Your natural instinct to run when faced with a bear in the woods could save your life — as long as you are able to outrun the bear.

But your instinct to withdraw cash from a bank certificate of deposit during the next recession could cause you to lose money.

That is the conclusion of a new behavioral economics study that found people’s natural anxiety about money caused them to make poor financial decisions during the Great Recession and its aftermath.

In particular, bank customers made a mad dash to yank money from certificates of deposit, which are term accounts that were paying an average of 1.26 percent interest at the time. For the most part, they moved the money to checking, savings and money market accounts —liquid accounts that were paying an average of only 0.23 percent interest.

Advertise with us

Hence, a recent study with the very academic title of “Dynamics of Yield Gravity” infers that money anxiety caused by the stress of the recession prevented banking customers from earning 500 percent greater interest on their deposits with no risk at all to their money.

As the economy went into free fall and fear gripped many households, people guided by basic survival instincts found a greater sense of comfort piling up their money in liquid accounts that could be readily accessed in case of an emergency.

“It is a compelling study because it introduces a new dimension to how people make financial decisions,” said Dan Geller, a behavioral finance expert based in San Francisco. “Moreover, it challenges the conventional thinking about interest rates. The prevailing theory of interest rates is that yields attract money and higher yields attract more money.

“If someone offers an investment paying 2 percent and someone else offers an investment paying 10 percent at the same level of risk, the assumption is that people will gravitate toward the 10 percent investment. This is the foundation of our financial system. However, the study shows this is not always the case.”

Mr. Geller focused his study on deposits insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. between December 2007 and December 2012.

Advertise with us

During that period, the annual percentage yield of liquid accounts made up of checking, savings and money markets decreased at nearly the same rate as that of term accounts consisting of bank CDs — 87 percent and 87.9 percent, respectively.

During that same period, the balances of term accounts decreased by 22 percent.

The balances of liquid accounts increased by 78.9 percent.

The greater percentage increase in liquid savings accounts suggests that all of the money that went into liquid accounts came from sources other than CDs. The money flowing to liquid accounts also could have included cash raised from the sale of stocks and real estate.

Most bank deposits are risk-free because they are insured by the FDIC up to $250,000. However, people who own bank CDs are penalized for withdrawing from them before the end of the term, which could stretch from one month to 60 months.

Advertise with us

While funds held at banks may have shifted from one account to another, the total amount consumers are stashing in banks has doubled since the financial crisis.

According to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Americans had $6.9 trillion deposited in U.S. commercial banks before the Great Recession. Consumer deposits total $12.1 trillion today.

In December 2007, which is the official start of the Great Recession, FDIC-insured banks had $2.6 trillion in CD balances and $4.3 trillion in liquid balances.

Although interest rates are rising, CDs have yet to make a comeback to pre-recession levels. FDIC-insured institutions currently hold total CD balances of $1.7 trillion and total liquid balances of $10.4 trillion.

“Today when people feel the economy deteriorating or we are faced with recession, the instinctive response is to decrease spending and increase savings,” said Mr. Geller, author of the 2013 book “Money Anxiety.”

Advertise with us

There’s nothing wrong with stashing money as long as savers aren’t losing so much of it by making rash decisions that end up being counterproductive.

“In the old days we hoarded food and wood,” Mr. Geller said. “Now we hoard money when faced with uncertainty.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591. 

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.