The emotional impact of president-elect Donald Trump's victory in Tuesday's general election took financial markets on a wild ride that drove some worried investors to the brink of liquidating all their stocks, while others were so confident of a sunny future they wanted to go on a buying spree when stock markets opened Wednesday.
At one point overnight, Dow index futures had dropped about 800 points, but then dramatically changed course and rallied to open only 15 points lower this morning than it had closed Tuesday. The same thing happened in fixed income markets, where a flight to quality sent yields on 10-year U.S. Treasuries to 1.70 percent overnight before reversing direction to close at just above 2 percent.
"That is possibly the biggest swing over a 12-hour period in stock market history," said Aaron Leaman, chief investment officer at Signature Financial Planning in Mt. Washington. "I've been doing this for 12 years and I can't recall a larger swing in a 12-hour period. Last night was about emotion. This morning we are seeing a bit more rationality and perspective creeping into people's decisions.”
Major market indexes ended high Wednesday, with the S&P 500 rising 1.1 percent and the Dow Jones Industrials up 1.4 percent.
The performance of local stocks Wednesday indicated the market’s initial interpretation of which industries will benefit from a Trump presidency.
U.S. Steel surged ahead 17 percent to close at $24.56, up $3.60, as investors bet Mr. Trump would make good on his rhetoric about renegotiating trade agreements and reviving Big Steel’s glory days. Ampco-Pittsburgh, which supplies the steel industry, and AK Steel, which has a large mill in Butler, also registered impressive gains. Ampco-Pitt jumped $1.60 to $12 a share while AK Steel advanced 84 cents to $6.91.
The president-elect also promised to bring back coal and to trim regulations, which could explain why Consol Energy jumped 9 percent Wednesday to finish at $18.50, up $1.53.
A broad market advance wasn’t on the minds of investors who checked in with their advisers early Wednesday.
"We had clients this morning wanting to sell everything and go to cash," Mr. Leaman said. "As financial advisers, we talked them out of it.
“Then we had clients who were so overjoyed with Trump's win they wanted to buy everything in sight. We told them to wait and see how this thing shakes out. The thing about Trump is he's an unknown. He's pro-business, but anti-trade, which makes it hard to predict what impact he might have on the market."
Kim Forrest, a vice president and senior equity analyst at Fort Pitt Capital in Green Tree, said given the dramatic action in overnight trading, she had expected the markets to have a rocky day.
"In 17 years of doing this, I've seen people move between the poles of greed and fear pretty rapidly," Ms. Forrest said. "My dad had an expression he used on me often. It was, ‘Don't cry until you're hurt.’ It means you may anticipate bad things happening, but don't cry until it actually happens.
"We have to get a little more information on what President Trump looks like as opposed to candidate Trump," she said.
In a memo to his clients Wednesday morning, P.J. DiNuzzo, chief investment officer at DiNuzzo Index Advisers in Beaver, told his clients to stay calm, hold onto their current positions and focus on long term investing.
"It is helpful to remember that these market gyrations are almost always bad times to trade, and particularly to sell,” Mr. DiNuzzo said. "We have months before the new president takes office.
"Traders and analysts have plenty of time to settle down between now and the first 100 days of the Trump presidency, and evaluate whether America's corporations are, indeed, worth much less than they were before election night.
“The safest bet you can make is that they'll be unusually jumpy for the next four years. But in the end, the intrinsic value of stocks don't change with the occupant of the White House."
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591. Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.