Former H.J. Heinz chairman and CEO Anthony J.F. O’Reilly’s descent into bankruptcy jeopardizes the claims of his ex-nurse, who alleges that Business Week magazine’s former highest-paid CEO reneged on a promise to give her more than $50 million in shares of the Pittsburgh food company and another company as compensation.
Sabina Vidunas, who has a home in Churchill, alleges Mr. O’Reilly promised her 343,000 shares of Heinz stock and 2.5 million shares of Providence Resources stock after he hired her as his personal nurse in 1995.
In a lawsuit filed in federal court in Pittsburgh three years ago, Ms. Vidunas alleged her job description eventually included duties that were “unsavory” and “repugnant.” Ms. Vidunas performed them anyway because of the pay and benefits Mr. O’Reilly promised, according to court papers.
Debts that Mr. O’Reilly accumulated through faltering investments in Waterford Wedgwood crystal and publishing prompted a court in the Bahamas to declare him bankrupt last year. Such a decision normally would freeze litigation against Mr. O’Reilly in other courts as a court-appointed bankruptcy trustee seeks to preserve the debtor’s assets in order to pay creditors.
The trustee of Mr. O’Reilly’s bankruptcy hasn’t asked that Ms. Vidunas’ be case halted. But U.S. District Court Judge Joy Flowers Conti this month put it on hold pending further developments in the Bahamas.
“The bankruptcy pretty much froze everything,” said Joel Sansone, one of the Pittsburgh attorneys representing Ms. Vidunas.
The trustee has indicated that he wants a home in the Bahamas Ms. Vidunas said she bought with $1.4 million Mr. O’Reilly gave her to be available to Mr. O’Reilly’s creditors, Mr. Sansone said.
Kevin Lucas, the Pittsburgh attorney representing Mr. O’Reilly, declined comment. In court filings, he said Ms. Vidunas’ vague allegations “are contrived and preposterous on their face” and that Mr. O’Reilly never promised her the stock.
The case pits Mr. O’Reilly, a former Irish rugby star who became one of Pittsburgh’s highest-profile CEOs during his 19-year tenure at Heinz, against Ms. Vidunas, who was hired by Heinz around 1990 as an employee wellness consultant. Her duties included health screening, conducting wellness programs and on-site message therapy, according to an affidavit Ms. Vidunas filed with the court.
According to the lawsuit that Ms. Vidunas filed in 2013, Mr. O’Reilly hired her around December 1995 as his personal nurse after he became seriously ill in Ireland.
Her duties were to see to his daily health needs, including giving him medication and arranging health care for him when he traveled. Her duties later expanded to scheduling appointments, making business and personal travel arrangements, and unspecified tasks the lawsuit refers to as “unsavory” and “repugnant.”
At first, there was no contract formalizing her work. Ms. Vidunas said she received housing, meals, expenses and a small salary the first two years, according to court papers.
When she asked for a more formal arrangement in 1997, Mr. O’Reilly promised to put 200,000 Heinz shares into a retirement trust he controlled as well as a year-end bonus of 5,000 additional shares, the lawsuit alleges.
In subsequent years, the lawsuit claims, he promised her: more Heinz stock; set her annual salary at $200,000 in 1999; purchased the home in the Bahamas on her behalf around 2005; and in the same year promised to give her 500,000 shares of Providence Resources annually for as long as she continued working for him, court papers state.
Providence Resources is an Irish oil and gas exploration company whose CEO is Mr. O’Reilly’s son, Tony.
The 343,000 Heinz shares Ms. Vidunas claims Mr. O’Reilly promised her would have been worth $24.9 million when Brazilian investors and Warren Buffett acquired Heinz in 2013. The Providence Resources shares have a current market value of about $31 million.
Ms. Vidunas said she continued working for Mr. O’Reilly after he stepped down as CEO in 1998, traveling with him for about seven or eight months a year, according to her affidavit.
The former nurse said she received none of the shares she was promised when she was discharged in 2011. She also claims Mr. O’Reilly paid her a reduced salary of $150,000 from 2001 through 2007 and substantially less in subsequent years, including nothing in 2010.
Court documents do not provide the whole story. A second amended version of Ms. Vidunas’ lawsuit was filed under seal in December 2014 and certain other documents filed with the court have been redacted.
Mr. O’Reilly has tried to have the lawsuit dismissed several times. Judge Conti dismissed Ms. Vidunas’ claims that Mr. O’Reilly breached his fiduciary duty and violated state wage law in 2014. But the judge let Ms. Vidunas’ breach of contract claim stand.
In a September 2015 court filing, Mr. O’Reilly’s attorneys said Ms. Vidunas confirmed that she had been paid in full as of July 2001. After that date, she was paid more than $1.1 million for her services, plus expenses, meals, and lodging, through September 2009, when her services ended. Mr. O’Reilly never promised her the stock, the filing states.
The filing stated that Mr. O’Reilly loaned Ms. Vidunas $1.4 million in 2005 so that she could buy the house in the Bahamas. His former nurse was to get a mortgage on the home to repay Mr. O’Reilly, his lawyers stated. The court papers indicated Ms. Vidunas did not make any loan payments and Mr. O’Reilly is demanding that she repay the loan.
Just how Mr. O’Reilly’s bankruptcy affects Ms. Vidunas’ claims depends in large part on how the trustee handling the bankruptcy looks at the case, said Matthew Heimann, a bankruptcy attorney in the Newark, N.J. office of McCarter & English, which has no involvement in the case.
He said the trustee could ask that the Pittsburgh case be halted to protect assets of Mr. O’Reilly that could be used to satisfy his creditors. The trustee probably will look at whatever land or mortgage documents are available to determine how Ms. Vidunas acquired the Bahamian home. Depending on how the deal was documented and structured, the trustee could try to overturn the transaction, Mr. Heimann said.
The trustee will have to investigate the allegations and transactions, including seeking a formal statement from Ms. Vidunas or deposing her, to determine whether she has a claim against Mr. Reilly’s bankruptcy estate or whether the ex-CEO’s bankruptcy estate has a claim against her, Mr. Heimann said.
Mr. Sansone, representing Ms. Vidunas, said a number of factors have delayed her case: difficulties in serving Mr. O’Reilly in France, where he lives; the bankruptcy; and Mr. O’Reilly’s claim that he is too ill to be questioned in a deposition. When asked what’s wrong with the former CEO, Mr. Sansone responded: “litigationitis.”
As part of her decision to halt the case for the time being, Judge Conti ordered Mr. O’Reilly’s attorneys to update Ms. Vidunas’ lawyers every 60 days about Mr. O’Reilly’s health and his ability to be deposed.
In the meantime, Ms. Vidunas is taking measures to ensure that Mr. O’Reilly’s creditors keep their hands off her home in the Bahamas.
“I believe she is currently interviewing lawyers down there,” Mr. Sansone said.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.