Over the past decade, lawyers in Pennsylvania have gotten into trouble with the state's disciplinary board for offenses spanning from ripping off clients and being disrespectful to judges to arson, assault and even homicide.

But the No. 1 cause of the hammer — or gavel — coming down on misbehaving lawyers is plain old lousy lawyering.

A review by The Legal Intelligencer of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's disciplinary board records from 2006 to 2016 reveals that attorneys who are ineffective at practicing law — most commonly by neglecting cases, not communicating with clients, and general incompetence — made up the largest portion of those punished in nearly 640 instances, at 32 percent.

A close runner-up was unauthorized practice of law, which made up 15 percent, followed by mishandling client money at 13 percent, which includes stealing from estates, misappropriating trust money or other misconduct involving client funds.

Advertise with us

Instances of misconduct were spread evenly throughout the years, and there were no discernible chronological trends. Instances of financial crime and misuse of client funds also didn't spike during the recession.

While ineffective lawyering was the most prevalent offense, misuse of client funds is considered the most serious offense, according to Julia Frankston-Morris, secretary of the disciplinary board.

"The board and the court have taken a very close interest in theft of client funds," she said.

That comports with the review of the records, which shows misusing client money had the highest rate of disbarment, at 29 percent, out of the top three offenses, including ineffective lawyering and unauthorized practice of law.

Punishment for any given offense can range from private reprimands and probation to suspensions and disbarment. Suspensions of a year and a day or more — the most common punishment — require lawyers to apply for reinstatement, whereas lesser suspensions don't. Suspensions can range from a period of months to a maximum of five years, depending on the severity of the case.

Advertise with us

Like the state's other professional boards — including medicine, real estate and accounting — the disciplinary board is reactive and relies on complaints to find misbehaving lawyers.

But some states, like New Jersey, perform random compliance audits, which are especially effective at catching attorneys practicing without a license.

That's not in Pennsylvania's immediate future due to limited resources, according to Ms. Frankston-Morris. "Random compliance audits are very costly. It really requires intense staffing," she said.

However, Ms. Frankston-Morris said there are some proactive measures the board has undertaken to address attorney misconduct. That includes disseminating compliance literature to law schools and sending brochures to vulnerable populations like the elderly to educate people on how to avoid getting scammed by a bad lawyer.

Legal ethics expert Michael Hayes of Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads in Philadelphia said attorneys could use more compliance education as well.

Advertise with us

"We have one hour of ethics training every year," he said. "Well, maybe there should be something there to educate us on the pitfalls of shoddy lawyering."

Most of the lawyers who get into trouble for neglecting cases or failing to communicate with clients are solo practitioners or smaller-firm lawyers who are overwhelmed, according to Sam Stretton, who has represented Pennsylvania lawyers in disciplinary cases for nearly 40 years.

"Many times these lawyers are overextended, they're handling a massive case load," he said.

Mr. Hayes said that stress can play a part in contributing to some of the offenses. He suggested that law schools should devote more time to teaching future lawyers how to handle the stresses of operating their own practices as well as time management.

Simple oversights can also result in charges for unauthorized practice, according to Mr. Stretton. Sometimes lawyers forget to stay current with continuing legal education or pay annual fees required for maintaining a license.

Advertise with us

P.J. D'Annunzio can be contacted at 215-557-2315 or pdannunzio@alm.com. Follow him on Twitter @PJDannunzioTLI. To read more articles like this, visit thelegalintelligencer.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.