The one silver lining that many people repaying student loan debt can look forward to this time of year is the chance to claim up to a $2,500 deduction on the interest they’ve paid on it.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t always work out for everyone.

“The problem is if your income is too high you don’t qualify for the deduction,” said Pittsburgh certified public accountant Howard Davis, president of Davis, Davis & Associates, Downtown. ”We have a lot of doctors and high-income earners who pay a lot more interest than $2,500 and they can’t deduct any interest. I guess the government is saying those people make enough income they can live without the deduction.”

That same logic may explain why student loan interest deductions are also not available for anyone who is married with a combined adjusted gross income of more than $160,000 or single people whose adjusted gross income is $80,000 or more.

Advertise with us

There are currently 43.3 million Americans with student debt, totaling $1.23 trillion, according to Student Loan Hero, an Internet-based company that works with borrowers to refinance and pay off their student debt.

While the government has been tweaking its efforts to keep student debt from being onerous for those who are in repayment mode, tax season is a reminder that some people will be able to get some of their money back, while others will come up empty-handed.

Mr. Davis pointed out that regardless of a person’s income, anyone who is married filing a separate tax return is not eligible for any deduction of their student loan interest payments.

The U.S. Department of Education in December rolled out its newest income-based college loan repayment program called the Revised Pay As You Earn Plan or REPAYE. Unlike the previous version only available to borrowers as of October 2007, the revised program expands the income-based repayment option to anyone with federal student loan debt.

REPAYE limits monthly student loan payments to 10 percent of discretionary income — the difference between a borrower’s adjusted gross income and 150 percent of the poverty level for his or her state and family size.

Advertise with us

But unlike other such income-based programs, it includes a borrower’s spouse’s income in the calculation, even if the husband and wife file taxes separately.

“Some people may think they can get a lower loan repayment if they file taxes separately from their spouse, but you can’t play that game with this program,” Mr. Davis said. “Nine times out of 10, married filing separately is more expensive than married filing jointly.

“I had a couple who filed their taxes jointly even though they were getting a divorce because it was cheaper to do it that way,” he said. ”They just have to figure out how to split up the refund.”

Income-based repayment is only available to borrowers who have federal loans. Private student loan lenders are less flexible on repayment options and usually charge higher interest rates on loans.

Research released Thursday by Citizens Bank showed that college graduates aged 35 and under with student loans are now spending nearly 18 percent of their salaries on student loan payments and that 60 percent expect to be paying off student loans into their 40s.

Advertise with us

“As this generation of college graduates starts to contemplate future life events like home purchases and retirement, it becomes increasingly important for them to take control of their college debt,” said Brendan Coughlin, president of consumer lending for Citizens Bank.

Some people who owe money for student loans will discover that the tax refund they thought was headed for their mailbox has instead been confiscated by the government to pay their student loan debt because they are in default.

Being in default on a student loan means the borrower has fallen behind by 270 days or more on payments.

The Department of Education can intercept a student loan borrower’s tax return through the offset program, which authorizes federal payments, such as tax refunds or Social Security income to be seized in whole or in part to satisfy debts owed to other federal agencies.

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.