Shortly after Earl and Dora Zissner decided to invest in an obscure corner of the insurance industry in which people who need to raise money sell their life insurance policies at a discount to investors who will reap a profit when they die, the Glenshaw couple received confirmation that their purchase was complete.
“I am pleased to inform you that we have concluded the purchase of the [insured’s name] policy on your behalf ...,” said the letter dated June 16, 2000, from Life Partners Inc. “As soon as we are notified of the demise of [insured’s name], the escrow agent, Sterling Trust Co., will make application for the payment of the death benefit.
“According to our records, your policy funding deposit for this policy was $12,000. You are entitled to 31.57895 percent of the death benefit paid under this policy,” the letter continued.
The insured person in this case died within three months of the Zissners making the investment, with two other people who shared a slice of the $50,000 policy face value.
The Zissners purchased three more life insurance policies for $28,000 when their investment adviser suggested they diversify their stock and mutual fund portfolio with life settlement investments.
“It did make me feel a bit uncomfortable in the beginning,” said Mr. Zissner, 87. “I don’t want to see anybody die.” He said his adviser said those insured were very sick and needed the money from policies because they weren’t expected to live long.
The second policy, which cost them $11,600, took three years to pay off and yielded a much lower return. They are still losing money on the last two policies, which they bought for $16,400, because the insured have not died.
There is little transparency in the life settlements market compared to the regulatory oversight that stock and bond offers are subject to. But investors are seduced by the promise of receiving a higher rate of return.
The return depends on the insured’s life expectancy and the date of the insured’s death. If the insured dies before his or her estimated life expectancy, the investor may receive a higher return. If the insured lives longer than expected, the return will be lower.
Clients claim confusion
Spurred by the growth in life settlement sales, the SEC created a special task force in the early 2000s to consider how federal securities law applies to life settlements and created guidelines for trading them as securities.
According to Carolyn Morris, director of the bureau of consumer services at the Pennsylvania Insurance Department, the department has received 45 complaints on unsatisfactory life insurance settlements from 2008 to 2014.
“For life settlement complaints, the department plays a liaison role,” she said. “We help connect the consumer with the area they need to contact in the company so they may reach the person responsible for settling the issue.”
The nature of complaints filed ranges from investments not being suitable; clients didn’t understand what they were getting into; clients were led to believe they would collect on the investments within two to three years; and clients were saddled with paying premiums to keep the policies in force.
Pension fund investments
In recent years, managers of several pension funds, including in Allegheny and Westmoreland counties, have decided to reduce their funds’ exposure to stock market volatility by investing a portion of their funds in life settlements.
The Retirement Board of Allegheny County in December 2008 approved investing $5 million in life settlements through Corry Capital Advisors. Since then, the retirement board increased its investment to $33 million. The Westmoreland County Employees’ Retirement System also voted in August 2008 to invest $8.9 million in a portfolio of life settlement policies through the New York firm. That investment has increased to $16 million over the past seven years.
Timothy Johnson, executive director of the Retirement Board of Allegheny County, said the total retirement fund as of June 30, is worth $844 million. Life settlements represent about 4 percent of the total fund, and over a six-year period since 2009 has yielded a per annum return — net of fees — of 14.83 percent.
“We look at life settlements as an alternative investment,” Mr. Johnson said, adding that the county retirement fund also has made other alternative investments. “In order to get a greater return, you have to take greater risks than you would with stocks and bonds.”
Westmoreland County Controller Jeff Balzer said the county’s life settlements investments have appreciated 6.7 percent as of the second quarter of this year.
Miscalculating the odds
In the Zissners’ case, either the life expectancy of two people was miscalculated or they have beaten the odds. Now the Zissners must pay additional premiums to keep the life insurance policies in force. The alternative is to let the policies lapse and lose the entire investment.
“With the life settlements, the company was supposed to have money in escrow to pay the insurance policies as they went along,” Mr. Zissner said. “After so many years, they told me that the money was gone.”
Mr. Zissner’s main concern now is whether he will ever get the $16,400 back that he invested on the last two policies and how the bankruptcy of the company, based in Waco, Texas, could complicate his payout. Life Partners, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in January.
Company representatives at Life Partners declined to comment for this report. The bankruptcy trustee could not be reached for comment.
Pittsburgh-based bankruptcy attorney Matt Herron of the Debt Doctors at Quatrini Rafferty, Downtown, is not involved in the case; however, he reviewed the court documents and provided clarity on the bankruptcy process. He said when Life Partners filed for bankruptcy protection, a trustee was appointed.
Life Partners operated under two companies. The first, Life Partners Holding Inc., filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy in January. The second, Life Partners Financial Services Inc., filed for bankruptcy protection in May. The move was prompted when the company came under investigation by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission for filing false and misleading statements. The SEC case resulted in a $46 million judgement against the company.
The Zissners’ financial adviser, Jay Adams at SagePoint in Oakmont, was fined $11,500 by FINRA in 2005, which found he had improperly sold life settlements through Life Partners to Pennsylvania residents from March 1998 through December 2000. Among the allegations were that he had failed to get authorization before selling the life settlements.
A separate case in which a client alleged a life settlement policy was an unsuitable investment was settled for $32,000 in February 2014. A broker statement in the FINRA file for Mr. Adams states, “This matter was settled by SagePoint Financial solely to avoid the cost and uncertainty of arbitration. I did not contribute to this settlement.”
Mr. Adams did not return calls seeking comment.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.