A recent U.S. Department of Labor report raised the possibility of federal oversight of state workers’ compensation programs, leaving employers concerned about the potential complications of increased regulation.
The report said a federal role in workers’ compensation “should be explored.” It suggested possible actions, including the establishment of minimum standards for states, federal tracking of changes to state programs, the commission of a national study on workers’ compensation systems, and the dissemination of “best practices.” The report also proposed an “expanded research agenda” covering benefits, access to care and the labor market experience of injured workers.
The review was prompted by a letter sent last October by 10 Democratic members of Congress concerned about “a pattern of detrimental changes” to state laws that they said have shifted costs to public programs such as Social Security disability.
Gene Barr, president of the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry, called the Labor Department report troubling and said it represents “another threat of federal overreach.” He said he hears often from employers about the state’s “burdensome” workers’ compensation system, and he fears federal involvement would only make operating in the state more difficult.
Defense attorney Anthony Salvino of White and Williams said federal oversight would create a “regulatory nightmare” for employers and insurance carriers. He acknowledged the Labor Department’s good intentions but said federal intervention would increase costs for everyone involved in workers’ compensation and wouldn’t ultimately deliver benefits to employers.
“If you overregulate the system, it creates logjams and the injured workers may not get their benefits as soon as possible,” Mr. Salvino said.
Geoffrey Dlin of Krasno, Krasno & Onwudinjo, a former workers’ compensation judge who now represents claimants, registered his own skepticism of the federal government’s role. If minimum federal guidelines are introduced, he said, any states with regulatory schemes favorable to injured workers will find ways to “dumb themselves down” to meet, but not surpass, the minimum standards.
“It could bring some rights up [for workers], it could diminish rights elsewhere. That’s a huge risk,” Mr. Dlin said. “Be careful what you wish for.”
The Labor Department report suggested that federal regulators might step into the fray in response to changes in numerous states that have limited benefits, reduced the likelihood of obtaining them and discouraged injured workers from applying for them.
“Some state legislatures continue to attempt to reduce workers’ compensation costs, and proposals for statutory amendments that restrict workers’ benefits or access have become increasingly bold,” the Labor Department report said.
The report did find some support in the workers’ compensation bar. Claimants attorney Samuel Pond of Pond Lehocky Stern Giordano said federal involvement is “a long time coming” in a system that has totally unbalanced the bargain made by workers who gave up their right to sue when injured on the job in exchange for workers’ compensation.
“Something drastic is needed,” Mr. Pond said.
If federal intervention established medical coverage and indemnity benefits, as well as punitive damages for “bad actors,” Mr. Pond said he would welcome it.
Defense attorneys said such requirements would take away states’ ability to establish a system that works best within their borders.
Pennsylvania’s workers’ compensation scheme has a section dealing with black lung because of the state’s history of coal mining, for instance, said Jeffrey Laudenbach of German, Gallagher & Murtagh.
“I understand what the Department of Labor wants to do — either ease access to benefits or raise the floor,” he said. “But I’m not so sure it’s so easy to do.”
Ben Seal: bseal@alm.com. On Twitter: @BSealTLI. To read more articles like this, visit www.thelegalintelligencer.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.