same argument in court.

In January, Phantom was joined by five Pennsylvania stores selling Sky King fireworks in bringing a lawsuit against Gov. Tom Wolf and other state officials, asking for all of Act 43, which includes a wide variety of tax and regulatory provisions, in addition to the new fireworks rules, to be declared unconstitutional.

Advertise with us

In their civil complaint filed in the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court, the companies allege the law violates constitutional requirements that legislation must concern a single subject and that acts’ purposes must be clearly expressed by their titles.

They also claim the law’s reliance on safety standards developed by the National Fire Protection Association unconstitutionally delegates rule making. Finally, the companies say the legislature did not follow proper procedures when it repealed the previous fireworks law.

In a brief to the court, attorneys representing the governor and the secretaries of agriculture and revenue call the lawsuit a “kitchen sink challenge,” and argue the fireworks companies did not have standing to sue because they did not suffer any harm from the law.

In addition, they claim the entire law concerns the single subject of taxes, and the procedures used in passing it did not violate the constitution. They say reliance on rules developed by the NFPA is permissible because the legislature made the basic policy choices related to fire saftey.

Drew Crompton, an attorney for Pennsylvania Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati, claimed the fireworks companies were using the lawsuit as “leverage” in a legislative fight.

Advertise with us

“They don’t like the policy and now they’re making it about the procedure,” he said.

Ben Mikek: bmikek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3852.