The White House’s tolerance for reasoned dissent being what it is, it’s no surprise that Kevin Hassett, chairman of President Donald Trump’s Council of Economic Advisers, took umbrage with the Tax Policy Center’s analysis of his bloviating boss’s tax “reform” plan.
Among other things, the center concluded that, based on the bare-bones proposal Mr. Trump has outlined to date, federal revenue could be reduced by as much as $7.8 trillion over the next decade. If tax increases included in the proposal or mentioned by Mr. Trump during his campaign were enacted, the 10-year cost would be reduced to a mere $3.5 trillion, the center concluded.
In an Oct. 5 speech at the center, Mr. Hassett, being the mild-mannered economist that he is, called his host’s analysis “scientifically indefensible” and “based on many fictions.”
That’s some assessment of the center, which is a joint venture of the Urban Institute and Brookings Institution, and its personnel, who are experts in tax, budget and social policy and have served in senior government positions.
But Mr. Hassett’s assertion regarding fiction at least had a ring of credibility to it, given his past writing.
Nearly two decades ago, when animal spirits ruled the stock market, Mr. Hassett took exception with the party poopers who insisted that Judgment Day was at hand. He co-authored “Dow 36,000” with James Glassman, a classic tome of financial fiction if there ever was one.
“Stock prices could double, triple or even quadruple tomorrow and still not be too high,” Mr. Hassett and his co-conspirator wrote in a September 1999 piece for The Atlantic.
The duo accused analysts and media pundits of being wrong for warning that stocks were extremely risky. Experts aren’t good at predicting what the market will do, he wrote, but “they are brilliant at scaring people.”
And as for Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan’s infamous warning about irrational exuberance three years earlier, Mr. Hassett and Mr. Glassman had this to say: “Many investors are rationally [their italics] exuberant. They have bid up the prices of stocks because stocks are a great deal.”
Eighteen years and two bear markets later, the Dow has topped 23,000. The widely watched index would have to ride an aging bull market up another 57 percent to get to where Mr. Trump’s chief economist thought it should have been years ago.
So when it comes to fiction, Mr. Hassett is a credible source.
Which is why his claim that Mr. Trump’s plan to cut the corporate tax rate to 20 percent from 35 percent would increase average household income by at least $4,000 annually deserves some scrutiny.
Mr. Hassett said that is a conservative estimate. He believes Mr. Trump’s plan will encourage U.S. corporations to repatriate offshore profits that are currently subject to tax. Companies will invest that money, generating economic activity that will lead to higher wages, he reasons.
The benevolent, generous nature of overpaid CEOs notwithstanding, remember that when companies were granted a tax holiday on offshore profits in 2004, they “invested” it mostly in dividends and stock buybacks — not in raising their workers’ wages. And never mind the fact that up to 60 percent of Americans oppose cutting corporate taxes.
The Tax Policy Center’s Howard Gleckman responded to Mr. Hassett’s assertion by saying the $4,000 claim “is based on some sloppy and highly controversial methodology.” While a tax cut may raise wages some, Mr. Hassett’s “conservative” estimate “is simply not supported by either the facts on the ground or the academic research,” he wrote on Wednesday.
Common folk don’t have the economic talent or time to determine where the truth lies. Instead, they must look at more elemental factors in deciding whether Mr. Trump’s idea of tax reform is gigantic tax cuts for companies and the affluent or trickle-down economics that will benefit the middle class.
They must decide for themselves whether the richest president in U.S. history, someone who has surrounded himself with a cabinet of billionaires, who refuses to release his tax returns and who embraces fiction across the policy spectrum, should be taken at his word.
Sooner or later, common folk will reach the obvious conclusion.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.