Despite an exodus to digital banking in recent years, 60 percent of Americans still open a checking account the old-fashioned way inside a bank branch, talking to a human, rather than online or using a smartphone, a new survey has found.
The use of branches was strongest among the 65 and over age group (78 percent), and weakest among those age 25-34 (46 percent), according to the study by consulting firm Novantas based in New York City.
Customers weren’t asked why they opted for one method over the other, but other Novantas research suggests several factors, said Matthew Sharp, head of customer knowledge for the company.
In some cases, banks don’t allow people to open checking accounts electronically. Most often, he said, customers try to open an account online or with an app, but it ends up being “such a headache” that they go to a branch.
Another factor is customers not being aware that they can open a checking account digitally, said Andrew Hovet, a director at Novantas.
Because of the “hiccups” some people experience electronically, banks don’t market the feature — fearing that those who have problems will take their business elsewhere, he said.
Although 40 percent of Americans say they prefer opening a checking account digitally, only about 10 percent end up doing it that way, researchers said.
It all points to the need for banks to do a better job of meeting demand by making the digital experience friendlier, or risk losing more market share to non-bank competitors, they said.
When it came to opening credit card and savings accounts, customers strongly preferred digital channels. Researchers said that was no surprise given the tremendous digital push by card issuers and the emergence of high-yield, online-only savings products.
The findings were based on email responses from 4,351 people in October.
The survey also found a “moderate to strong” lingering attachment to traditional banks, with half of U.S. customers feeling that online-only institutions were “less legitimate” than those with branches.
“People want to know there is a branch nearby in case there is an issue ... so they can resolve it face to face,” Mr. Sharp said.
That sentiment is a warning to banks not to go overboard when scaling back their branch networks, Mr. Hovet said. “Because a majority of customers still have emotional attachment to branches, banks have to be careful how far and how fast they make cuts,” he said.
On the flip side, with fewer customers visiting branches for everyday transactions, banks that want to enter new markets may be able to become formidable competitors with fewer and smaller branches than in the past, he said.
That could be behind the thinking of Bank of America, which in January announced it was planning to expand into the Pittsburgh region by opening its first three retail branches here in Upper St. Clair, Wexford and East Liberty.
The nation’s second biggest bank — which has had commercial lending operations in Pittsburgh for about 20 years — said it would open an unspecified number of additional branches in the region over the next few years.
When asked about the types of technology customers prefer as a substitute for getting help in person at a branch, respondents were the most comfortable with chatting online with a person, followed by an automated chat, the survey found.
Consumers were least comfortable with getting customer service from the bank via video conference, Novantas said.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.