Santa’s not the only one keeping tabs on misbehavior this holiday season.
An annual scrutiny of well-known businesses released this week by Consumer Reports takes companies to task for annoying fees, shoddy procedures and sneaky marketing policies, while offering kudos to others for stand-up behavior.
The product comparison guru noted that its sixth annual “Naughty & Nice” list wasn’t meant to be a rebuke or endorsement of an overall company. Instead, companies were called out for specific policies or practices that Consumer Reports believes are particularly harmful or helpful to consumers.
Here’s a rundown of some of this year’s winners and losers:
THE NAUGHTY
Allegiant Air. Noting that few industries rile customers more than airlines for their nickel-and-diming practices, Consumer Reports said it still couldn’t help but notice Las Vegas-based discount carrier Allegiant Air’s long list of extra fees. Among them: a processing fee of up to $8 for credit card purchases; a $13 “electronic carrier usage charge” for tickets bought outside of an airport ticket office; a $15 fee for tickets booked through the call center; up to $80 for a seat assignment; $15 to $35 for checked bags if paid in advance, rising to $50 to $75 if paid at the airport; plus $15 to $20 for carry-ons paid in advance, jumping to $45 at the airport.
The airline defended the fees, saying that by “unbundling” fares, passengers get to choose what they pay for instead of paying for services they don’t use. “The average price paid on Allegiant is still significantly lower than the average domestic one-way fare,” the airline said in an email.
Citizens Bank. The second largest retail bank in the Pittsburgh region, Rhode Island-based Citizens in August agreed to pay at least $35 million in penalties and refunds for systematically cheating customers out of their deposits. According to regulators, Citizens ignored discrepancies between deposit slips and actual deposits if the difference fell below a certain amount, sometimes by as much as $50.
Citizens, which also agreed to change the practice, has noted that in addition to under-crediting deposits, the faulty policy often worked in the customer’s favor.
Volkswagen. In a stunning act of cheating, the German automaker was caught installing software on diesel vehicles sold in the U.S. that enabled them to pass emissions tests while exceeding pollution limits. Investigations continue.
“Volkswagen is committed to finding a remedy as soon as possible,” the automaker said in an email this week.
LifeLock. The Federal Trade Commission has accused the Arizona-based I.D. theft protection company of violating a 2010 settlement that barred it from making deceptive claims about its services. The agency also said LifeLock failed to take steps required to protect the personal information it collects from its customers. “It is essential that companies live up to their obligations under orders obtained by the FTC,” the agency said in July. In October, LifeLock announced a tentative, undisclosed settlement with the FTC involving “past marketing representations and information security programs.”
THE NICE
Southwest Airlines. The low-cost carrier won praise for “providing the most frequent-flier award program trips of any big airline” based on an analysis by Consumer Reports for the fiscal year ended Sept. 30, 2014. “The Dallas-based carrier also did some Texas-sized butt-kicking of rivals by providing the highest percentage of award-seat availability on 72 percent of the 25 most popular U.S. award routes,” Consumer Reports said.
Dish Network. The pay television service unveiled an online appointment tool called “My Tech” that allows consumers to receive personalized information about their service appointment, including the name and photo of the technician and the technician’s proximity to the home. A countdown and interactive map allow customers to track technicians “to determine when to leave work or if they have time to run to the store,” according to Dish.
Nomorobo. The winner of a Federal Trade Commission contest, the cloud-based app is designed to help Americans who have signed up for the federal Do-not-call list but continue to be hounded by automated telemarketing calls known as robocalls. The system, which analyzes caller IDs and automatically disconnects suspicious calls, is free and available to many consumers who use Internet-based VoIP service. The goal is to eventually include Nomorobo into all phone lines.
Target. The retailer was cited for enacting several consumer-friendly policies, such as expanding its price-match policy to include all major in-store and online competitors — including giants Amazon and Walmart — plus doubling the time-frame for a price adjustment to 14 days. The Minneapolis-based chain also lowered the purchase minimum from $50 to $25 required for free year-round shipping on online orders.
For the complete list and analysis, visit www.consumerreports.org/consumer-protection/naughty-and-nice-2015.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.