The mad holiday shopping rush is over, but the waiting in line is about to ramp up again.

Too-tight suede boots, the wrong Lego Minecraft set and duplicate Star Wars Battlefront video games will be hustled and bustled back to stores or, in many cases, to the post office as imperfect gifts bought online make their way back to retailers’ warehouses.

According to the National Retail Federation, nearly 40 percent of consumers returned a holiday gift last season.

Some $70 billion in merchandise is expected to be returned this season, accounting for about one-quarter of returns annually, said logistics provider Optoro, based in Washington, D.C.

Advertise with us

Stores typically give refunds to shoppers holding receipts, while those without a receipt can expect store credit. Retailers generally limit returns to 30 to 60 days from the purchase date, although many offer special extended holiday return windows allowing gifts bought in November to be returned until mid- to late-January.

Oftentimes, stricter rules are imposed for returning opened goods and electronics such as computers and game consoles, which may have shorter return windows and restocking fees.

In short, to avoid hassles, shoppers should save receipts, avoid using the items and then take them back as soon as possible. Shoppers with gift receipts are often limited to exchanges or store credit.

Some stores are known for their better-than-average, or stingier-than-average, return policies.

The online shopping site Zappos is generally regarded as the gold standard for generous return policies, according to Benjamin Glaser, features editor with the deal-hunting website Dealnews.com. Zappos offers free return shipping and a full-year return window, he said.

Advertise with us

Others often mentioned in the top-tier include Nordstrom, Target, Macy’s, J.C. Penney, L.L. Bean, Costco, and Bed Bath and Beyond.

On the flip side, stores often categorized as having worse-than-average return policies include Kmart, Sears, Barnes & Noble and GameStop. In general, the worst policies offer a short window for returns — sometimes as short as two weeks — and only allow returns with a receipt, Mr. Glaser said.

When it comes to shopping online, experts say more retailers are providing free return shipping this year. In addition, most retailers allow merchandise purchased online to be returned to a brick-and-mortar store as long as the item isn’t an online-only item or an outlet brand.

Customers who miss the return window or fail to meet some other criteria may still be able to return an item by taking a few extra steps, Mr. Glaser said.

Asking to speak with a manager or getting in touch with the corporate office can help. “Always remain calm and be polite…and let them know you are disappointed with the service,” he said.

Advertise with us

“Acknowledge the unusual circumstances. You might reach someone who wants to keep you happy and keep your business even it it means bending the store policy a bit.”

Another option for people past the store’s return deadline is to check with their credit card issuer to see if they’re covered by a so-called return extension program. These programs allow card holders to return an item purchased with their card to the card issuer for credit.

To file a claim, card holders must have a receipt and pay the shipping charges. There also are limits to the price of the returnable item and other rules and restrictions, plus a number of exclusions to the coverage, such as artwork, consumable goods, jewelry and cell phones.

For people still left holding an unwanted item, there’s always the regifting option.

Just remember a few simple rules of regifting etiquette. First, don’t use the gift. Also, rewrap it and never give it back to the original gift-giver.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.