As federal regulators prepare to issue guidelines on autonomous vehicles, plaintiffs attorneys and consumer-safety groups are concerned about confusion and potential harm that could arise from the lack of federal standards.

Mark Rosekind, head of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, said at an automotive conference in June that federal guidelines would be released last month dealing with issues that include deployment and operational guidance, uniform state policies, exemptions, and new tools to make technology available more quickly. As observers wait for those guidelines, they’re anticipating chaos.

“The NHTSA seems to have been asleep at the wheel,” said Larry Coben of Anapol Weiss.

Without federal regulation, each state will chart its own course on driverless vehicles, crash-avoidance technology and the range of innovations already finding their way onto America’s roads. The buffet of state laws will create a mess for all parties, Mr. Coben said.

Advertise with us

Nine states and the District of Columbia have some form of legislation, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Pennsylvania established the Autonomous Vehicles Testing Policy Task Force in June to make recommendations to the state Department of Transportation for drafting regulations. The state has not yet passed any legislation, although there are bills pending in committees of the state Senate and House of Representatives.

Clarence Ditlow, executive director of the Center for Auto Safety in Washington, D.C., said the feds are making a “terrible mistake” by not issuing safety regulations. Without a regulatory framework in place as technology advances and more features make their way onto highways, consumers will be used as guinea pigs, he said.

NHTSA is leaving the door open for companies to use loopholes to put potentially unsafe vehicles on the road, Mr. Ditlow said.

Mr. Ditlow said he expects corners of the auto industry to slow down the rollout of certain features that could bring added safety to drivers, out of the fear of not knowing the regulatory scheme. Both the auto and insurance industries want certainty that can only be delivered by a federal framework, he said.

“Voluntary guidelines don’t give you certainty, and at worst they give you a patchwork quilt of state regulations,” Mr. Ditlow said.

Advertise with us

Plaintiffs attorney Jaime Jackson of Atlee Hall said a “hodgepodge” of state laws would be inconsistent and difficult to enforce. If neighboring states have different statutory schemes, drivers crossing borders could face complications if they get into car crashes, he noted.

“It can create a lot of potential for chaos — even for the manufacturers,” Mr. Jackson said.

Mr. Coben and Mr. Ditlow both drew comparisons to the 1960s, prior to formation of the NHTSA. One of the primary factors motivating the agency’s creation was the variety of state regulations developing to govern safety standards. The auto industry felt it could meet a tough federal standard, but not a disparate group of state laws, Mr. Ditlow said.

The best approach for everyone involved would be the development of minimum safety standards governing autonomous vehicles and crash-avoidance technology, Mr. Jackson said. Mr. Coben made the same point in a July 1 letter to Paul Hemmersbaugh, chief counsel for the NHTSA, after a meeting earlier this summer on the issue.

Publishing “bridge guidelines,” he said, could create “national confusion.” Writing on behalf of the American Association for Justice and the Attorneys Information Exchange Group, Mr. Coben said the guidelines could jeopardize Congress’ intent to establish uniform safety regulations. He urged the agency to follow the course it took with the introduction of electronic stability control, the first automated technology for accident avoidance. Mr. Coben said he received no response.

Advertise with us

In a separate letter sent July 20 to Secretary of Transportation Anthony Foxx on behalf of the AIEG, Mr. Coben expressed concern that states could try to enhance legal immunity for manufacturers. In a response, an NHTSA administrator said the agency will encourage states to adopt its model policy for autonomous 
vehicles.

Mr. Coben said states are less equipped than the NHTSA to issue regulations. And if federal regulators aren’t ready to enact a framework now, there’s no reason to think it will happen anytime soon. Mr. Coben said he was told by NHTSA counsel that it would be at least five years before the agency promulgated regulations on any subject related to autonomous vehicles.

“If the government hasn’t been studying this issue intensely for the last five years,” Mr. Coben said, “then it’s way behind the 8-ball.”

Ben Seal: 215-557-2368 or bseal@alm.com. On Twitter @BSealTLI. To read more articles like this, visit www.thelegalintelligencer.com.