At the end of May, Hill District Federal Credit Union CEO Richard Witherspoon received a visit from a PNC Bank representative that left him flabbergasted.
After some 45 years as a customer, the credit union would have 30 days to find somewhere else to bank, Mr. Witherspoon was told. The reason? The institution, with some 3,000 members, no longer fit the bank’s business model.
“I was in total shock,” Mr. Witherspoon said in an interview last week. “I couldn’t believe it.”
He began transitioning the credit union’s checking and savings accounts to First National Bank, which like the credit union and PNC, has an office on Centre Avenue.
He said he never received a formal letter or notice from PNC that the accounts would be closed. When he showed up one day near the end of June to make a daily deposit, the teller told him the accounts had been closed and the balances had been mailed to the credit union.
“It’s very sad that PNC Bank has chosen to sever such a long-term relationship in such a callous way,” Mr. Witherspoon wrote in a blog post that appeared on Facebook recently.
PNC spokeswoman Diane Zappas declined to talk specifically about the Hill District credit union, citing the bank’s privacy policy.
But she emailed a statement saying, “PNC periodically reviews its relationships with business customers across a variety of dimensions, including profitability, nature and type of account, and adherence to applicable policies and requirements.”
The Hill District credit union, founded in 1970, has assets of $5 million and serves people who live, work or worship in the Hill District. Roughly 20 percent of credit unions nationwide have assets of $5 million or under, according to the Credit Union National Association, the trade association for credit unions.
Because of its relatively small size, the credit union doesn’t deal directly with the Federal Reserve, so it needs a bank like PNC to provide depository and check-clearing services, Mr. Witherspoon said.
He said his biggest beef with PNC is how it went about closing the credit union’s accounts without any official notice in writing.
“After that many years of a relationship and just to show up and say we are closing your account … seems a bit rough,” he said.
The bank’s actions felt like “a kick in the gut,” he said.
In the past, PNC was there for the credit union during a difficult period financially, Mr. Witherspoon said. The Pittsburgh-based bank made a substantial deposit in the early 1990s to give the credit union more funds to lend out.
Ms. Zappas said PNC “continues to support the mission of the Hill District FCU, and remains an investor in the organization.”
Nevertheless, Mr. Witherspoon remains disappointed.
“Pittsburgh is PNC’s hometown,” he said. “Maybe they have just outgrown their backyard.”
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.