As the House narrowly passed a budget resolution to kick off a fast-paced debate on overhauling the U.S. tax code, a lingering obstacle re-emerged: whether or how to limit a federal tax break that benefits high-tax states including New York and New Jersey.

President Donald Trump and congressional Republican leaders have proposed abolishing the state and local tax deduction -- a prospect that prompted many GOP lawmakers in those states to vote against the budget. It passed, 216-212.

Bank shares reached a decade high after the House vote. The KBW bank index gained as much as 1.2 percent to reach the highest intraday level since November 2007. Bank of America Corp. was up as much as 1.2 percent to the highest level since October 2008, while JPMorgan Chase & Co. rose as much as 1.4 percent to a record high.

The vote set off a three-week sprint to introduce a bill, consider it in committee and pass it through the chamber before Thanksgiving. But the protest votes from New York and New Jersey surrounding the so-called SALT deduction reflect the difficult balancing act ahead for House tax writers.

Advertise with us

A leader of the bloc supporting SALT said that despite the budget’s passage, the tax bill itself cannot pass until GOP leaders deal definitively with the issue.

“I know, and they know, that there were people that voted yes only to keep the process going forward but who disagree with the fact that we don’t have a deal yet,” said Rep. Tom MacArthur, R-N.J., who joined 19 other GOP House members in voting against the budget. “Without a deal, tax reform can’t move forward. This isn’t over.”

In reality, it hasn’t even begun. While House leaders including Majority Whip Steve Scalise and Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady pledged to help resolve the SALT impasse, various contentious issues remain.

Brady said after the vote that he plans release a House tax bill by Nov. 1 -- which is expected to usher in a frenzy of lobbying as various interest groups vie to preserve their favored tax breaks. One example: Brady has hinted that tax writers are considering changes to retirement savings -- putting investment managers on alert.

On the Senate side, Tim Scott, a Republican on the chamber’s tax-writing Finance Committee, said Thursday they’re making progress on the Senate’s version of a tax bill and hope to introduce it “in a couple of weeks.”

Advertise with us

A Wednesday deadline to introduce a bill sets up what is likely to be several days of intense lobbying to shape measure.

Other still-unresolved questions: whether the legislation would moderate the expected benefits for the wealthy; whether it would cap or eliminate the popular tax benefit of 401(k) retirement plans; and how dramatically it would expand a child care tax credit that helps working-class families. Also on the table were several critical questions about how the corporate tax code would change.

Amid the rush, plans for ending the various tax breaks -- which are key to helping to offset the deep tax-rate cuts that Trump and congressional leaders want to achieve -- have been kept under wraps.

Lawmakers planned to spend the coming days trying to resolve those concerns, with hopes that they would avoid the kind of interparty squabbles that have doomed other major legislative efforts this year. They also hoped to avoid unexpected criticism from Trump, who has railed against GOP hopes of overhauling the 401(k) provision.

Asked Friday if he was concerned that Trump might undermine the effort, House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., said - half jokingly - that his party’s leader would be beginning a lengthy trip to Asia next week.

Advertise with us

“He’s going to be in Asia, No. 1,” Ryan said. “No, I’m just kidding. That was kind of a joke. I was sort of joking on that one.”

Ryan went on to say that he was working closely with the White House on the bill, but several senior administration officials said they had not seen a final draft of what the tax plan would look like.

Now that the budget blueprint has been adopted, a hard reality will set in as the business community and others realize how much of the tax bill will involve closing loopholes and changing their credits and deductions, said Sen. Bob Corker, a Republican member of the Senate Budget Committee. He said that will be “80 percent of the work.”

The GOP tax framework calls for doubling the standard deduction for individuals and reducing the current seven income brackets to three -- 12 percent, 25 percent and 35 percent, with a possible fourth bracket for top earners.

The corporate tax rate would be slashed to 20 percent from 35 percent, and pass-through business income -- now taxed at rates as high as 39.6 percent -- would face a top rate of 25 percent.

Advertise with us

In the absence of details on how to pay for those rate reductions, the fight over the SALT deduction is instructive. Repealing the tax break would generate an estimated $1.3 trillion over 10 years. If it’s not fully repealed, lawmakers will have another revenue hole to fill.

They can’t afford many such holes: The budget they passed Thursday -- which had already cleared the Senate -- allows for increasing the deficit by $1.5 trillion. House leaders say economic growth stemming from their tax overhaul would help plug that gap. Regardless, Brady and others will be under pressure to preserve every revenue-enhancing provision they can.

Some observers seem to think “we’ve got a $1.5 trillion tax cut that’s taking care of this,” said Corker, who’s pushed for a tax bill not to add to the deficit after reasonable economic growth is taken into account. “Over the next two weeks, especially when the Senate tax-writing committee puts their stuff out, they’re going to realize that this the biggest tax code rewrite since 1986 and it’s going to affect everyone.”

Brady acknowledged Thursday morning that the “no” votes on the budget show that several GOP lawmakers need the SALT issue resolved before they support tax legislation. “We continue to hone through some solutions and what it means for their taxpayers,” he said of the House members who are concerned about the deduction.

Ryan referred questions about the deduction to Brady’s Ways and Means panel during a press conference following the budget vote. He stressed that “the entire purpose” of the tax bill will be to cut middle-class taxes.

Advertise with us

Ryan didn’t answer a question about rumored changes to retirement savings vehicles, saying the House tax-writing committee should be given “the latitude they need to write their legislation.”

In sidestepping the question, he avoided aligning with Trump, who this week called for making no changes to workers’ 401(k) contributions.

Trump told reporters Wednesday that preserving the 401(k) tax-deferred retirement plans is very important to him. Earlier in the week he said on Twitter that there would be “NO change to your 401(k),” calling the plans a “great and popular” tax break for the middle class.

Brady hasn’t ruled out changes to retirement plans. He said Wednesday that Republicans are “exploring a number of ideas” to “create an incentive for Americans to save more and save sooner.”

Sen. Rob Portman, a top Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, said that while no final decision has been made, he anticipates that the Senate version of the tax legislation will largely leave intact current tax breaks for 401(k)s.

Advertise with us

“I think there’s an understanding that we need to preserve the retirement incentive,” said the Ohio Republican.

The Washington Post contributed.